Competing aims clash as Senate tackles immigration

Published Feb. 11, 2018

A long-anticipated showdown on immigration reform is coming this week — and nobody knows how it will turn out.

The Senate is set to begin debate tonight on an issue that has vexed lawmakers for years, likely signaling whether the closely divided chamber has any hope of striking a bipartisan compromise.

Among other challenges is whether Congress can find a way to protect "dreamers" — as a majority of Americans want for those young immigrants brought to the U.S. illegally as children — while also enacting changes in border security eagerly sought by President Donald Trump.

"We're going to have something in the Senate that we haven't had in a while," Sen. Jeff Flake, R-Ariz., said Sunday on NBC's Meet the Press. "It's a real debate on an issue where we really don't know what the outcome is going to be."

And few are saying much publicly about what they're planning.

"There's not a lot of deep planning that's gone on," said Frank Sharry, founder and executive director of America's Voice, an immigration advocacy organization. "Everyone was focused on what was going on with the shutdown. I think it is going to have a helter-skelter quality to it."

Even if the Senate is able to pass a bill, it's far from certain that the House will move ahead with it. Speaker Paul Ryan, R-Wis., said last week that the House "will bring a solution to the floor, one the president will sign."

What exactly Trump will support remains crucial yet unknown, as he has shown little willingness to accept anything short of the four-part plan he proposed last month.

In a weekend tweet, he reiterated support for "creating a safe, modern and lawful immigration system" that includes more border security, ending family-based legal migration and ending the diversity lottery program. He made no mention of his support for protecting 1.8 million dreamers, whose status was thrown into uncertainty when he canceled an Obama-era program known as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA.

"It's time for Congress to act and to protect Americans," Trump said in a video message released late Saturday. "Every member of Congress should choose the side of law enforcement and the side of the American people. That's the way it has to be."

Trump sparked the debate in September by announcing the end of DACA, which grants temporary legal status to roughly 690,000 dreamers. He has given lawmakers until March 5 to enact a permanent solution.

But Congress has failed for years to secure the votes to pass a Dream Act, as the legislation has become known.

Unlike most congressional debates, which begin with a prepared piece of legislation, the give and take over immigration will not. Instead, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., used his powers as floor leader late last week to bring up an unrelated bill that he said will be used as the "shell" for the debate. The shell can be reshaped when a proposed amendment has the 60 votes needed to clear procedural challenges and pass. Once amendments are added, the final bill will also require at least 60 votes to survive and pass.

Keep up with Tampa Bay’s top headlines

Keep up with Tampa Bay’s top headlines

Subscribe to our free DayStarter newsletter

We’ll deliver the latest news and information you need to know every weekday morning.

You’re all signed up!

Want more of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get started.

Explore all your options

"Every ounce of energy this week is going to be spent on crafting a bill that protects dreamers and can get 60 votes," Senate Minority Leader Charles Schumer, D-N.Y., said in a statement. "It's a hard needle to thread, but we are making progress."

Liberal organizations and immigration-reform advocates are warily watching the debate, pushing for a narrow fix to protect dreamers and warning that they will hold Democrats and vulnerable Republicans accountable if they cannot keep Trump's proposed policy changes to a minimum.

"Our nightmare scenario is that we get into a long-term conversation about immigration," said Angel Padilla, policy director for Indivisible, a grass roots liberal organization. "There are things that need to be addressed for sure that should be addressed separately, but that will only block actual real solutions for dreamers."

Aides in both parties and advocates tracking the debate expect that Democrats and Republicans will try introducing a series of proposals to test the Senate's appetite for reform.

Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, has been hosting meetings in her office since last month's shutdown, trying to get about 25 senators in a bipartisan "Common Sense Caucus" to endorse a plan that could pass overwhelmingly. After several long meetings fueled by several boxes of Girl Scout cookies, they still have nothing.

"I don't know whether we can get there or not," she said.

A bipartisan proposal by senators John McCain, R-Ariz., and Chris Coons, D-Del., has already been dismissed by Trump as a "waste of time." It would grant legal status to a larger pool of undocumented immigrants than the 1.8 million Trump supports legalizing and not immediately authorize spending the $25 billion Trump wants to fortify the southern border. Their bill also says nothing about curbing family-based legal migration or making changes to the diversity lottery program.

Democrats, meanwhile, are expected to introduce a new version of the Dream Act, a bill first introduced during George W. Bush's presidency that would provide a pathway to citizenship for millions of dreamers. A majority of Americans support the concept, but it is opposed by most Republicans unless it is passed alongside changes in border security.