TALLAHASSEE — Gov. Rick Scott and other top state officials quickly distanced themselves last month from a controversial deal approved by Citizens Property Insurance Corp. to shift thousands of homeowners policies to a startup insurance company.
But emails show that the Scott administration and other officials knew in advance about the unique deal that calls for Citizens, the state-backed insurance giant, to pay $52 million to Heritage Property Insurance and Casualty to absorb 60,000 policies.
Documents obtained by the Associated Press show that a lobbyist representing Heritage had met with a top Scott aide to discuss the transaction. The Scott administration acknowledged that the meeting happened in late March — roughly two months before the Citizens board approved the deal.
Scott's chief of staff, Adam Hollingsworth, insisted in a statement that no one in the Scott administration took a position before Citizens approved the transaction, known as a "takeout," on May 22.
"Our office does not weigh in for or against any Citizens take-out action. Instead, we expect the experts at Citizens and the Office of Insurance Regulation to act in the best interest of Citizens policyholders and the taxpayers that support the company," Hollingsworth stated.
Other state officials — including Chief Financial Officer Jeff Atwater — were also given information about the deal before the vote. Citizens officials sent an email to Atwater's personal email account the week before that included background material on the transaction.
Atwater, in the wake of news reports questioning the arrangement, talked to a top Citizens official hours before the transaction was approved. A spokeswoman for Atwater's office did not respond to questions about his role.
Citizens also sent material to House and Senate staff, although a Citizens spokesman said emails to the House were apparently never received.
Citizens does not normally pay companies to absorb its policies, although the board did approve a similar transaction earlier this year. Instead, Heritage is being paid to assume any claims associated with policies going back to January. But since Heritage gets to pick the policies it wants, the insurer could cherry-pick policyholders who have no claims pending.
Citizens officials have defended the deal as a way to shrink the size of the state-created insurer. Citizens currently has nearly 1.3 million policyholders. There has been a push to shrink the insurer because of fears that it would not be able to cover claims if a huge hurricane hits the state. Citizens has the power to place a surcharge, also called a "hurricane tax," on its own policies and policies of most insurance policies if it can't cover its losses.
Call for inquiry
But the backlash against the Heritage deal has already led legislative leaders to call for hearings in the fall to look into how the transaction was constructed.
Senate President Don Gaetz in a statement to senators said the "facts and circumstances surrounding the Heritage transaction need thorough investigation so the people of Florida are assured that it and transactions like it are in the best interest of Floridians."
Follow trends affecting the local economy
Subscribe to our free Business by the Bay newsletter
You’re all signed up!
Want more of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get started.Explore all your options
Some have also questioned the deal because of campaign contributions.
Campaign finance records show that Heritage and affiliated companies have donated $176,000 in contributions since last year. Those donations include $110,000 to a political committee controlled by Scott and more than $40,000 to the Republican Party of Florida. Contributions to Scott's committee came in March.
Hollingsworth previously called it "outrageous" that anyone would suggest that the Scott administration influenced Citizens, whose board members are appointed by Scott, Atwater and legislative leaders.
But Dan Gelber, a former state senator and leading Florida Democrat, said that "Scott's denials of influence peddling ring pretty hollow in light of these new emails."