1. Business

After $6 billion in customer losses, state okays plan to reduce utility hedging

Published Jun. 10, 2016

Floridians are poised to lose another $560 million in 2016 as the state's investor-owned electric utilities continue to lose big at the poker table by hedging their purchases of natural gas.

That would mean nearly $6.6 billion in total losses since 2002, and $1.38 billion since the start of 2015 alone.

The state Public Service Commission took the first tentative step Thursday to reduce the financial carnage and approved a plan by Florida's electric utilities to cut their hedging by 25 percent. They rejected a call by critics to end hedging altogether, but said they could revisit the issue later in the year.

"While I think we all would have appreciated more robust changes to further minimize customer risk, this is at least a fair start," said Commissioner Art Graham. "It's a prudent first step."

In a hedge, a utility agrees to buy a volume of fuel in the future at a fixed price. If the price rises later, the utility wins. But if it falls, the utility — or more specifically its customers — loses.

With natural gas prices falling for much of the past decade, hedging has proven to be a reliable money loser.

TECO Energy, Florida Power & Light and Gulf Power earlier this year proposed adjusting their risk-management plans to reduce hedging after the PSC last year urged them to "explore possible changes" to stem hedging costs.

While Duke Energy Florida didn't revise its plan on hedging, the company said its existing plan will allow it also to reduce its hedging by 25 percent.

Critics, however, said cutting the practice by a quarter isn't nearly enough.

"The cost of financial hedging activities still greatly outweigh any potential benefits that the customers may receive from hedging," said Erik Sayler, an attorney with the Office of Public Counsel, which represents consumer interests before the PSC.

Jon Moyle, an attorney representing Florida Industrial Power Users Group, called the 25 percent reduction "a Band-Aid on a gaping gunshot wound," adding, "It's just not going to get us there."

Despite the big losses, the utilities and the PSC maintain that hedging is good for customers because it reduces the volatility of their electric bills, eliminating wide price swings. Natural gas prices can be affected by many factors that the PSC said are outside the control of utilities — things such as weather and environmental regulations.

"With these variables continually changing, fuel hedging programs provide a measure of price stability for customers," the PSC said in a news release.

Graham acknowledged the PSC may need to revisit a further reduction in hedging, though he said he "applauded" utilities for this first step. "This may be a half step, but it's still a step in the right direction," he said.

Utilities say they don't profit when the hedges lead to savings. Customers pay all losses through higher electric bills, but they would also reap all savings.

The utilities have correctly noted that hedging losses aren't restricted to Florida. But higher hedging losses posted by other utilities outside Florida have renewed debate about whether hedging is in the customers' best interest. A few states, the counsel's office said, have moved to stop their utilities from hedging given continued losses.

Utilities and the PSC dispute descriptions of hedges as bets or attempts to out-guess the market. They said they are simply limiting price spikes and volatility, and are not gambling with customers' money.

Contact William R. Levesque at Follow @ Times_Levesque.


  1. A huge number of homes owned by Baby Boomers will sell in the next 20 years. How will the trend affect the Florida housing market? CAMERON GILLIE  |  NAPLES DAILY NEWS
    The enormous generation born between 1946 and 1964 owns about 40 percent of the homes across the country.
  2. Service dog Eleanor Rigby unexpectedly gave birth to eight puppies at Tampa International Airport as her human family was waiting near gate F81 to board a flight to Philadelphia in May 2018. The airport is getting ready to add pet-relief areas at its airsides for service dogs. (EMILY NIPPS | Tampa International Airport) Tampa International Airport
    Work on the new amenities is expected to be completed by next July.
  3. Developers of a proposed apartment complex near St. Petersburg's Mirror Lake area want to tear down this bungalow and replace it with a ramp to the parking garage. Susan Taylor Martin
    The only access would be via a narrow court lined with vintage houses.
  4. Cooling canals, with Turkey Point nuclear power plant in the background. Miami Herald
    The Nuclear Regulatory Commission on Thursday announced that it had signed off on Florida Power and Light’s latest application for a 20-year extension.
  5. Check for the latest breaking news and updates. Tampa Bay Times
    Wages rose a solid 3.1% in November compared with a year earlier.
  6. Noah Shaffer of Confidant Asset Management says the restaurant sector in the Tampa Bay area has done well in 2019 and to expect more openings in the coming months. Chick-fil-A Brandon South opened earlier this year.
    So far, the economy appears robust enough to support further expansion, says a local industry professional.
  7. A new retail center and health club are proposed for the Epperson neighborhood in Wesley Chapel, home of the Crystal Lagoon. Preliminary plans show the fitness club near the most eastern edge of the lagoon. SCOTT KEELER  |   Times
    Ryan Companies proposes grocery, retail stores and health club at neighborhood’s entrance
  8. Jamie Harden of Creative Sign Designs and Maryann Ferenc of Mise en Place discuss priorities for the Tampa Bay Chamber for the coming year. Harden is the outgoing chairman of the chamber. Ferenc is the incoming chairwoman. RICHARD DANIELSON | Times
    Leadership of the organization, formerly the Greater Tampa Chamber of Commerce, also says it could have handled its recent name change better.
  9. The snow park in Pasco County will be known Snowcat Ridge Alpine Snow Park and is scheduled to open in November 2020. Snowcat Ridge Alpine Snow Park
    The park in rural east Pasco anticipates opening in November 2020.
  10. Renderings of the proposed Red Apple Group project show a 20-story hotel on the west side of the block, and a building of about six stories facing Central with parking, shops and offices. The 45-story condo tower rises at an angle on the east side of the block. Courtesy of Arquitectonica
    The $300 million project by Red Apple Group would include a hotel and badly needed parking space.