Advertisement
  1. Florida

The 25 most expensive homes sold around Tampa Bay in 2018

Many of them are on the water and the cheapest sold for $3.45 million.
The historic Stovall-Lee House on Bayshore Boulevard in Tampa. [Courtesy of Coldwell Banker]
The historic Stovall-Lee House on Bayshore Boulevard in Tampa. [Courtesy of Coldwell Banker]
Published Jan. 18, 2019
Updated Jan. 18, 2019

Ever wonder who buys those multi-million dollar mansions we spotlight each month when new sales figures are released?

For the third consecutive year, we've delved into property and other public records to put names to those jaw-dropping transactions. The research reveals that buyers of Tampa Bay luxury homes are an increasingly eclectic bunch, reflecting what has become one of the most diverse and desirable areas of Florida.

Two of the 25 most expensive homes of 2018 went to well-known buyers: Blake Casper, who owns many of Tampa Bay's McDonald's restaurants, and Thomas James, chairman emeritus of Raymond James Financial.

But while unfamiliar to most of us, other buyers have made their mark in a wide range of industries and professions. One co-founded a company that supplies temporary housing for victims of natural disasters. Another is a top executive of a major casino resort company. A third plays a key role in the making of gold and platinum jewelry. As in past years, buyers with ties to the health care industry outnumbered buyers from any other field though the tech industry was also well represented.

Despite concerns about climate change and rising sea levels, high-end buyers continue to flock to the water. Of the top 25 sales, 16 were on Pinellas County beaches. Redington Beach alone accounted for five sales, the most of any community in the Tampa Bay area. And prices have steadily risen, notes agent Dania Perry, who had three of the Redington listings.

"I remember telling a developer when he first built over on the beach that 'hey, (Pinellas) county has only four or five home transactions a year over $3 million so you've got to be prepared — we don't have those kinds of buyers,' '' Perry said. "Now we had 20 homes over $3 million in Pinellas (in 2018).''

Prices are climbing in Hillsborough County, too. Tampa had the top sale in either county -- $9.5 million. Overall, a bay area home had to sell for at least $3.45 million to make it into last year's top 25, versus $2.65 million in 2015.

Prices will keep rising, agent Jeff Shelton predicts.

"In 2018 we had a lot of volatility in the stock market and people are now realizing that real estate is a solid investment,'' he said. "I think 2019 is going to be a fantastic year.''

He and partner Mike Hughes currently have a $7 million Davis Islands home under contract.

Although they concentrate on their respective sides of the bay, Perry and Shelton agree that the Tampa Bay area overall has much to offer.

"We've got some of world's best beaches, professional sports teams and owners that support the town, excellent museums, great restaurants, a world-class airport — What's not to like?'' Shelton said. "You couple that with the fact that waterfront pricing is still a bargain compared to Miami, Naples or Sarasota.''

The increase in international flights — direct service to Amsterdam starts this spring — and Britons' uncertainty over the impact of withdrawing from the European Union could encourage more foreign buyers to consider Tampa Bay, Shelton said. And, Perry noted, "we still have our Canadians that love our area.''

Here's a look at who bought the 25 most expensive home in Tampa Bay last year. (The listing agent's name is in parentheses.)

$9.5 million, Bayshore Boulevard, Tampa

[Courtesy of Coldwell Banker]

The basics: 8,930 square feet, six bedrooms, nine full baths (Jennifer Zales)

Blake Casper, CEO of a company that owns dozens of Tampa Bay McDonald's restaurants, and wife Tate bought the historic Stovall-Lee House with plans to turn it into a private club. The price was the highest ever for a residential property in Hillsborough County and third highest in the Tampa Bay area.

$7.25 million, Redington Beach

[Courtesy of Dania Perry]

The basics: 8,629 square feet, eight bedrooms, eight full baths (Dania Perry)

This gulf-front home with a 33-foot high foyer and 11-car garage was bought by Robert Dohmen and Shawn Buending. He is chairman of Dohmen, a group of Milwaukee-based companies active in the health care field.

$6.399 million, Redington Beach

[Courtesy of Debbie Blume/Bill Horne]

The basics: 4,841 square feet, three bedrooms, three full baths (Debbie Blume)

Built in 2016, this house sold to Canadian entrepreneur Jeffrey Scott Fettes. He is co-founder and chief operating officer of 24/7 In Touch, an IT company with offices in Clearwater and 16 other sites in North America, Guatemala, Jamaica and the Philippines. It handles customer service calls for major companies like Walmart.

$6.2 million, Redington Beach

[Courtesy of Sherry Keenan]

The basics: 6,582 square feet, four bedrooms, six full baths (Bill Newsome)

Anton and Donna Nikodemus bought this home with 120 feet of beach and a 900-bottle wine cellar. He is the chief operating officer of regional operations of MGM Resorts International, which has casinos in Las Vegas, Mississippi and other areas.

$6.2 million, Davis Islands, Tampa

[Courtesy of Raif Fluker]

The basics: 7,284 square feet, five bedrooms, seven full baths (Julie Lux)

This home sold for $200,000 above the asking price to Carlos and Cassandra De Quesada. He is CEO of InSync Health Care Solutions, a Tampa-based medical software company. He is also a director of Allegra Motorsports, which competes in races throughout North America.

$5.7 million, Belleair Shore

[Courtesy of Erica Kuykendal]

The basics: 6,390 square feet, six bedrooms, five full baths (Kerryn Ellson)

Chris and Maria Callas, trustees for the MCC Revocable Trust, bought this house shortly before selling for $5 million a nearby mansion that they had owned for barely over a year. He has been the CFO and she the CEO of Apollo Industries, now known as PLAZE Georgia, a specialty chemical contract packager of insecticides, cleansers and other household products.

$5.45 million, Harbour Island, Tampa

[Times]

The basics: 7,399 square feet, six bedrooms, six full baths (Ralph Harvey)

This house, one of just nine behind a secondary security gate in the gated part of Harbour Island, sold to Brian F. Prince. He is a founder of Hegemon Capital, a Tampa-based private equity investment company, and an investor in Florida Funders, a firm providing early-stage capital to Florida technology companies.

$5.2 million, Redington Beach

[Courtesy of YourDigitalPro]

The basics: 5,639 square feet, five bedrooms, four full baths (Dania Perry)

Shawn and Dagmar Moore are the new owners of this home, which sold in an off-market transaction. He has been chief technology office of Solodev, an Orlando-based software company.

$5.1 million, Belleair Shore

[Courtesy of Coastal Properties]

The basics: 6,807 square feet, six bedrooms, six full baths (Cheryl Franzese)

This home with multiple levels of outdoor lanais sold to Crossroads Trust, a private trust based in Palm Beach.

$5 million, Belleair Shore

[Courtesy of Coastal Properties]

The basics: 4,988 square feet, four bedrooms, five full bathrooms (Kerryn Ellson)

Thomas Kerr, a vascular surgeon, and wife Holly Ann Kerr, a vein removal specialists, bought this three-level home with salt water pool. The house also was among Tampa Bay's 25 Most Expensive in 2017.

$4.9 million, St. Pete Beach

[Courtesy of Robyn Gunn]

The basics: 5,915 square feet, five bedrooms, six full baths (Robyn Gunn)

This three-story home with a 22-foot-high white Carrara marble fire place sold to a revocable trust with Stacey L. Whidden as trustee. Whidden, a Tampa native, is founder and CEO of EZ Dental Care, a dental insurance agency, and founder of other businesses in the health care and workers compensation fields.

$4.7 million, Snell Isle, St. Petersburg

[Courtesy of Strickland Property Group]

The basics: 11,023 square feet, six bedrooms, eight baths (Bonnie Strickland)

Thomas James, chairman emeritus of Raymond James Financial Inc., and his wife, Mary, bought this home on Brightwaters Boulevard. Their James Museum of Western and Wildlife Art opened last year in downtown St. Petersburg.

$4.4 million, Palma Ceia, Tampa

[Courtesy of Aaron Flores/High Res Media]

The basics: 8,250 square feet, six bedrooms, six full baths (Mary Pond)

This home on the 3rd fairway of the Palma Ceia Golf Course sold with T A Ballard as trustee.

$4.35 million, Belleair

[Courtesy of Aaron Flores/High Res Media]

The basics: 9,425 square feet, five bedrooms, eight baths (Rafal Wazio)

Tim Arenberg, president of Columbia Pipe and Supply in Chicago, is the new owner of this home on Belleview Island, a double-gated enclave of 31 home sites within the Belleair Country Club compound.

$4.2 million, Tierra Verde

[Courtesy of Tony Sica]

The basics: 6,391 square feet, five bedrooms, five full baths (Debi Eagan)

This home on Oceanview Drive, one of Tampa Bay's most expensive streets, was bought by Quinn Properties LLC. of Lexington, Michigan.

$4.1 million, Hyde Park, Tampa

[Courtesy of FastPix]

The basics: 5,982 square feet, five bedrooms, five baths (Henderson Everett)

Harrel Lambert and Julia Lambert bought this home, built in the 1920s and once featured in Architectural Digest. The property includes a separate "glass'' house with glass door. Harrel Lambert has been an asset management manager for IBM.

$4.04 million, St. Pete Beach

[Courtesy of Sandy Hartmann Homes]

The basics: 6,027 square feet, five bedrooms, four baths (Sandy Hartmann)

This Pass-a-Grille home with a commercial-rated elevator and room for 11 vehicles sold to Herbert and Patricia Ligon. He is the owner of 166 Research, a Nashville-based market research firm.

$4 million, St. Petersburg

[Courtesy of Robyn Gunn]

The basics: 5,359 square feet, three bedrooms, three full baths (Robyn Gunn)

This penthouse encompassing the entire top floor of the Vinoy Place Tower # 4 sold to Ocean Pines, LLC of Hendersonville, Tennessee. It was a record-breaking price for a Vinoy condo.

$3.75 million, Clearwater Beach

[Courtesy of Erica Kuykendal]

The basics: 3,698 square feet, five bedrooms, five full baths (Kerryn Ellson)

Built in 2017, this home with an 1,800-bottle wine cellar sold to a trust in North Barrington, Illinois with Mark F. Moon as trustee. He has been a top executive at Motorola Solutions, a Chicago-based data communications and telecommunications equipment provider.

$3.75 million, Bayshore Boulevard, Tampa

[Courtesy of Karla Dorsey/Keller Williams]

The basics: 7,777 square feet, five bedrooms, four full baths (Karla Dorsey)

Donald and Mildred Bigger are the new owners of this home with exercise room and saltwater pool. He has served as president of Multax Corp., an Illinois-based company that makes parts for the aerospace, power generation and mining equipment industries.

$3.7 million, Tierra Verde

[Courtesy of Dania Perry]

The basics: 10,388 square feet, five bedrooms, six full baths (Dania Perry)

This Mediterranean-style estate on Oceanview Drive sold to Robert Napior of Brookline, New Hampshire. He is co-owner of Deployed Resources, which provides temporary base camps for the U.S. military as well as temporary housing solutions and support for those displaced by natural disasters.

$3.65 million, Redington Beach

[Courtesy of YourDigitalPro]

The basics: 4,602 square feet, four bedrooms, four full baths (Dania Perry)

This home on a deep, over-sized lot was bought by Terrence and Virginia McCarthy. According to his LinkedIn profile, he is president of TJM Properties, which owns independent and assisted living facilities in several states. Through a separate company he operates hotels in Clearwater, Lakeland and Fort Myers.

$3.63 million, Indian Shores

[Courtesy of YourDigitalPro]

The basics: 4,490 square feet, six bedrooms, six full baths (Dania Perry)

Vincent and Mary Guadagna of East Amherst, New Jersey are the new owners of this two-year-old castle-like home. He is president and CEO of United Precious Metal Refining, one of the world’s largest suppliers of master alloys for the manufacturing of gold, silver, platinum & palladium jewelry.

$3.6 million, Clearwater Beach

[Times]

The basics: 4,713 square feet, three bedrooms, three full baths (Maria Brandenburg)

This penthouse in the Grandeur at Sandpearl Residences sold to Jill Vissman and Shannon Vissman. Both Vissmans are executives in the health care field in the Pittsburgh area.

$3.45 million, Sunset Park, Tampa

[Courtesy of Jeff Shelton/Mike Hughes]

The basics: 8,935 square feet, five bedrooms, six full baths (Mike Hughes/Jeff Shelton)

Finished last year, this home inspired by British West Indies architecture was purchased by Chad London. Sorry, we don’t know more about him. This one stumped us.

Contact Susan Taylor Martin at smartin@tampabay.com or (727) 893-8642. Follow @susanskate.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. “My body, my choice” was the rallying cry on the anniversary of Roe v. Wade in the state Capitol, where abortion rights activists decried a fast-tracked bill that would raise the bar for minors seeking abortions. (AP Photo/Aileen Perilla) [AILEEN PERILLA  |  AP]
    Abortion supporters worry about Florida’s move toward parental consent and what may follow.
  2. In this July 30, 2019, file photo, a Super Mario figure is displayed at a showroom in Tokyo. After months of being tight-lipped, Comcast executives on Thursday, Jan. 23, 2020, said the fourth park at Universal Orlando would be based on characters from Nintendo. [KOJI SASAHARA  |  AP]
    Universal Studios is building theme parks based on Nintendo video games across the world. Orlando is set to get its Super Nintendo World in 2023.
  3. Florida's unemployment rate hit a record low in December. (AP Photo/Lynne Sladky, File) [LYNNE SLADKY  |  AP]
    Nearly every major job sector posted gains from a year earlier.
  4. A proposed bill in the Legislature would set a statewide referendum on whether to amend Florida's constitution to add a year to the period when home buyers can transfer their accumulated benefits under the Save Our Homes cap on property assessments to a new home. Pinellas County Property Appraiser Mike Twitty says going from two years to three would reduce the possibility that construction delays in a booming real estate market would prevent some buyers from meeting the deadline, costing them potentially thousands 
 of dollars in property tax savings. [SUSAN TAYLOR MARTIN | Times (2019)]
    The bill, the idea of Pinellas County Property Appraiser Mike Twitty, would give buyers another year to transfer their tax savings under Florida’s Save Our Homes assessment cap to a home they’ve...
  5. Loreen Spencer (left) and Sue Watts, the two newest members of HCI Group's board of directors. [HCI Group]
    “I just wish I had thought of this earlier,” the chairman and CEO said.
  6. Dogs who survived Thursday's fire at a reputable breeder's house in Orlando. [Orlando Fire and Rescue]
    The fire occurred at a reputable breeder’s house, reports say.
  7. Twitter user Mark Kelly (@MarkKellyWPBF) posted a video of what looked like snow flurries in South Florida. [Twitter screenshot]
    This type of precipitation is still out of the ordinary for the Sunshine State.
  8. A Publix chicken tender sub sandwich. Pub Subs are now easier to order through Instacart grocery deliveries. [CHRIS URSO   |   Times]
    New Instacart Meal program to make Pub Sub orders a breeze, according to the grocery delivery app.
  9. Ramon Christopher Blanchett. [Courtesy of Ramon Christopher Blanchett] [Ramon Christopher Blanchett]
    An attorney for Ramon Christopher Blanchett sought a lesser sentence after his client admitted to filing a false return.
  10. This Feb. 6, 2015, file photo shows a Measles, Mumps and Rubella, M-M-R vaccine on a countertop at a pediatrics clinic in Greenbrae, Calif. A study released this week has found that a 2016 California law intended to improve childhood vaccination rates had the greatest effect on high-risk areas where the rates were the lowest. (AP Photo/Eric Risberg, File) [ERIC RISBERG  |  AP]
    The case involves a man who recently traveled to South America.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement