Advertisement
  1. Florida Politics
  2. /
  3. The Buzz

PolitiFact Florida: Was there one school shooting a week in 2018?

A Florida congressman made the statement in response to President Trump’s State of the Union.
Students walk past the new memorial garden outside of Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland on Jan. 14.  (Joe Cavaretta/South Florida Sun Sentinel/TNS)
Students walk past the new memorial garden outside of Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland on Jan. 14. (Joe Cavaretta/South Florida Sun Sentinel/TNS)
Published Feb. 18, 2019

Florida Democrat Rep. Alcee Hastings criticized President Donald Trump for ignoring the topic of gun violence during his State of the Union address.

Trump’s speech came nearly a week before the anniversary of the Feb. 14 shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland that left 17 people dead. Lawmakers invited three fathers of children who died to watch Trump speak.

Hastings, of nearby Boynton Beach, called on Trump to support gun control and cited a statistic about school shootings nationwide.

“In 2018, we endured a school shooting nearly once a week,” Hastings said in a statement to the media.

Hastings’ spokesman told us he arrived at the one-shooting-per-week statistic by citing a database of school shootings compiled by Education Week, a national education publication. Hastings divided a 180-day school year by 24 shootings to arrive at one shooting every 7.5 days.

It is not apparent from Hastings’ statement, though, that the underlying data lumps together various types of shootings on school property — everything from indiscriminate mass shootings to an accidental shooting.

Databases

There is no consensus about how to define a school shooting. Some tallies include shootings in which someone was killed or injured, for example, while others may include only K-12 schools and not colleges and universities.

“No two school shootings are alike and therefore the circumstances surrounding each must be assessed and considered,” stated a 2018 report by the Naval Postgraduate School Center for Homeland Defense and Security, which examined more than two dozen shooting databases. “Choosing to include or exclude any of these criteria comes with a level of risk by directly affecting the statistical narrative on school shootings.”

The count by Education Week includes 24 school shootings on K-12 school property that resulted in firearm-related injuries or deaths. Shootings that happened on school grounds during school or a school event are also counted. Suicides and self-inflicted injuries are not.

Other groups arrive at higher totals by looking at every time a gun goes off on school property. A database from Everytown for Gun Safety, a gun control advocacy group, found at least 102 incidents of gunfire on school grounds, including K-12 as well as colleges, in 2018. The Naval Postgraduate School database found 97 school gun violence incidents in 2018, the most in any year.

Hastings’ statement is on the lower end of these tallies, but that doesn’t make it more precise.

Database issues

Experts offered some key caveats about Hastings’ statement and databases of school shootings.

Jaclyn Schildkraut, an associate professor in the Department of Public Justice at the State University of New York at Oswego, said that Hastings’ statement omitted context that he was referring to an academic year. If he applied the same 24 shootings to a calendar year, it would have worked out to a shooting incident every other week.

But Schildkraut and other experts have warned that it creates confusion when mass shootings are combined with other types of shootings that occur on school property — for example, two people getting into a fight after a school sporting event.

Most of the shootings are not the indiscriminate mass shootings such as Parkland or Sante Fe. Schildkraut said she would consider about six on the list of 24 as school shootings.

The database includes incidents such as two people shot in a fight outside a high school football game, a parent shot when a gun discharged accidentally in another parent’s pocket, and three students injured when a teacher accidentally fired his gun in a classroom as he was teaching a gun safety lesson.

These various types of shootings require different responses, Schildkraut said.

“We are not going to do a threat assessment on every person who goes to a football game, but we would on a troubled student,” she said. While each loss of life by firearm is too many, “the way we respond to events needs to actually take into account the totality of the situation and not only there was a gun at the school.”

Education Week acknowledges the difficulty in coming up with a methodology. Staff writer Evie Blad explained that “setting — and sticking with — a simple definition was more elusive than we expected.”

Nine of the 24 school shootings determined by Education Week resulted in deaths — or about one per month in an academic year.

“In sum, the one-per-week statement can easily be misunderstood without such clarification,” said James Alan Fox, a criminologist at Northeastern University.

While mass school shootings draw the most attention, the majority of children and teenagers killed by a gun are shot somewhere other than school, such as at home or on the streets. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found that school-associated homicides consistently represent less than 2 percent of all youth homicides in the United States when examining data from 1994-2018.

Our ruling

Hastings said, “In 2018, we endured a school shooting nearly once a week.”

He arrived at that figure by looking at the 24 school shootings documented by Education Week and dividing that into a 180-day school year. (If we applied the same math to a calendar year, it would work out to half that amount.)

A statement about the number of school shootings warrants an explanation of what types of shootings were included. The Education Week database includes any K-12 shooting on a school property during school or a school event that resulted in injury or death. That means it includes both indiscriminate mass shootings as well as other types of incidents such as fights in a parking lot after a football game or an accidental shooting.

Hastings’ statement is partially accurate but leaves out important details about the database he cited. We rate this statement Half True.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

  1. Every physician and scientist who has reviewed the benefits and risks of cannabis to date, regardless of the THC content, has agreed on one thing: more study is needed. In particular, research is required to develop dosing protocols, using well-studied strains containing known amounts of cannabinoids for treating specific conditions.
  2. Former Sen. JD Alexander. [WALLACE, DANIEL  |  Tampa Bay Times]
  3. Florida Chief Financial Officer Jimmy Patronis speaks during a news conference about hurricane preparedness in June in Miami. (Associated Press)
  4. A large monitor displaying a map of Asia and a tally of total coronavirus cases, deaths, and recovered, is visible behind Vice President Mike Pence, center, and Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, left, as they tour the Secretary's Operations Center following a coronavirus task force meeting at the Department of Health and Human Services, Thursday, Feb. 27, 2020, in Washington. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik) [ANDREW HARNIK  |  AP]
  5. Florida lawmakers are investigating why the Florida Coalition Against Domestic Violence’s board of director paid its former CEO, Tiffany Carr, more than $7.5 million over three years. These photos of Carr are from 2004 (left and right) and 2009 (center.) [Tampa Bay Times]
  6. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis delivers remarks during Clay County Day at the Capitol, Thursday, Feb. 20, 2020, in Tallahassee, Fla. (AP Photo/Steve Cannon) [STEVE CANNON  |  AP]
  7. Rep. Bobby Rush, D-Ill., speaks during a news conference about the "Emmett Till Antilynching Act" which would designate lynching as a hate crime under federal law, on Capitol Hill in Washington, Wednesday. Emmett Till, pictured at right, was a 14-year-old African-American who was lynched in Mississippi in 1955, after being accused of offending a white woman in her family's grocery store. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite) [J. SCOTT APPLEWHITE  |  AP]
  8. Eric Welch, a Florida inmate, died on Feb 12 after an accident at his work program [Florida Department of Corrections]
  9. The Times is tracking who Florida elected Democrats are endorsing for president in 2020. [TARA MCCARTY  |  Tara McCarty]
  10. Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, San Petersburg.
  11. A signature analysis of two documents signed by Melody Keeth, former board chair of the Florida Coalition Against Domestic Violence, show signatures from separate documents signed on the same day were nearly exact, as demonstrated in the combined signatures on the third line. Legislators are disputing the authenticity of one of the documents, noting that it includes information that didn’t exist until a year after it was purportedly signed by Keeth. [Florida House of Representatives]
  12. The question before the 1st District Court of Appeal in Tallahassee is whether Florida is following its constitutional duty to provide a high-quality education to public school students.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement