Advertisement
  1. Florida Politics
  2. /
  3. The Buzz

Pennsylvania GOP lawmaker seems to suggest students calling for gun control are not students at all

The controversy comes a day after a Florida legislative aide lost his job for a similar post.
Students from Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, where 17 people were killed in a mass shooting last week, on a bus bound for Tallahassee, in Coral Springs, Fla., Feb. 20, 2018. As the students traveled to the Capitol to call for a ban on assault rifles, the Florida House rejected a motion to take up a bill that would do that, by a 36 to 71 vote along party lines. [Saul Martinez  |  The New York Times]
Students from Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, where 17 people were killed in a mass shooting last week, on a bus bound for Tallahassee, in Coral Springs, Fla., Feb. 20, 2018. As the students traveled to the Capitol to call for a ban on assault rifles, the Florida House rejected a motion to take up a bill that would do that, by a 36 to 71 vote along party lines. [Saul Martinez | The New York Times]
Published Feb. 21, 2018

As students were making their way to Florida's Capitol in Tallahassee Wednesday morning to demand gun law reforms, a Republican lawmaker from a few states away wrote a Facebook post that appeared to question whether the teenage protesters were, in fact, students.

Pennsylvania state Rep. Daryl Metcalfe's comments came as some right-wing media figures have attacked the credibility of a handful of students who have become the most vocal advocates for gun control since a lone gunman killed 17 people at their high school in Parkland, Florida.

Read More: Florida lawmaker's aide fired after saying outspoken Parkland students are actors

Metcalfe, who once snapped at a male colleague for touching his arm during a meeting, notably used quotation marks twice when he referred to the students and cited his military experience as he argued about gun control.

Metcalfe wrote on Twitter: "I enlisted in the U.S. Army at 17 years old. This morning I was working out and listening to the news about 'students' being bused in to the Florida Capitol. The hypocrisy of the left struck me! They expect lawmakers to listen to the policy advice of 18 year old and younger "students" who are advocating for gun control, but they do not believe 18 year olds who are old enough to serve on the battlefields of Afghanistan are old enough to purchase a rifle."

A spokeswoman for Metcalfe said she can't speak for him when asked about the Facebook post. Metcalfe was not immediately available for comment. The Pennsylvania GOP and the office of Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf, D, have not responded to requests for comment.

Metcalfe's comments were condemned on Facebook, where users immediately took notice of his use of quotation marks.

"What are you saying about these kids who were lucky enough to walk through blood and past corpses of friends slaughtered by an AR15? Please remove the quotation marks and be specific," one commenter wrote.

"Anyone begrudging or mocking (which is what you are doing) these young people and their right to protest and be heard after going through such a horrific experience doesn't understand what being an American is all about," another one wrote.

Read More: Parkland survivor David Hogg on conspiracy theories: 'It's sad'

Perhaps Metcalfe's fellow Pennsylvania state lawmaker, Rep. Brian Sims, a Democrat, is the harshest of them all.

"Every time you step up to prove that you're even more of an ignorant monster, you hit it right out of the park," Sims wrote in reply to Metcalfe's post. "Attacking the students of Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School for taking their advocacy to a state Capitol is one of the most twisted, ghoulish things that you've done in a career marked by intense bigotry, discrimination, and divisiveness."

The students who rallied in Tallahassee have become the loud and sympathetic voices for gun law reforms. A handful of them have made impassioned comments on national news networks. But their newly found platform and activism have made them a target of right-wing smears and conspiracies, while the more mainstream voices resort to calling them naive victims driven by emotion.

Some prominent figures in the right-wing media have suggested that the students are making it all up, or that the children are paid actors or that their talking points have been manufactured by public relations experts on the left, The Washington Post has written in another report.

On Tuesday, an aide to a Florida legislator was fired after he falsely claimed that two survivors of the shooting were "actors that travel to various crisis when they happen." In a tweet Wednesday, David Clarke, the controversial former sheriff of Milwaukee County, suggested that Democratic billionaire George Soros was behind the "well ORGANIZED effort by Florida school students demanding gun control."

One article published by Gateway Pundit claimed that one of the students, 17-year-old David Hogg, was being coached to peddle anti-gun rhetoric and that he was a pawn by the FBI (Hogg has said that his father is a retired FBI agent). That article features a picture of Hogg with the word "EXPOSED" stamped on his forehead. The president's son Donald Trump Jr. on Tuesday liked a tweet linking to the article.

The students, though, have presented a unique adversary to their detractors. They have shown a willingness to fire back – publicly. And as The Washington Post wrote, it is much more difficult for right-wing detractors to assail student survivors with "the kind of full-throated personal attack they're used to."

Read More: Why is this still happening? Douglas High students press Florida leaders for answers

"Actually for me the worst news I got was that 17 people died in my school. One of my best friends was shot twice. And many more were injured. But sure keep making us look like we don't know anything when in reality what we're doing is much much much bigger than you can imagine," Sarah Chadwick wrote.

Responding to the innuendo, Hogg told CNN's Anderson Cooper that he is "not a crisis actor."

"The fact that some of the students at Stoneman Douglas high school . . . are showing more maturity and political action than many of our elected officials is a testament to how disgusting and broken our political system is right now in America. But we're trying to fix that," said Hogg, a student journalist who interviewed classmates as the massacre was happening – and while they were hiding inside a small room.

Some conservative legislators have come to the students' defense. Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., said in a tweet Tuesday that claiming the students are actors "is the work of a disgusting group of idiots with no sense of decency."

Florida state Rep. Shawn Harrison, quickly distanced himself from the aide who claimed two of the survivors are actors.

The Valentine's Day massacre has since prompted urgent calls for gun-control legislation. By Tuesday, President Donald Trump was signaling an openness to some modest measures, such as raising the minimum age at which a person could buy a semiautomatic weapon from 18 to 21.

Police say Nikolas Cruz, a 19-year-old former student with a history of depression and mental health problems, used an AR-15 when he shot down the school. On social media, Twitter users who say they're veterans have used the hashtag #VetsForGunReform as they question whether high-capacity rifles should be used anywhere other than in a war zone.

Metcalfe was criticized last December after he interrupted a committee meeting because a male colleague sitting next to him, Pennsylvania state Rep. Matt Bradford, touched his forearm for a few seconds.

"Look, I'm a heterosexual. I have a wife, I love my wife, I don't like men – as you might. But stop touching me all the time," Metcalfe, a staunch opponent of same-sex marriage, told Bradford. "Keep your hands to yourself. If you want to touch somebody, you have people on your side of the aisle who might like it. I don't.

Bradford, a Democrat, began laughing while the other people in the meeting giggled and smirked.

Wolf, Pennsylvania's Democratic governor, said Metcalfe's comment to Bradford was part of "a disturbing pattern" and urged Republican House leaders to re-examine whether Metcalfe should continue heading a committee that oversees civil rights legislation.

Metcalfe said Wolfe attacked him because of his criticisms of the governor, according to Philly.com.