Friday, September 21, 2018
Business

Next front to fight flood insurance rate hikes: lawsuits

Nobody told Rangel Dockery that flood insurance premiums for the St. Petersburg home she bought in June would skyrocket from $1,900 to nearly $14,000.

Ditto for Colin Elston, who bought his dream retirement home in Treasure Island that same month, and Penny Lee, who bought a cottage nestled inside a St. Pete Beach flood zone a year ago.

"There was no disclosure at all, or we never would have bought this house," Dockery said.

So who do home buyers blame for not telling them the feds were eliminating flood insurance subsidies for some homes starting this month? Or, as one audience member posed to boisterous enthusiasm at a recent flood insurance forum:

"Who do I sue?"

"The biggest injustice of this whole thing is for people to not have heard at all" that insurance subsidies were being stripped from homes sold after July 2012, said Tim Fellabaum, flood product manager for Bankers Insurance Group in St. Petersburg. "I fully anticipate somewhere down the line someone's going to sue their real estate agent and/or their insurance agent."

St. Petersburg real estate attorney Matt Weidner has already met with several property owners preparing to file suit, alleging their Realtors should have warned them their flood bills would soar.

"It's a known defect," Weidner said. "As professionals, they had an obligation to know when it was passed more than a year ago."

Weidner grants that it would have taken Realtors a few months after the passage of the Biggert-Waters Flood Insurance Reform Act in July 2012 to realize its flood rate implications — maybe as much as six months. But after that, failure to tell prospective buyers becomes deceptive, he said.

"There are going to be many, many Realtors who are going to pay the price," he said. "Their insurance carriers are going to be cutting checks to people who bought these homes."

John Sebree, senior vice president of public policy for the Florida Realtors, said his industry was "just as surprised by (the) rate increases as anyone."

"This is not what Congress sold to us," Sebree said in an email. Rather, he said, Biggert-Waters was "sold" as a five-year, phased-in increase in rates.

Sebree said he hasn't heard of any legal challenges. But he noted one line of defense: Realtors aren't the ones quoting flood insurance rates; that information comes from insurance agents.

"Hot potato," responded Jeff Grady, president and CEO of the Florida Association of Insurance Agents.

Grady said so far he has not received any complaints or heard of insurance agents facing lawsuits, which he thinks would be groundless anyway.

"I just don't think agents are going to be in that same line of fire," he said. "We're just placing coverage. The transaction in trying to buy the real estate has already taken place."

The source of the angst, the Biggert-Waters Act, was an attempt to keep the National Flood Insurance Program afloat by gradually — or in some cases immediately — ending subsidized rates. Older properties in flood zones that were built before flood maps were adopted in the 1970s and early 1980s have enjoyed lower rates for years because of the subsidies. Pinellas County alone has more than 50,000 subsidized policies, the most of any county nationwide; Hillsborough has more than 14,000.

Hardest hit are new buyers of those subsidized homes, property owners with repetitive claims and those who let their policies lapse. All are at risk to lose their subsidies immediately.

Darryl C. Wilson, a professor who specializes in property law at the Stetson University College of Law, maintains buyers of subsidized homes have "a very weak case" if they target their own real estate agent. Home buyers typically sue Realtors for shielding known physical defects of a property like a cracked foundation, not over the vagaries of shifting insurance rates, he said.

Some test cases aside, Wilson said the more likely scenario may be a class-action suit targeting "the deepest pockets" available, possibly the insurance industry.

Nicholas Ekonomides, a real estate attorney in Clearwater, agrees proving "intentional misrepresentation" by a Realtor may be tough, especially an agent selling a property. A buyers' agent, on the other hand, bears more responsibility to keep their client informed, he said.

Still, Ekonomides said, home­owners can contend the more pertinent issue is not what a real estate agent knew at the time of a sale but that they should have known that Biggert-Waters Act called for eliminating subsidies on all homes bought after July 2012.

"Ignorance is no excuse," Ekonomides said. "You're going to have lawsuits just as a practical matter."

For their part, Realtors are clinging to FEMA's persistent sketchiness about Biggert-Waters' impact, with the government holding off on releasing new rate figures until August, a full year after the law was passed.

Eileen Bedinghaus, a ReMax Realtor in St. Petersburg, said she tried to pass along information as she knew it. She was far ahead of most of her colleagues in alerting clients about the possibility of a substantial flood rate hike last spring.

The real estate community, though initially slow to react, has taken steps the past couple of months to shield itself and warn property owners.

The Florida Realtors this summer changed sales contracts to alert buyers they may need to get a flood certification to obtain flood insurance. By getting the certification, buyers should now know exactly how much their new premium will be.

The new contract language also makes a buyer's offer contingent on obtaining flood coverage by a certain date at a price not to exceed a cap that is written into the contract.

"If Realtors wait to educate themselves, it will be too late, and could lead to lawsuits and (Florida Real Estate Commission) complaints," attorney Joe R. Boyd, legal counsel to the Tallahassee Board of Realtors, warned in a blog post to members three weeks ago. "There is no reason to think this is just going to go away."

Some real estate agents said they thought the worst of the rate increases would never happen — that there would be another fix in Congress just like in previous times the National Flood Insurance Program faced a financial shortfall.

Even now, much of the emphasis from Tallahassee to Washington, D.C., has been on finding a legislative way to end or at least postpone the rate hikes, which took effect Oct. 1.

Washington's poisonous political climate, which culminated in the recent shutdown of the federal government over whether to fund Obamacare, makes the likelihood of a congressional flood fix even more remote.

That's one reason why Weid­ner, the local real estate attorney, thinks there will be plenty of disgruntled home buyers looking to sue.

"Anybody that is talking about some Washington solution to this is delusional," he said.

Jeff Harrington can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 893-8242.

Comments
Tampa General nurses record the last heartbeats of dying patients, making a family memory

Tampa General nurses record the last heartbeats of dying patients, making a family memory

TAMPA — As John Reisinger waited with family at Tampa General Hospital, grief settled in like a fog. So some of the details are hazy.But he remembers the moment when three women in white lab coats approached him.The day before, his niece, Jessica Rau...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Retro Fitness sets first of several area locations in Citrus Park

Retro Fitness sets first of several area locations in Citrus Park

In early fall, Retro Fitness will open a 17,000 square foot fitness facility in Citrus Park, and it plans for more Tampa Bay area locations.Founded in 2005, Retro Fitness has 153 clubs throughout the United States and is the official fitness center o...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Joe and Son's Olive Oils, a legacy Ybor business, finds new roots in Carrollwood

Joe and Son's Olive Oils, a legacy Ybor business, finds new roots in Carrollwood

Andrea Gebbia grew up in Carrollwood, and now she is bringing the family business to the neighborhood of her youth.In late fall, Joe and Son’s Olive Oils is slated to open a second location."I feel so blessed having the ability to grow my...
Updated: 8 hours ago
The guys who brought you Tampa’s Armature Works plan high-end offices next door, and they’ve already signed a lease with med-tech company AxoGen

The guys who brought you Tampa’s Armature Works plan high-end offices next door, and they’ve already signed a lease with med-tech company AxoGen

TAMPA — Coming soon from the developers who brought you the Armature Works: Heights Union, two high-end office buildings next door to the trendy food hall, event space and co-working complex overlooking the Hillsborough River.Developers said Friday t...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Chi Chop + Kung Fu Tea looks to succeed where others failed

Chi Chop + Kung Fu Tea looks to succeed where others failed

RIVEVIEW – Amy Lin knows that her newest Chi Chop + Kung Fu Tea store is in a location where previous businesses have not lasted.The short-lived Tap’s Brewhouse & Deli and even shorter-lived Top Shelf Sports Bar and Grill tried to r...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Walmart is teaming with a Seminole Heights chef to promote locally grown mushrooms

Walmart is teaming with a Seminole Heights chef to promote locally grown mushrooms

TAMPA — It might seem like an unlikely match from the outside: A distinguished chef with a restaurant known for inventive plates using produce shoppers can find at… Walmart?Walmart, the country’s largest grocer, is known for having a core consumer wh...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Federal loans open to Pinellas businesses struggling against Red Tide

Federal loans open to Pinellas businesses struggling against Red Tide

The U.S. Small Business Administration has extended its disaster loan program to include Pinellas and Pasco county businesses affected by Red Tide.Already, the Pinellas County Economic Development Office was taking applications for bridge loans to he...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Watch: A southern white rhinoceros calf just a week after being born at ZooTampa

Watch: A southern white rhinoceros calf just a week after being born at ZooTampa

TAMPA — A southern white rhinoceros gave birth to a calf at ZooTampa on Sept. 12, marking the sixth successful birth of the species in the zoo's history. In a news release, ZooTampa said southern white rhinoceroses are a nearly threatened spec...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Baggers, cashiers soon can grow beards at Publix

Baggers, cashiers soon can grow beards at Publix

ORLANDO — The faces of baggers, cashiers and stockers at a Florida-based grocery chain may look slightly different in the near future.That's because Publix said Friday that it would start allowing workers to grow beards and other facial hair b...
Updated: 12 hours ago
They spent $15,000 adding a driveway to their St. Pete House. Now the city says they can’t park on it

They spent $15,000 adding a driveway to their St. Pete House. Now the city says they can’t park on it

ST. PETERSBURG — One day in January, Dana Cremo was on her front porch hanging a vintage screen door when two city employees walked up. "You can’t park on your driveway," they said. "Why?" she asked. "Because somebody filed a complaint," they said. F...
Published: 09/21/18