Advertisement
  1. Florida Politics
  2. /
  3. The Buzz

Latest round in Florida conservation fight a blow to environmentalists

The battle is over a 2014 amendment, which was approved by 75 percent of voters, that requires 33 percent of revenues from a tax on real-estate documentary stamps go to the Land Acquisition Trust Fund.
Will Haney and his dogs break to head off a herd on its way to the cowpens at the Ward family's Limestone Creek Ranch. The Hardee County property protects oak hammocks, pine flatwoods and wetlands that supply water to Limestone Creek and the Peace River. The family has been raising beef cattle there since the 1930s. Seasonal row crops and honey complement cattle production. The ranch is listed for a conservation easement with the Rural and Family Lands Protection Program. A primary threat to ranches in the region is strip mining for phosphate. [Photo by Carlton Ward Jr.]
Will Haney and his dogs break to head off a herd on its way to the cowpens at the Ward family's Limestone Creek Ranch. The Hardee County property protects oak hammocks, pine flatwoods and wetlands that supply water to Limestone Creek and the Peace River. The family has been raising beef cattle there since the 1930s. Seasonal row crops and honey complement cattle production. The ranch is listed for a conservation easement with the Rural and Family Lands Protection Program. A primary threat to ranches in the region is strip mining for phosphate. [Photo by Carlton Ward Jr.]
Published Sep. 9, 2019

In a blow to environmental groups, an appeals court Monday overturned a circuit judge’s ruling that said state lawmakers improperly diverted money that flowed from a 2014 constitutional amendment designed to boost land and water conservation.

A three-judge panel of the 1st District Court of Appeal found that Leon County Circuit Judge Charles Dodson erred when he ruled that money from the amendment could only be used on land purchased after the voter-approved measure took effect.

Dodson’s ruling followed allegations by environmental groups that lawmakers had improperly used money from what is known as the Land Acquisition Trust Fund for other expenses, including agency expenses and salaries.

RELATED STORY: Judge sides with environmentalists, says lawmakers failed to comply with Amendment 1

The appeals court pointed to an “unsupportable reading” by Dodson of the amendment and held that the money is “not restricted to use on land purchased by the state after 2015.”

“While the trial court purported to construe the plain meaning of the constitutional text, that provision does not plainly restrict the use of LATF (trust fund) revenue to improvement, management, restoration, or enhancement of lands only acquired after 2015,” said the 13-page opinion, written by appeals-court Judge Ross Bilbrey and joined by judges Joseph Lewis and Scott Makar. “(A subsection of the amendment) authorizes LATF revenue to be used to finance the acquisition of land, water areas, easements and the like. The subsection also authorizes refinancing. That the text specifically authorizes refinancing suggests that property for which the state already owns title is within the purview of permissible LATF activities.”

The 2014 amendment, which was approved by 75 percent of voters, requires that 33 percent of revenues from a tax on real-estate documentary stamps go to the Land Acquisition Trust Fund. The ballot summary of the amendment said, in part, that the money would be used to “acquire, restore, improve, and manage conservation lands including wetlands and forests; fish and wildlife habitat; lands protecting water resources and drinking water sources, including the Everglades, and the water quality of rivers, lakes, and streams; beaches and shores; outdoor recreational lands; working farms and ranches; and historic or geologic sites.”

RELATED STORY: Voters say Amendment 1 funds were supposed to be spent acquiring land

Environmental groups filed two lawsuits, which were later consolidated, challenging the way lawmakers carried out the amendment during the 2015 legislative session. They argued that lawmakers had used the money as what one attorney described as a “slush fund” to cover environmental expenses.

Dodson last year sided with the groups and found that dozens of legislative budget appropriations were unconstitutional.

“(The constitutional amendment) creates a trust fund that must be expended, if at all, to acquire conservation lands or other conservation property interests … that the state of Florida did not own on the effective date of that amendment and thereafter to improve manage, restore natural systems thereon and enhance public access or enjoyment on those conservation lands,” Dodson wrote.

A brief filed in December by attorneys for the Legislature said Dodson’s ruling declared unconstitutional 185 budget appropriations worth more than $420 million. The brief contended that Dodson “drastically curtails the expressly stated purposes” of the constitutional amendment.

“A broad range of conservation purposes that have properly been funded from the LATF --- including restoration of springs, beaches, and the Everglades --- are ineligible to receive those funds under the trial court’s reading,” the brief said.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

  1. In this June 17, 2019, file photo, a cashier displays a packet of tobacco-flavored Juul pods at a store in San Francisco. Investigators from 39 states will look into the marketing and sales of vaping products by Juul Labs, including whether the company targeted youths and made misleading claims about nicotine content in its devices, officials announced Tuesday. Juul released a statement saying it has halted television, print and digital advertising and eliminated most flavors in response to concerns by government officials and others.  (AP Photo/Samantha Maldonado, File) [SAMANTHA MALDONADO  |  AP]
  2. Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., speaks during First in the South Dinner, Monday, Feb. 24, 2020, in Charleston, S.C. (AP Photo/Matt Rourke) [MATT ROURKE  |  AP]
  3. Airbnb app on a phone: The company faces a fight with regulators.
  4. In this Feb. 19 photo, from left, Democratic presidential candidates, former New York City Mayor Mike Bloomberg, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., former Vice President Joe Biden, former South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg, Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., participate in a Democratic presidential primary debate in Las Vegas, hosted by NBC News and MSNBC. [JOHN LOCHER  |  AP]
  5. Melody Keeth, the former chair of the Florida Coalition Against Domestic Violence, testifies in the Florida House on Monday about how she and the board approved $7.5M in compensation to the nonprofit's former CEO. [Florida Channel]
  6. Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., speaks during a campaign event on Sunday, Feb. 23, 2020, in Austin, Texas. (Nick Wagner/Austin American-Statesman via AP) [NICK WAGNER  |  AP]
  7. Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Bernie Sanders I-Vt. speaks at a campaign event in El Paso, Texas, on Feb. 22, 2020. [CEDAR ATTANASIO  |  AP]
  8. Sen. Audrey Gibson, leader of the Florida Senate Democrats, introduces a bill in January to refocus the $900 million proposed for teacher pay into salaries for all public school employees. It's just one of many ideas still floating around Tallahassee relating to educator raises. [The Florida Channel]
  9. Ten current and former members of the board of directors of the Florida Coalition Against Domestic Violence and two top executives have been asked to testify to a Florida House committee about a pay scandal. The hearings begin today. [SAMANTHA J. GROSS | Times/Herald]
  10. Bernie Sanders defends his 1980s comments on 60 Minutes regarding Fidel Castro. [Twitter]
  11. Democratic candidate for president Mike Bloomberg in Tampa for a campaign rally in January. [LUIS SANTANA   |   TIMES  |  Tampa Bay Times]
  12. Tiffany Carr, the former executive director of Florida Coalition Against Domestic Violence, left, at a 2004 news conference held by Gov. Jeb Bush. [PHIL COALE  |  AP]
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement