1. Business

Trigaux: Wall Street wants big profits, 'good enough' advice

Raymond James CEO Paul Reilly supports the “good enough” standard for advice. 

Published Mar. 13, 2015

A new front is quietly raging in a lengthy war.

On one side: government and consumer groups that want investment advisers held to a higher standard designed to benefit clients. On the other side: Wall Street firms eager to sustain their cherished "good enough" standard of investing advice that has driven the gravy train of commissions for so many stock brokers.

Often at their clients' expense.

The entrenched standard has inspired such Wall Street jokes as this oldie but goodie:

A stock broker escorts a prospective customer around a stock brokerage and then to a nearby dock, where the stock broker boasts: "This is where our yachts are moored." The potential customer nods, then asks: "Impressive. But where are the yachts of your clients?"

There's a reason people who want to make lots of money become stock brokers. In 2014, despite falling profits, the average bonus on Wall Street rose to $172,860.

Last month, President Barack Obama reignited the touchy subject of standards, proposing tougher rules on investment brokers who handle retirement funds. He said such rules would limit hidden fees, "back-door payments" and the kinds of conflicts of interest that eat into the savings of middle-class Americans.

The president called on the Department of Labor, or DOL, to revive plans to require retirement advisers to put their clients' best interest before their own profits. The AARP and other groups keen on stronger financial consumer protections say basic investors are not aware of the commissions their advisers earn when getting them to enroll in retirement plans that qualify as suitable but may not be the best possible choice for clients.

Needless to say, Wall Street is up in arms again. Among those taking the lead: Paul Reilly, CEO of the regional Raymond James Financial investment firm based in St. Petersburg.

According to a late January email sent to Raymond James employees, Reilly called a White House memo supporting the Labor Department "an example of biased and distorted research (that) impugns the integrity of the work our advisers do every day to help clients achieve their financial goals."

Reilly wrote that he was working with the industry trade group SIFMA — the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association — in its lobbying efforts, "and rallying our senior management team and all of our associates to oppose the DOL's proposal." Details of Reilly's email appeal to employees were first reported in several investment industry publications.

Wall Street's formidable opposition quashed a similar effort after the 2007-2009 financial meltdown to standardize the care that investors receive from financial professionals at the federal level.

Once again at issue is the pitting of the "suitability" against the "fiduciary" standard. They are two different standards that govern advisers and financial planners. The suitability or "good enough" standard requires that investments recommended by advisers simply fit a client's financial objectives, time horizon and experience.

And if such investments also happen to generate mediocre returns to the client but big commissions to the adviser? Well, that's okay under the suitability standard.

Advisers held to the higher fiduciary standard are legally obligated to recommend investments that are only in a client's best interests, whether or not they match the financial interests of the adviser.

Barbara Roper, director of investor protection for the Consumer Federation of America, wants all financial advisers to be held to the fiduciary standard so consumers are more likely to receive better investment recommendations. The issue is critical because, with so many Americans way behind in their efforts to build an adequate retirement nest egg, every dollar counts.

Supporters of the DOL's efforts scoffed at the content of Reilly's email, one recent news report in On Wall Street said.

"This is as Orwellian as it gets," stated Roper in the story. "They will serve their clients best by defeating a regulation that would require them to do what's best for their clients?"

Advisers offering suitable investments have too much leeway, she argues. It means an adviser can pitch a D+ investment with a high commission, even when an A+ alternative exists at lower cost to the client, and still meet the standard.

The brokerage industry argues that curtailing the suitability standard advice based on commissions will hurt middle-class Americans who lack enough assets to be attractive to financial planners who adhere to the higher fiduciary standard. Such advisers typically charge a flat fee based on the size of assets they manage and, Wall Street argues, people with smaller amounts to invest would get squeezed out and have to fend for themselves.

The industry also criticizes the government's latest decision to move ahead without the involvement of the Securities and Exchange Commission. Under the Labor Department plan, brokers would have to follow two sets of rules — a fiduciary standard for retirement accounts, a suitability standard for all others — that would end up further confusing investors.

Many brokers, no doubt, do the right thing to keep their clients happy. That is, of course, a much easier thing to do in a bull market that has driven the Dow from less than 7,000 in 2009 to about 18,000 this year.

I've got to hand it to the Wall Street powers. They are rich. They are not stupid. They know a good gig when they see one.

How many other industries enjoy a seal of approval to be well compensated by giving customers merely mediocre advice?

Orwellian? Sure. Welcome to Washington. Don't bet on a victory by the White House and consumer groups on this battle.

Contact Robert Trigaux at Follow @venturetampabay.


  1. A citrus grove in eastern Hillsborough County. [Times (2017)]
    The U.S. Dept. of Agriculture is predicting a 3.3 percent increase for the struggling industry.
  2. Gas prices may go up as much as 5 cents this week, AAA, The Auto Club Group, said. Pictured is a man filling up at a gas station in St. Petersburg in 2017. [DIRK SHADD   |   Times  (2017)] SHADD, DIRK  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Gas dropped 10 cents on average in Tampa Bay last week and 6 cents on average in Florida.
  3. Artist Danny Acosta completes re-lettering  of the Southernmost Point in the Continental U.S.A. marker in Key West after much of the paint was stripped off in Hurricane Irma in 2017. [Florida Keys News Bureau via the Associated Press]
    Less than 10 percent of U.S. counties are "vacation home'' counties.
  4. The Maple Street Biscuit Company opened in April on the 600 block of Central Avenue. [SCOTT KEELER   |   Times]
    The popular Jacksonville biscuit shop has recently opened a handful of Tampa Bay locations.
    A frustrated business card user learns that his on-time payments don’t boost his personal credit score.
  6. Regina Temple is the new president and CEO at Regional Medical Center Bayonet Point. HCA West Florida
    Read this and more Pasco County business news.
  7. The City Council has called for consultants to design an outdoor concert pavilion with a fixed covering over 4,000 seats in the middle of its proposed overhaul of the downtown waterfront. That decision is causing some friction in the city as officials prepare to present preliminary design drawings to the public. City of Clearwater
    Some in the city are divided over Clearwater’s $64.5 million plan.
  8. Tampa Bay workers are more likely than employees in other metros to quit because of a boss they don’t like, according to a recent survey. Pictured are job seekers at a Tampa job fair in June. [OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times] JONES  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Tampa Bay and Miami tied for the percentage of employees who quit because of a boss.
  9. Recent sunny day flooding in Shore Acres, a St. Petersburg neighborhood vulnerable to rising sea levels. [Times] Susan Taylor Martin
    The organizations will explore the impact of climate change on Florida.
  10. The University of Florida's Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences - Pasco Extension opened an incubator kitchen on Sept. 23. It's  at 15029 14th Street in Dade City. The goal of the kitchen is to create educational opportunities for food entrepreneurs and help them to start new businesses. Whitney Eleamor (center left) developed the idea for the kitchen. PAIGE FRY  |  Paige Fry
    The ribbon-cutting ceremony was held last week for the Pasco County Extension Service community kitchen.