1. Business

FP&L considers charging customers to explore fracking; Duke Energy could follow suit

State regulators are considering a proposal from Miami-based Florida Power & Light to charge its customers as much as $750 million a year for a fracking exploration project in Oklahoma that the utility says could help lock in fuel prices for years and save customers money. [AP photo]
Published Dec. 3, 2014

Duke Energy is one of two Florida utilities pondering the high-risk natural gas exploration business, and they want customers to pay for it.

Already, state regulators are considering a proposal from Miami-based Florida Power & Light to charge its customers as much as $750 million a year for a fracking exploration project in Oklahoma that the utility says could help lock in fuel prices for years and save customers money.

Duke is watching closely and could follow suit if FPL gets its way.

Here's the real bottom line:

Florida utilities currently do not profit from the cost of fuel used to run their power plants. The utilities bill customers for their fuel costs as a pass-through charge.

But the fracking deal would allow the utilities to earn profits on the fuel that powers their plants, along with revenue from the construction of the facilities and the electricity they generate. FPL's proposal would be the first effort by the state's utilities to charge customers for fracking exploration.

"This is socialism," said Mark Cooper, a senior fellow for economic analysis at Vermont Law School. "This is plain and simple national socialism in Florida. They have no risk. Why should ratepayers bear that risk?"

Stephen Smith, executive director of the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy, put it this way: "If it goes bad, it's all on the back of the customers. Instead of using their own corporate dollars, they want to use ratepayer money. This is part of the same narrative: the utilities are out of control."

To Smith and Cooper, the idea of charging customers for fracking exploration is reminiscent of Duke's use of the state's so-called nuclear advance fee to build the proposed Levy County nuclear plant. But Duke canceled the project after spending $1.5 billion of customer money with no refund.

The fracking proposal comes at a time when the utilities are seeking every opportunity to preserve their increasingly troubled business model. The utilities' revenue and profits face a growing threat from ratepayers' ability to reduce their energy consumption with more efficient products and homes as well as to produce their own power from rooftop solar panels or other sources.

The state Public Service Commission already gave the utilities a huge leg up last week when regulators approved proposals by the power companies to gut their energy-efficiency goals by more than 90 percent and end the state's solar rebate program at the end of 2015.

Jennifer Zajac, a Duke spokeswoman, said investment in fracking exploration is just one of many proposals that the utility is considering as it seeks to bring stability to volatile natural gas prices.

"It would lock in gas supplies in the long term at the wellhead," Zajac said. "If we did that, it would reduce the fuel (price) volatility with gas. Customers do like us to reduce fuel costs. We would have to get a solid return.

"No hard decisions have been made yet," she added. "We'll be following what happens with FPL and the Florida commission."

Charles Rehwinkel, state deputy public counsel, who represents consumers before the PSC, had filed a motion to dismiss FPL's request, arguing that allowing a utility to charge customers for natural gas exploration was out of the commission's jurisdiction. He said the Legislature never gave the commission such broad power.

If the commission approves FPL's plan, it could face a legal challenge, with the Office of Public Counsel already arguing that the commission is overstepping is bounds.

"This case is about whether you have the power or authority to act, and you do not," Rehwinkel told the commission last week.

The five-member panel disagreed and moved forward with this week's hearings on the issue.

"The specific project before us, I find intriguing," said Commissioner Lisa Edgar during hearings Tuesday. "But I am also wrestling with how the guidelines (for executing the proposal) would interact with our procedures."

J.J. Terry Deason, an FPL expert witness, said the utility would be comfortable with the utility approving the proposal and in the near future developing guidelines for executing the project and protecting consumers.

Deason described the proposal as noncontroversial and that it will benefit consumers in the long run.

"What's being proposed," Deason said in defining the plan, is "a different way to procure the fuel."

Cooper, the senior fellow at Vermont Law School, said the trouble isn't with FPL and Duke seeking different ways to secure natural gas but the way the utilities are trying to fund the projects. He said the typical way for utilities to conduct such a project is to form a subsidiary that would explore the potential natural gas well.

By creating separation between the utility and its natural gas exploration efforts, state regulators can better ensure that customers are getting the best deal on fuel prices, Cooper said. But covering the utilities' cost of exploration means the ratepayers may pay for something that they will never get.

"You cannot shift all of these risks to ratepayers," Cooper said. "If it is a dry hole, why should ratepayers be paying? Here's an easy one for the PSC: This is so off the wall, they should be able to say no."

Contact Ivan Penn at or (727 ) 892-2332. Follow @Consumers_Edge.


  1. Frances Werner-Watkins Julie Rinaldi
    News and notes on local businesses
  2. Left to right: Oak Hill Hospital Anesthesiology residents Daniel Eskander, Wayne Simmons, Jeffrey Huang and Benjamin Segil. Katie Stacy/Oak Hill Hospital
    News and notes on local businesses
  3. A total of 131 employees are scheduled to be laid off in January as Locale Market and Farm Table Cucina close at the Sundial to make way for a new food hall created by the developers of the Heights Public Market at the Armature Works in Tampa. CHRIS URSO   |   TIMES
    In a notice to the state of Florida, Sundial owner Bill Edwards said the layoffs are expected to take place the first week of January.
  4. WeWork is opening Tampa offices at 501 E Kennedy Blvd. despite company struggles, including $1.25 billion in losses over 2019. SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times
    WeWork has 200 planned coworking space openings as leadership tries to manage $1.25 billion in losses.
  5. Florida's unemployment rate was unchanged in October at 3.2 percent, according to numbers released Friday. LYNNE SLADKY  |  AP
    The latest numbers were released Friday morning.
  6. Apollo Global Management has offered $130 per share for Tech Data's stock in an acquisition worth $5.4 billion. If regulators shareholders approve, the home-grown company will remain based in Pinellas County, where it employs 2,000 of its 14,000 workers. DIRK SHADD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Private equity firms like Apollo create wealth for pension funds, financial institutions and individual investors by buying assets that typically are sold later at a profit.
  7. Some of Tampa Bay's largest companies are being sold or are up for sale. Times files and Bloomin' Brands
    Tech Data is just the latest in a growing list of public companies bought up by out-of-state firms.
  8. Hillsborough Community College solicited "non-binding letters of interest or intent” last month from developers interested in purchasing the Dr. Gwendolyn W. Stephenson District Administration Center on Davis Islands. OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    Developers have eyed the 3.7 acre waterfront parcel for years, but recent interest has prompted the college’s trustees to finally start the conversation.
  9. Tampa International Airport looking north. The Wall Street Journal ranked it the best midsize airport in America. [Times files]
    TPA took first place in the Wall Street Journal’s annual survey of U.S. airports.
  10. Tech Data's CEO Rich Hume (left) shares a moment with former CEO Bob Dutkowsky during a send off celebration for Dutkowsky earlier this year. JIM DAMASKE   |   Times
    A private equity firm has agreed to buy Tech Data.