Advertisement
  1. Florida Politics
  2. /
  3. The Buzz

Florida lawmakers want same privacy as cops and judges, but why?

Sen. Kelli Stargel said lawmakers deserved the same level of privacy as police officers and judges, but offered no proof why such an extraordinary exemption in public records was necessary.
Sen. Kelli Stargel, R-Lakeland. [STEVE CANNON  |  Special to the Times]
Sen. Kelli Stargel, R-Lakeland. [STEVE CANNON | Special to the Times]
Published Jan. 22
Updated Jan. 22

TALLAHASSEE — Senate Bill 832 would give lawmakers and Cabinet members the same level of secrecy granted to police officers and judges, making their home addresses, telephone numbers and dates of birth private.

But while threats made against cops and judges are an occupational hazard, lawmakers supporting the bill offered no evidence that they needed the same protections. Regardless, a Florida Senate committee approved the bill Tuesday, along party lines, that would make secret the most basic details about state lawmakers.

Under the bill, the personal information and places of employment of their spouses and children would be exempt. So, too, would be information that lawmakers don’t disclose when they run for office, such as the names and locations of the schools their children attend.

Four Republicans voted for and three Democrats voted against the bill, which was sponsored by Sen. Kelli Stargel, R-Lakeland. She said the exemption was needed because of threats made to lawmakers, but she didn’t cite any Florida examples.

The bill has to pass two more committees before making it to the floor. A companion bill, House Bill 1191, sponsored by Rep. Erin Grall, R-Vero Beach, has not yet been heard in the House.

Providing such a broad exemption would be a stunning setback for Florida’s broad public records law, which makes a wide variety of state and local government records open to the public.

Knowing a lawmaker’s home address and a spouse’s employer are critical starting points to uncovering conflicts of interest and other scandals.

Not only are homes often a lawmaker’s biggest asset listed on their financial disclosure forms, but stories abound of lawmakers and local officials living outside their district.

In 2013, WPLG-TV found three then-Democratic state representatives living in nicer homes outside their districts.

In 2017, the Miami Herald reported that state Rep. Daisy Baez, D-Coral Cables, did not appear to live in her district. The reporting prompted a criminal investigation, which led to her resigning and pleading guilty to perjury six months later.

In 2018, the Miami Herald struggled to figure out where Democratic state Sen. Daphne Campbell, D-Miami Shores, lived. The resulting scandal — and others — likely contributed to her defeat in the election later that year.

The scandals often follow redistricting, when lawmakers find their homes are no longer in their district and they have to buy or rent another property to be qualified to run in the new district. The next round of redistricting will take place following this year’s census.

That concern was raised by Sen. Jose Javier Rodriguez, D-Miami, the only senator on Tuesday who raised concerns about the bill.

He said the bill was “problematic” because it didn’t allow the media or the public to verify where a lawmaker lived. He also said the case had not been made that there were enough threats to justify exempting such pertinent personal information.

Stargel, whose husband is a judge, has advocated for several controversial bills in recent years that have received national attention, including a bill this session that would require minors seeking an abortion to get the consent of their parents.

She said lawmaker addresses would still be reported to the Secretary of State and Division of Elections. Neither of those agencies actively verify whether a lawmaker lives where they claim they live, however.

Stargel said there was a need for the bill because of growing threats against lawmakers. She referenced the shootings of former Arizona Congresswoman Gabby Giffords and Louisiana U.S. Rep. Steve Scalise. Giffords was shot in 2011 at a campaign event with constituents at a supermarket and Scalise was shot in 2017 during a Congressional baseball event at a public park. Both were shot far from home and in public settings. Stargel did not say how exempting their home addresses would have protected them.

Stargel also appeared to pose a random hypothetical as evidence, referencing state Sen. Travis Hutson, R-Elkton, whose wife just gave birth.

“His wife’s going to be home, alone, with three young children and an address that’s public,” she said with nary a mention of an actual threat made against Hutson’s family.

The need for the exemptions was “speculative at best,” according to Pamela Marsh, a former prosecutor and the president of the nonprofit First Amendment Foundation. Both the Tampa Bay Times and Miami Herald are members of the organization.

“We have seen no evidence that a threat of harm exists to these individuals or that such harm has, in fact, occurred,” Marsh wrote to wrote to Grall, the House sponsor, last week. The organization is against the idea.

No one spoke in favor of the bill on Tuesday. Rich Templin, a lobbyist for the AFL-CIO, said he had “real concerns” about it.

“We believe that you are different than law enforcement," Templin told senators. "We believe that you are different than prosecuting attorneys...You volunteered. You put yourself up ... and said ‘I want this. I want this job.’”

Asked about the bill Wednesday, Gov. Ron DeSantis expressed reservations.

“You elect someone, you kind of need to know where they live if they’re going to represent your community,” DeSantis said.

The bill is one of nearly 70 filed during this year’s legislative session aimed at making secret more government records that are currently available to the public. The session is scheduled in end in March.

The News Service of Florida was used in this story.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

  1. John MacIver, Gov. Ron DeSantis' pick to be the chief judge of the Florida Division of Administrative Hearings.
  2. Linda Hadley, 57, from St. Petersburg, shows off her "I registered to vote today" sticker after filling out her paper work and registering to vote for her very first time at the Pinellas County Election Services, 501 1st Ave N, on Wednesday, Feb. 12, 2020 in St. Petersburg. When asked why she has decided to register to vote now for her first time Hadley said, "Because I'm desperate to try to get the one that's in the White House out now." Hadley said, "I feel like I'm trying to save the country. It's more important now than ever." Hadley says she is currently supporting Mayor Pete or Bernie.
  3. Pinellas County Supervisor of Elections Deborah Clark, shown in a 2011 public hearing in Largo.
  4. Leon County fifth-grader Ingrid Hanley asks the Senate Education Committee not to adopt legislation that would get tougher on D-rated schools, during a Feb. 17, 2020, session.
  5. The Republican Party recently asked Florida tax collectors to provide "all email addresses" that had been collected by their offices.
  6. For Florida Chief Financial Officer Alex Sink is endorsing Michael Bloomberg in the Democratic primary for president.
  7. Russell Weigel. (Courtesy of Russell Weigel)
  8. Fans watch from the grandstands as Air Force One, carrying President Donald Trump, prepares to land at Daytona International Airport before the NASCAR Daytona 500 auto race at Daytona International Speedway on Sunday in Daytona Beach.
  9. Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., speaks during a Democratic presidential primary debate on Feb. 7 hosted by ABC News, Apple News, and WMUR-TV at Saint Anselm College in Manchester, N.H.
  10. Nathan Myers, left, embraces his uncle, Clifford Williams, during a news conference after their 1976 murder convictions were overturned March 28, 2019, in Jacksonville. The order to vacate the convictions originated from the first ever conviction integrity review unit set up by State Attorney Melissa Nelson.
  11. Democratic presidential candidate and former New York City Mayor Mike Bloomberg speaks at a campaign event in Raleigh, N.C., on Feb. 13, 2020.
  12. President Donald Trump, accompanied by first lady Melania Trump, waves as he steps off Air Force One at the Palm Beach International Airport, Friday, Feb. 14, 2020, in West Palm Beach, Fla. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement