1. Florida Politics
  2. /
  3. The Buzz

Andrew Gillum voted for a coal plant, but attacks Gwen Graham’s oil pipeline vote

As a city commissioner, Gillum eventually turned against a controversial coal plant proposal for north Florida
File photo of gubernatorial candidate Andrew Gillum.
File photo of gubernatorial candidate Andrew Gillum.
Published May 4, 2018

Democratic gubernatorial candidate Andrew Gillum often tells liberal Democrats that they should take a close look at the congressional voting record for fellow Tallahassee resident Gwen Graham.

"You can measure for yourself," Gillum said Monday during a Miami-based podcast.

" (You) have one candidate who is running who, during her term in Congress, during the first year of her two years of total service, voted against President Obama 52% of the time. She's running for the Democratic nomination. She voted for the Keystone pipeline, voted to weaken Dodd-Frank, an important consumer protection, voted to weaken Obamacare – Obama required employers provide healthcare for their employees after thirty hours a week of work."

Gillum, however, has a vote on his record that could give environmentalists at least as much pause as Graham's Keystone vote: As a Tallahassee city commissioner in 2005 he voted for Tallahassee to join a group of cities and public utilities to build a $1.5 billion coal-fired power plant in north Florida.

The 4-1 vote committed the city to spending up to $6.4million to secure its spot in the controversial project. Amid citizen opposition, Gillum suggested it go a referendum for Tallahassee residents to sign off.

Then-commissioner Allan Katz, a top Democratic fundraiser, voted against it, saying the city should explore non-coal alternatives and doubting the city would back away once it started spending money for the coal plant. From the Tallahassee Democrat:

"I would not vote for this plant if it were in Leon County," he said over a chorus of cheers and applause. "I think that for me, there are certain points along the way when you look up and you say, 'I can't do this because it's not right.'"

Voters approved the project, thanks in part to a public relations firm the city hired to promote the project, but Gillum eventually turned against it. The city wound up spending about $2.7 million pursuing the coal plant that would never be built.

The Gillum campaign brushed off the significance of a 13-year-old vote and took the opportunity to attack Graham again on her Keystone vote.

"Clean energy technology has improved, as evidenced by Tallahassee's new 120-acre solar farm that Mayor Gillum opened last year, and we have better ways to power our lives than coal or the Keystone XL Pipeline, which Gwen Graham voted for over President Obama's objections," said Gillum spokesman Geoff Burgan.

The Graham campaign responded:

"It seems the Gillum campaign still owes Florida Democrats an explanation when it comes to Mayor Gillum's support for building a coal plant in Florida," said spokesman Matt Harringer. "Gwen Graham is transparent and detailed whenever asked about her record on energy issues, and, in Congress, was a proud supporter of President Obama's bold Clean Power Plan to eliminate coal plants and reduce pollution — a fact the Gillum campaign is well aware of, though it obviously doesn't fit very neatly into their increasingly negative campaign."


  1. IndyCar driver Oliver Askew poses for photos during IndyCar Media Day Auto Racing, Monday, Feb. 10, 2020, in Austin, Texas. (AP Photo/Eric Gay)
  2. María José Chapa hace un gesto durante una entrevista después de abrir oficialmente la primera oficina local de la Federación Hispana en Davenport, Florida. En un condado del centro de Florida, enclavado entre Orlando y Tampa, la población de votantes hispanos registrados está en auge y los puertorriqueños están impulsando el aumento. Foto: AP
  3. The XFL begins its 10-week regular season Feb. 8, one week after the NFL's Super Bowl.
  4. Pinellas County School Board member Carol Cook, left, celebrates her reelection to her fifth term in 2016. If ultimately approved, a term limits proposal would force Florida's school board members out after two consecutive terms.
  5. Emilia Sargent of Tampa Repertory Theatre.
  6. Columbus left wing Artemi Panarin (9) and Columbus Blue Jackets center Matt Duchene (95) celebrate in front of the Lightning bench during the Blue Jackets' first-round victory over Tampa Bay in the first round of the 2019 NHL Playoffs. The four-game sweep was Columbus' payoff for a few deals at the trade deadline for players with expiring contracts.
  7. Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones, left, and his son Stephen Jones, the team's executive vice president, leave after NFL owners meet to discuss a proposed labor agreement, Thursday Feb. 20, 2020, in New York. (AP Photo/Bebeto Matthews)
  8. Finishing at, or near, the bottom of MLB in attendance isn't even the biggest problem for the Rays. It's the huge gap between where the Rays are in attendance compared to the average team. Tampa Bay is roughly 92 percent below just an average MLB crowd. [Times files (2017)]
  9. Vegas Golden Knights center Paul Stastny (26) scores against Tampa Bay Lightning goalie Andrei Vasilevskiy (88) during the second period of an NHL hockey game Thursday, Feb. 20, 2020, in Las Vegas.
  10. Vipers' Quinton Flowers (9) said it's been difficult to get into a rhythm with quarterbacks moving in and out. Is that why the Vipers have struggled in the red zone so much?
  11. The Knicks' Kevin Knox looks to pass as two Suns players defend him during the first half in a game on Jan. 16, 2020.