Advertisement
  1. Florida Politics
  2. /
  3. The Buzz

Florida Supreme Court rejects ‘energy choice’ idea

The justices said the ballot summary was misleading.
TECO power plant at Port Sutton [CLIFF MCBRIDE  |  Tampa Bay Times]
TECO power plant at Port Sutton [CLIFF MCBRIDE | Tampa Bay Times]
Published Jan. 9
Updated Jan. 9

Floridians won’t have the chance to vote on a constitutional amendment this fall that would have allowed them to choose their electric provider, the state Supreme Court ruled Thursday.

The court’s justices found the proposed amendment was misleading because its summary stated that the amendment would also allow customers to sell electricity.

“In fact the amendment does no such thing,” justices wrote.

The proposal looked to deregulate the state’s energy market, which is dominated by private utility monopolies such as Florida Power & Light, Gulf Power, Duke Energy and Tampa Electric Co.

It would have allowed customers to choose their electricity providers from a competitive market or give them more options to produce solar energy. The proposal was closely modeled on Texas’ deregulation under former Gov. George W. Bush.

Attorney General Ashley Moody also argued to the court that the proposal was misleading and a veiled attempt to “eliminate” the state’s investor-owned utilities. She has come out against several proposed amendments that are now facing review by the Supreme Court, including proposals that would ban assault weapons and allow the use of recreational marijuana.

By law, proposed constitutional amendments are screened by the Supreme Court, which decides whether the amendment adheres to a single subject and isn’t misleading.

The amendment was opposed by the state’s major utilities. Business groups that represent those utilities, such as the Florida Chamber of Commerce and Associated Industries of Florida, praised the court’s decision.

“Thanks to today’s ruling, Florida’s consumers and businesses can continue to rely on our electricity system that helps drive Florida’s economy," Associated Industries of Florida said in a statement.

The amendment was being led by the committee Citizens for Energy Choices. Its chairman, Alex Patton, said in a statement Thursday that he respected the court’s decision, but that it now places Florida at an “economic competitive disadvantage” compared to other states that are considering deregulating energy markets.

“The way Florida regulates and protects monopolies is wrong, antiquated, and anti-consumer,” Patton said in a statement.

The organizers had already collected more than 642,000 verified signatures of the 766,200 required to make it on to the 2020 general election ballot. Patton said he did not know what the group would do next.

“We will review the data, seek legal advice, and regroup after a detailed post-mortem,” Patton said.

While Moody criticized multiple aspects of the amendment, the justices focused on just one: whether the amendment allowed customers to sell electricity.

The amendment summary stated that it “grants customers of investor-owned utilities the right to choose their electricity provider and to generate and sell electricity.”

But justices noted that the amendment itself did not grant the right for customers to sell electricity. Instead, the ballot language, which would appear in the state Constitution, said that nothing in the amendment "shall be construed to limit the right of electricity consumers to buy, sell, trade, or dispose of electricity.”

"The question is not whether a person has the right to sell electricity if the Initiative is adopted, but whether, as the ballot summary claims, the Initiative grants that right,” justices wrote. “It does not, and the ballot summary is therefore affirmatively misleading.”

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. Democratic presidential candidate, former New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg speaks at the ​U.S. Conference of Mayors' Winter Meeting, Wednesday, Jan. 22, 2020, in Washington. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky) [PATRICK SEMANSKY  |  AP]
    It’s also the first visit by any Democratic contender this year
  2. Jimmy Patronis had been appointed to the state’s Public Service Commission by Gov. Scott.
    FDLE cited a ‘potential conflict,’ Leon County State Attorney Jack Campbell said.
  3. Gov. Ron DeSantis. [STEVE CANNON  |  AP]
    Florida students will read more classical literature and learn math differently, according to summary documents.
  4. Florida House Speaker José Oliva made hospital deregulation one of his top priorities. [SCOTT KEELER | Tampa Bay Times]
    Speaker José Oliva slammed pharmaceutical companies in his opening day speech, but a bill to place $100 caps on co-payments for insulin will not pass this year. In fact, it won’t even get a hearing.
  5. The Florida Supreme Court, Wednesday, May 1, 2019. [SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times]
    Judge Renatha Francis has not been a member of the Florida Bar for 10 years.
  6. State Rep. Adam Hattersley, D-Riverview, speaks before volunteers with the gun control advocacy group Moms Demand Action outside the Florida Capitol on Thursday, Jan. 23, 2020. [[LAWRENCE MOWER | Tampa Bay Times]]
    Like it has since the Parkland massacre, the gun debate is growing fierce in Tallahassee. But there are some significant changes this year.
  7. West Palm Beach Mayor Keith James talks with his Director of Communications Kathleen Walter while going over the state of the city address in his office at the City of West Palm Beach municipal building in West Palm Beach, Florida on Wednesday, January 15, 2020.  [OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times]
    West Palm Beach Mayor Keith James leads a city about the same size as Buttigieg’s South Bend. Here’s what his day looks like. Is this presidential experience?
  8. The Florida Supreme Court, Wednesday, May 1, 2019. [SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times]
    “Death is indeed different,” wrote the lone dissenting justice. “This Court has taken a giant step backward."
  9. State Rep. Erin Grall, R-Vero Beach, presents legislation to create a new chapter of Florida law dedicated to parents' rights when dealing with government and other agencies, during a committee meeting Jan. 23, 2020. [The Florida Channel]
    Parents have been marginalized by bureaucracy, and need to be empowered in law, sponsor Rep. Erin Grall says.
  10. Wichita State Shockers center Jaime Echenique (21) and USF Bulls guard David Collins (0) battle for the loose ball during the second half at the Yuengling Center in Tampa on Tuesday. [OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times]
    Lawmakers may require public colleges and universities to ask permission before selling naming rights.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement