1. Investigations

The law firm investigating All Children’s filed its report. The hospital will make big changes.

The investigation was commissioned by the board of Johns Hopkins Medicine, which runs the hospital, following a Times investigation into fatal problems in All Children’s heart surgery unit.
Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, St. Petersburg. [SCOTT KEELER | Times]
Published Jun. 28
Updated Jun. 28

Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital will make sweeping changes to its policies and structure in response to problems in its heart surgery unit, Johns Hopkins announced today.

The changes include new checks and balances on the hospital’s president, more rigorous evaluations for top executives, better tracking of internal complaints, more thorough vetting of doctors and improved monitoring of patient safety and quality metrics.

Top executives will now report to both the hospital president and Johns Hopkins Health System leaders in Baltimore. And officials in Baltimore will be more involved in hiring, firing and discipline in St. Petersburg.

The new policies come after the Tampa Bay Times exposed serious problems in the hospital’s heart surgery unit, including a sharp increase in surgical mortality and complications.

[ Read the investigation: Johns Hopkins promised to elevate All Children’s Heart Institute. Then patients started to die at an alarming rate. ]

Late last year, the Johns Hopkins Medicine board hired the law firm Gibson Dunn to investigate the unit. Johns Hopkins officials promised to “share lessons learned from the review.”

Gibson Dunn reviewed more than 140,000 documents and interviewed 119 people. It said it said it briefed the All Children’s and Johns Hopkins Medicine boards on its “detailed observations” at meetings in March, April and May.

On Friday, Johns Hopkins released a 12-page memo with the firm’s recommendations for improvement. Health system President Kevin Sowers said the All Children’s and Johns Hopkins Medicine boards had already approved the suggestions and that the hospital would hire an external monitor to make sure they happen.

Family settles for $2.3 million over All Children’s heart surgery death

System leaders will analyze whether the same steps are needed at the five other Johns Hopkins hospitals, Sowers said.

Sowers said the firm discovered a culture of “fear of retaliation and retribution” across the hospital but determined that the quality and safety issues were limited to the heart unit.

Sowers declined to release the detailed findings from the firm’s investigation.

“The story has really already been told,” he told the Times in an interview. “You’ve been a part of telling that story. The question I think our board was looking at was: What were the people failures, the system failures and the process failures that we could learn from and become a better organization so this would never happen again?”

Some of Gibson Dunn’s recommendations echoed findings from federal regulators, who showed up at All Children’s in January and found that too much power rested with the hospital’s president.

Other recommendations addressed key findings in the Times report.

One example: The Times reported that procedures started going wrong after All Children’s became part of the Johns Hopkins network and hospital leaders made a series of personnel changes within the Heart Institute.

The firm recommended “more strategic planning” when changing clinical programs and more quality monitoring during transitions, especially for units that handle complex procedures.

It made the point bluntly: “In making personnel decisions, consider the effect on team dynamics.”

The Times also reported that hospital leaders had failed to report safety incidents to the appropriate regulatory agencies. Sowers said former employees had used concerns about malpractice lawsuits “as rationale as to why things weren’t being reported.”

Gibson Dunn suggested that All Children’s develop “a clear disclosure policy that prioritizes sharing, disclosing or reporting information,” regardless of the concern for legal risk.

In another story, the Times reported the six Johns Hopkins hospitals had not consistently followed safety practices championed by the system’s Armstrong Institute for Patient Safety and Quality.

[ Read: Johns Hopkins wrote the rules on patient safety. But its hospitals don’t always follow them. ]

Gibson Dunn called for the system to consider expanding the institute’s emphasis “from a focus on education and research to include a focus on patient safety within the health system, with accountability for hospital residents regarding relevant operational matters.”

Sowers said the hospital had already acted on at least one of the recommendations: detailed tracking data for programs and individual physicians on a regular basis. Hospital leaders have examined the heart, neonatal intensive care and congenital diaphragmatic hernia units, he said, and are now looking at the bone marrow transplant unit.

“There’s a series of programs that we’re going through and that’ll be done on an annual basis,” he said.

Gibson Dunn also recommended “structured, automated data processes to counteract the possibility of health care providers and leaders not sharing information.”

Sowers said the new steps will help ensure problems come to light sooner. He said health system leaders in Baltimore did not fully understand what was happening in the All Children’s heart program until late last year. When they were presented with all the facts, they acted quickly, he said.

Sowers said he believed he had already made “appropriate changes” to the hospital’s leadership; six top officials resigned after the Times story published. But if additional problems were discovered, “I’m not saying that there wouldn’t be other changes,” he added.

[ Read more: Top All Children’s executives resign following Times report on heart surgeries ]

As All Children’s carries out the policy changes, it will also work to address systemic problems flagged by the federal government. Hospital leaders recently agreed to hire an external consultant to oversee improvement for 12 months in order to maintain public funding.

Separately, a team of national experts has been working on a plan to restart the heart surgery program. Sowers said the team had drawn up recommendations and given them to the board. But he said he did not have a timeframe for surgeries beginning and that the program would first need to hire another surgeon.

Read the full list of Gibson Dunn recommendations here:

Staff writer Justine Griffin contributed to this report.

[ Click here to read all of the Times’ coverage of All Children‘s Heart Institute ]


  1. Richard Zeitlin's clients include a PAC called the Children's Leukemia Support Network. About 86 percent of the money raised by the leukemia network went to Zeitlin’s companies. Facebook
    Las Vegas police also ‘looking into’ officer following Center for Public Integrity investigation.
  2. Michael Jenkins spent seven days at North Tampa Behavioral Health last July. Since then, he says his three children have been afraid he’ll leave and not come home. JOHN PENDYGRAFT   |   Times
    The patients have no choice, and the hospital is making millions.
  3. The Times’ reporting focused on how the hospital misuses Florida’s Baker Act.
  4. Seven-year-old Sriyam Sriadibhatla, who suffers from B acute lymphoblastic leukemia, waits for chemotherapy at Palm Beach Children's Hospital in West Palm Beach. Susan Stocker
    A look inside his machine, which turns charitable and political contributions into paydays.
  5. State regulators plan to fine Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital in St. Petersburg a total of more than $800,000. SCOTT KEELER  |  Times
    The planned $800,000 penalty is the latest fallout from problems in the hospital’s heart surgery department.
  6. Rosana Escamilla gives her daughter Alexcia tiny pieces of food to taste in their home in August 2018. Alexcia was left paralyzed after a heart surgery at John Hopkins All Children's Hospital. The details of her case match the public filing of a $12.75 million settlement the hospital recently signed with a family. EVE EDELHEIT  |  Tampa Bay Times
    The hospital has been negotiating with 11 families; some were struggling to afford the immense cost of care.
  7. EDMUND D. FOUNTAIN   |   Times 
(03/19/2009) In the woods not far from the current Arthur G. Dozier School for Boys, up a dirt road, and up a hill is a small cemetery with 31 unmarked graves. Some of the White House Boys think the bodies of children murdered by guards at the Florida School for Boys are buried in the cemetery. Some of the graves can be attributed to students killed in a 1914 fire. Others can be attributed to a flu epidemic that swept the campus, but not all are accounted for.
    Read the classic Tampa Bay Times story that exposed a dark chapter of Florida history.
  8. Johns Hopkins All Children‘s Hospital. [CHRIS URSO   |   Times]
    It is the first settlement to become public. Others are expected.
  9. Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, St. Petersburg. [SCOTT KEELER   |   Times]
    The investigation was commissioned by the board of Johns Hopkins Medicine, which runs the hospital, following a Times investigation into fatal problems in All Children’s heart surgery unit.
  10. Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital, St. Petersburg.  (SCOTT KEELER   |   Times)
    Outside physicians will now be allowed to inspect Florida heart surgery programs. The change follows problems at Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital.