Advertisement
  1. Florida Politics
  2. /
  3. The Buzz

How an Orlando strip club sparked a fight for civil rights in Florida

On Thursday, Miami Beach led a coalition of 21 municipalities, including Tampa, Pinellas County and Dunedin, in filing a brief urging the overturn of a May decision voiding local protections of civil rights.
A trial court ruling barring two women from entering an Orlando strip club without a man has caused a constitutional chain reaction. Miami Beach argues that local human rights ordinances are under attack, and the city is leading an effort to overturn the ruling. [STEVEN JOHNSON | Miami Herald]
A trial court ruling barring two women from entering an Orlando strip club without a man has caused a constitutional chain reaction. Miami Beach argues that local human rights ordinances are under attack, and the city is leading an effort to overturn the ruling. [STEVEN JOHNSON | Miami Herald]
Published Dec. 12, 2019
Updated Dec. 12, 2019

What do the policies of an Orlando strip club have to do with anti-discrimination protections in Pinellas County, Tampa and Dunedin?

A whole lot, it turns out.

Attorneys for those three governments joined a statewide effort to protect local anti-discrimination ordinances after an Orange County Circuit Court judge ruled in May that Florida’s anti-discrimination laws overrule local ordinances.

The constitutional chain reaction was sparked by a lawsuit filed by two women denied entry to an Orlando strip club in 2018 because the strip club’s policy prohibited women from entering the business unless they were accompanied by a man.

When the women sued, their lawyer cited Orange County’s Human Rights Ordinance, which prohibits discrimination on the basis of traditional factors, like race and religion, but goes beyond the Florida Civil Rights Act by protecting LGBTQ residents as well.

Now that local ordinance and 45 others across the state are at risk of being voided, as the plaintiffs appeal to the Fifth District Court of Appeal in Florida.

“The worst case scenario is that local discrimination ordinances that protect LGBTQ people around the state of Florida would cease to exist,” said Robert Rosenwald, the Miami Beach’s first assistant city attorney. “Gay and trans folks would have absolutely no protections from discrimination in the state of Florida.”

Miami Beach led a coalition of 21 municipalities in filing an amicus curiae — friend of the court — brief on Thursday encouraging the appellate court to overturn the trial court’s decision.

“If allowed to stand, the trial court’s decision will harm the most vulnerable people across our state by preventing local governments from barring discrimination against people not yet protected by state or federal law,” said Mayor Dan Gelber. “Together with 21 other local governments, we are taking a stand in court today to ensure that the additional protections offered by local discrimination laws will continue to make our cities and counties the fairest and most equitable places to live, work and play.”

In 2009, Dunedin, a city known for progressive and inclusive policies, expanded its 1973 civil rights ordinance to include gender identity and sexual orientation as protected classes.

The City Commission voted unanimously last month to join the amicus brief to preserve that safeguard, City Manager Jennifer Bramley said. But the trial court’s ruling also raised an issue cities like Dunedin have been battling for years: home rule and their ability to govern freely at the local level.

"This is a human rights issue but it's also a home rule issue, " Bramley said. "There are home rule issues that preempt local ordinances that are problematic. This one is disheartening. We know our population, our visitors, best and the local government should be allowed to enforce its own ordinances, especially as it pertains to human rights."

Pinellas County adopted bans on discrimination against sexual orientation in 2008 and gender identity and expression in 2013 that would no longer apply under this ruling, said county attorney Jewel White. And the county's code that bans workplace discrimination applies to employers with five or more employees while the state defines employers with at least 15 employees, setting up another protection that could be trumped.

“If the trial court judge’s decision is upheld, it could set a legal precedent that threatens municipal and county human rights to enact laws and already-in-place laws across the state,” White said in an email."

Monroe and Broward counties joined Miami Beach and others in the filing. Rosenwald filed the court papers after an attorney in the original case called him to warn about the potential stripping of local discrimination protections.

“The city of Miami Beach took it upon itself to call every local government in the state that has a Human Rights Ordinance, all 46 of them, and asked them to join our coalition and sign our brief,” he said. “It’s a very dangerous situation because the judiciary in Florida has changed a lot recently, and they’ve shown a strong willingness to ignore prior precedent and just reverse it.”

Rosenwald said Florida Supreme Court precedent is on the city’s side. Many of the cities and counties with Human Rights Ordinances have enjoyed its protections since the 1980s. In Miami Beach, he said, the local ordinance was passed in the early 1990s.

“If they follow the law, the decision on appeal should be short and it should reverse the trial court,” he said. “But with the current judiciary, anything can happen.”

The case is not expected to be decided until next year.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. Pinellas Sheriff Bob Gualtieri, left, and Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody were appointed to the Presidential Commission on Law Enforcement and the Administration of Justice by Attorney General Bob Barr. [Tampa Bay Times]
    Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody will also join a commission that will “explore modern issues affecting law enforcement," according to the Department of Justice.
  2. Tiffany Carr — shown during a 2004 visit to a Hollywood nail salon, where she spoke on domestic violence — did not respond this past week to requests from the Miami Herald to address her $761,560 annual salary. She is head of the Florida Coalition Against Domestic Violence. [MIAMI HERALD  |  [Bob Eighmie Miami Herald file photo]]
    A bill removes a statute ensuring a state contract with the Florida Coalition Against Domestic Violence following a flap over how much its former CEO was paid.
  3. State Rep. Wyman Duggan, a Jacksonville Republican, presents his bill to create a "do not hire" list for any school employee who has been terminated, or resigned in lieu of termination, from employment as a result of sexual misconduct with a student. [The Florida Channel]
    The measure would apply to district, charter and private schools.
  4. A green iguana strolls around Eco Golf Club in Hollywood, Florida on Oct. 28. [MATIAS J. OCNER  |  Miami Herald]
    The Senate Environment and Natural Resources committee voted 4-0 on a bill that would prohibit green iguanas from being kept as pets or sold in pet shops.
  5. Pasco County Supervisor of Elections Brian Corley, middle, looks over an absentee ballot.
    A nonprofit is mailing millions of voter registration forms to Floridians this month in hopes of getting people on voter rolls in time for the 2020 election. Pasco’s supervisor of elections issued an...
  6. Sen. Kelli Stargel, R-Lakeland. [STEVE CANNON  |  Special to the Times]
    Sen. Kelli Stargel said lawmakers deserved the same level of privacy as police officers and judges, but offered no proof why such an extraordinary exemption in public records was necessary.
  7. In this Feb. 14, 2018, file photo, students hold their hands in the air as they are evacuated by police from Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla., after a shooter opened fire on the campus. (Mike Stocker/South Florida Sun-Sentinel via AP, File) [MIKE STOCKER  |  AP]
    But this year’s bill may provoke fewer fireworks than the bitter debates seen in the past two sessions.
  8. The four candidates for Clearwater mayor in 2020. Clockwise from the top left: Frank Hibbard, Morton Myers, Bill Jonson and Elizabeth "Sea Turtle" Drayer. [[Frank Hibbard (Courtesy of Hibbard); Morton Myers [Douglas R. Clifford | Times]; Bill Jonson [Douglas R. Clifford | Times]; Elizabeth "Sea Turtle" Drayer; (Courtesy of Drayer)]
    We might learn a great deal about a key election in Tampa Bay.
  9. iPhone x Pano of fans outside of Amalie Arena in Tampa for game one of the Eastern Conference NHL Playoffs of the Tampa Bay Lightning and the New Jersey Devils. LUIS SANTANA   |   Times [LUIS SANTANA  |  TIMES]
    Rep. Bryan Avila, R-Miami Springs, wants to repeal sales tax money earmarked for stadiums such as Amalie Arena and Raymond James Stadium and the Trop.
  10. Rep. Anthony Sabatini presents his bill to create school board term limits to the Florida House PreK-12 Innovation subcommittee on Jan. 21, 2020. [The Florida Channel]
    The idea would require a three-fifths vote in each chamber before it could appear on the ballot.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement