1. Florida Politics
  2. /
  3. The Buzz

Lawsuit filed (again) over Gov. Scott appointing justices to state supreme court

The three upcoming vacancies on the court have the potential to transform its ideological makeup.
Rick Scott [MONICA HERNDON | Tampa Bay Times]
Rick Scott [MONICA HERNDON | Tampa Bay Times]
Published Sep. 20, 2018
Updated Sep. 20, 2018

It's back: two groups that were previously told their case was "not ripe"filed a new lawsuit Thursday that alleges Gov. Rick Scott does not have the legal authority to appoint justices to the state supreme court, as three major vacancies loom in January 2019.

The League of Women Voters and Common Cause of Florida have asked the state supreme court to stop the Judicial Nominating Commission from nominating candidates to fill the vacancies.

Their case was previously struck down because Scott had not yet picked new justices, but last week, he directed the commission to begin seeking nominees.

"Governor Scott intends to follow this precedent and will invite the governor-elect to conduct his own interviews of the nominees following the general election," Scott's statement said at the time. "The governor's expectation is that he and the governor-elect — like Governor Chiles and then Governor-elect Bush — will agree on the selection of three justices who will serve with distinction."

READ MORERick Scott orders panel to screen nominees for Supreme Court

The lawsuit contends that Scott is acting "unquestionably beyond his authority" by intending to make nominations before the vacancies open and while Scott is still in office, which they say violates the state constitution.

In a statement, John Tupps, a spokesman for Scott, hit back.

"It's disappointing that these partisan groups filed a politically-motivated lawsuit that would create three prolonged vacancies on the Florida Supreme Court, contrary to all historical practice," he wrote.

What's at stake with the next justices is the ideological makeup of the state's highest court. Because of a mandatory retirement age of 70 that's set in the state's constitution, all three justices must retire.

Two of the three justices, Fred Lewis and Barbara Pariente, were appointed by Florida's last Democratic governor, Lawton Chiles, with the third, Peggy Quince, having been jointly appointed by Chiles and then-incoming Gov. Jeb Bush.

They have all issued opinions in opposition to the Scott Administration.

Republicans like the GOP's nominee for governor, Ron DeSantis, have spoken often about their retirement as an opportunity to "end judicial activism" by appointing strong conservatives to the bench. His campaign has indicated he would cooperate with Scott.

But if Democratic nominee Andrew Gillum is elected, it's likely he, too, will challenge Scott for the power to appoint the justices. His campaign has said that they believe the rightful authority lies with the next governor.


  1. Check for the latest breaking news and updates.
  2. A Shoot Straight employee conducts background checks and others finish sales at the Florida Gun Show in Tampa.
  3. When called up to Cincinnati last year, Brian O'Grady hit .190 with two homers in 42 at-bats while splitting time between center field, left field and first base. The Rays say O'Grady will get a look at all three positions this spring, plus third base.
  4. Elaine Jeffers, left, and mom Jennifer are all smiles in their pirate and parrot costumes after finishing the 15K and 5K races Saturday morning. Today, both Elaine, 33, and Jennifer, 60, will run their 61st half-marathon.
  5. Tampa Bay Vipers quarterback Quinton Flowers (9) charges for yards during the second quarter of the XFL home opener against the Houston Roughnecks on Saturday, Feb. 22, 2020, at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa.
  6. Rays slugger Yoshi Tsutsugo, left, meets with former Rays infielder Akinori Iwamura, who is working for the NHK WORLD-JAPAN television network and was in Port Charlotte Saturday to interview Tsutsugo.
  7. Happy Palindrome Day! Well, to some of you, anyway.
  8. Tampa Bay Rays Japanese slugger Yoshi Tsutsugo signs autographs while coming off the field after the Rays first full-squad workout at the Charlotte Sports Park, 2300 El Jobean Rd, on Tuesday, Feb. 18, 2020 in Port Charlotte.
  9. Joe Conrad, at the mere age of 90 in the orange hat, crosses the Publix Gasparilla Distance Classic 5K finish line with 30 of his relatives: kids, grandkids and so on. Conrad, who has set several age-group records at races the past few decades, finished in 59 minutes, 28 seconds, but he did, of course, benefit from all the pacers around him.
  10. Jessica Boomershine, 42, was charged with escape and vandalism following the episode late last month, according to the Montgomery County Prosecutor's Office in Ohio.