1. Florida Politics
  2. /
  3. The Buzz

In bid to get his job back, ex-Broward sheriff says he’s not to blame for mass shootings

“The totality of the evidence does not indicate any failure of significance on the part of Sheriff Israel in the faithful performance of his duties of sheriff of Broward County,” Israel’s lawyer writes to the Senate.
Broward County Sheriff Scott Israel speaks before a CNN town hall broadcast, in 2018. [Michael Laughlin | South Florida Sun-Sentinel via AP]
Published Aug. 21

In a final pitch to a Senate special master, former Broward County Sheriff Scott Israel’s lawyer is insisting that the suspended law enforcement officer wasn’t to blame for two deadly mass shootings that led to his ouster by Gov. Ron DeSantis earlier this year.

The Republican governor made the suspension of Israel one of his first actions after taking office in January, accusing the former sheriff of “neglect of duty” and “incompetence” connected to the 2018 massacre at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland that left 17 students and faculty members dead.

In his executive order suspending Israel, DeSantis also blamed the former sheriff for mishandling the response to a mass shooting at Hollywood-Fort Lauderdale International Airport that resulted in five deaths.

RELATED STORY: Ron DeSantis stripped him of his job. Now Broward’s ex-sheriff is fighting back

Israel, a Democrat, appealed his suspension to the Florida Senate, which has the authority to reinstate or remove elected officials. Senate Special Master Dudley Goodlette, appointed by Senate President Bill Galvano, held a two-day hearing on the matter in June. Goodlette will make recommendations to Galvano, and the Senate Rules Committee could consider the recommendations as early as September, when lawmakers return to Tallahassee for committee meetings in advance of the legislative session that begins in January.

The full Senate will make a final decision on Israel’s fate.

In a proposed recommended order filed with the Senate Tuesday evening, Israel’s lawyer, Benedict Kuehne, argued that the Senate should reinstate Israel and that he should be repaid for lost wages since his January suspension.

“The totality of the evidence does not indicate any failure of significance on the part of Sheriff Israel in the faithful performance of his duties of sheriff of Broward County,” Kuehne wrote in the 30-page proposed order.

Israel and his lawyers have maintained that the suspension, something DeSantis pledged to do while running for office last year, was a political ploy aimed at winning favor with voters in Democrat-rich Broward County and supporters of the National Rifle Association.

But lawyers for DeSantis harshly criticized Israel for failing to prepare his deputies for mass shootings, directly putting the onus of the fatalities on the former sheriff and his policies.

Florida law makes Israel accountable for the actions of his underlings and for policies instituted by his office, the governor’s lawyers argued in a proposed recommended order submitted to the Senate on Aug. 13.

Those failures resulted in “unnecessary and preventable deaths and injuries” at the airport and the Parkland school, DeSantis’ lawyers Nicholas Primrose and John MacIver wrote in the 50-page proposed order.

But Israel’s lawyer argued that, although the sheriff “is ultimately responsible for the operation of the sheriff’s office,” it “has never been the role of a sheriff in Florida to prevent crime from occurring.”

“Mass murders are undoubtedly tragic and reprehensible, inflicting untold harm to the victims and our communities,” Kuehne wrote, adding, “these attacks must be treated with the utmost alarm and attention.”

Mass shootings have “unfortunately, have become all too commonplace in our society,” Kuehne wrote, pointing to massacres in Florida and throughout the nation.

“It is far too easy for an executive to criticize others for underperformance when the executive has neither the background nor experience to grade the work of law enforcement leaders,” Kuehne wrote. “In our system of elective governance, however, it is for the people --- the voters --- to test the competency of elected officials.”

Both sides’ proposed orders reiterated many of the arguments made during a heated, two-day hearing before Dudley in June.

DeSantis’ team faulted Israel for the failure of two deputies to follow up on interactions with alleged gunman Nikolas Cruz, including one report that Cruz would be responsible for “the next Columbine.” The Marjory Stoneman Douglas shooting might never have happened if Israel’s office had acted on the reports, Primrose implied in June.

DeSantis’ proposed order also said that Israel was to blame for the failings of Scot Peterson, the long-serving resource office at the Parkland school who was seen on videotape hovering outside a building as Nikolas Cruz unleashed a volley of bullets inside.

Peterson, who retired after Israel announced he intended to suspend the deputy, was arrested earlier this summer following a Florida Department of Law Enforcement’s investigation into the shooting.

DeSantis’ lawyers argued that Peterson’s failure to enter the building upon hearing gunshots “resulted in eight more fatalities and more injuries, a failure to act which should be attributed to Israel’s leadership, personnel, training and active shooter policy decisions.”

“Any failure of Deputy Peterson is also a failure of Israel,” the governor’s lawyers wrote in the proposed order.

But Kuehne pushed back, writing that “nothing in Deputy Peterson’s extensive BSO (Broward Sheriff’s Office) record offered any advance warning of his incapacity.”

Israel’s proposed order acknowledged that the mass shooting at the Parkland school “is an extreme tragedy,” but argued “it was not a preventable mass terror attack given the intention of the mass murderer to commit acts of terrorism on the suburban high school campus.”

“Neither Sheriff Israel nor the BSO were responsible for the mass shooting,” he added.

Primrose, however, laid the blame at Israel’s feet.

“The facts and evidence show that Scott Israel failed to provide appropriate department policies for responding to an active shooter situation, he failed to adequately and frequently train his deputies to respond to an active shooter situation, and he failed in his paramount statutory duty to be the conservator of the peace in Broward County. These are the grounds for his suspension,” Primrose wrote.

Kuehne again accused DeSantis of carrying out a campaign promise by suspending the sheriff, arguing that Israel “faithfully carried out” his statutory duties as an elected, constitutional officer.

“But instead of relying on evidence, the governor’s case proceeds with speculation, finger-pointing, and after-the-fact criticism, despite the abundant evidence that Sheriff Israel acted to protect the lives, safety and property of Broward County residents by putting in place effective processes, policies, and personnel to keep the peace. That Sheriff Israel is neither perfect nor omnipotent does not establish any proof of any constitutional negligence or incompetence,” Kuehne wrote.

Israel’s lawyer also wrote that DeSantis’ suspension of the sheriff “represents a perilous step for our system of checks and balances, resulting in elected officials becoming subservient to the vagaries of executive action and wholly unrealistic expectations.”

Kuehne urged the Senate to reinstate Israel, warning that making law enforcement officials responsible for “failing to prevent criminals and terrorists from causing mass destruction” was a standard that has not been imposed on any sheriff or official in Florida until now.

“Imposing such sweeping responsibility upon elected sheriffs for the conduct of deviant, malicious criminal perpetrators is unfounded in law, policy, or custom, and establishes a frightening a precedent,” Kuehne concluded.

-- Dara Kam


  1. Tampa City Council member Orlando Gudes has another $500,000 for an East Tampa cultural center, courtesy of the Hillsborough County Commission. OCTAVIO JONES  |  Octavio Jones
    The Hillsborough County Commission voted unanimously to give the money for the planned facility at Al Barnes Park.
  2. Sen. Rick Scott, R-Fla.
    Scott renews his talking point in the wake of an investigative story.
  3. Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Elizabeth Warren speaks at the Polk County Democrats Steak Fry, Saturday, Sept. 21, 2019, in Des Moines, Iowa. (AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall) CHARLIE NEIBERGALL  |  AP
    All the candidates are here, hoping to pass the Hawkeye test. So far, Elizabeth Warren is surging.
  4. Tallahassee Mayor and Florida gubernatorial candidate Andrew Gillum talks with reporters before addressing a group of gay and lesbian Democrats in Tallahassee on Aug. 19. (AP Photo/Brendan Farrington)
    Gillum accused Florida’s Republican governor of “routine” voter suppression.
  5. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis talks to reporters in Tampa on Aug. 21. Delays in his filling vacancies on the state's five water management district boards have twice led to those agencies canceling meetings to levy taxes and set budgets, which one expert said was unprecedented. OCTAVIO JONES   |   TIMES  |  Times
    Vacancies lead to canceling two agencies’ budget meetings.
  6. Vice President Mike Pence reacts during an immigration and naturalization ceremony in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building on the White House grounds, Tuesday, Sept. 17, 2019, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon) ALEX BRANDON  |  AP
    Katie Waldman, a former University of Florida student senator, was accused of helping discard independent student newspapers with a front-page endorsement of a rival party’s candidate. | Analysis
  7. Richard Swearingen, Florida's Commissioner of the Department of Law Enforcement, testifies before state lawmakers on Monday. Florida Channel
    But law enforcement officials are getting behind a “threat assessment system.”
  8. Rep. Geraldine Thompson, D-Orlando, urges the Florida Board of Education to hold schools accountable for teaching the Holocaust and African-American history, as required by lawmakers in 1994. The board was considering a rule on the matter at its Sept. 20, 2019, meeting in Jacksonville. The Florida Channel
    School districts will have to report how they are providing the instruction required in Florida law.
  9. The Mar-a-Lago Resort in Palm Beach. JOE RAEDLE  |  Getty Images
    It wasn’t immediately clear how much Mar-a-Lago would charge to host the Marine Corps Birthday Ball — or even if it might do so for free.
  10. In this March 24, 2018, file photo, crowds of people participate in the March for Our Lives rally in support of gun control in San Francisco. JOSH EDELSON  |  AP
    ‘Guns are always a volatile topic in the halls of the legislature,’ one Republican said.