Advertisement
  1. Business

Once an economic bedrock, 'middle class' feels unattainable to many

Published May 15, 2015

For a cornerstone phrase decreasing numbers of Americans identify with and today's presidential candidates steer away from, "middle class" remains one very hot topic.

That's because the very concept of the middle class — in which a U.S. family can make enough money to afford a home, a car, health care, child care, a yearly vacation and their kids' education — is increasingly in jeopardy.

"One of the enduring successes I have observed in my lifetime of 64 years is the ability of the 1 percent or the power elite to continually convince so many Americans that they are, in fact, middle class," said Tampa resident Lew Sibert, a retired "minor" pharmaceutical executive. "The statistics are abundantly clear that, certainly in the last decade or more, wages have not kept pace with the everyday cost of living. We are fewer owners and more renters. We throw away a disproportionate share of our incomes on our cars. And our vices.

"And yet, perhaps to preserve our sanity, we condition ourselves to believe 'we aren't doing so bad' or 'we're better off than (fill in the name)' — so we must be middle class."

Pollsters who track the growing anxiety of Americans would agree with Sibert.

Fewer Americans are identifying themselves as middle class in recent years, a recent Gallup survey finds. More Americans feel they have slipped.

"Currently, 51 percent of Americans say they are middle class or upper middle class, while 48 percent say they are lower class or working class," Gallup reported last month. "In multiple surveys conducted from 2000 through 2008, an average of more than 60 percent of Americans identified as middle or upper middle class." Among Gallup's findings:

• In 2008, polls found 30 percent of Americans making $30,000 or less still identified themselves as middle or upper class. In the latest polls, only 25 percent did.

• In 2008, 57 percent of people making between $30,000 and $75,000 said they were middle or upper class. Now that figure is 48 percent.

• Even among those earning more than $75,000, the 86 percent identifying as middle or upper class in 2008 had slipped to 78 percent in the latest polls.

Many point to the weak bounceback of the economy and skewed government policies.

A Pew Research Center survey in February found majorities said that large banks, large corporations and the wealthy have been helped a great deal or a fair amount by government policies.

By contrast, 72 percent said that, in general, the government's policies since the recession have done little or nothing to help middle-class people. Nearly as many said they have provided little or no help for small businesses (68 percent) and the poor (65 percent).

This is a reversal of an earlier trend. In the last decades of the 20th century, many in the middle class saw themselves become upper-class households. Since 2000, more of the middle class has been shrinking because incomes have fallen or are treading water.

The figures for Tampa Bay are typical and disappointing. Pinellas County's average annual pay in 2013 was $43,194, up just $881 (or $88 a year) over the previous decade. Hillsborough's pay in 2013 was $47,408, up $1,226 over the same period. Pasco's average pay slipped to $34,540, a loss of $878. Hardest hit was Hernando County where average pay of $32,141 in 2013 was down $1,256 from 2004.

It's hard to feel middle class and bullish with the lack of progress shown by those pay numbers.

And it is a feeble argument by Florida's political leaders that simply reducing the unemployment rate with lower-paying jobs somehow will empower the Sunshine State going forward. Even the jobless rate in the state has stopped declining in recent months.

A recent report from economists at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis concluded that "families that are neither rich nor poor may be under more downward economic and financial pressure than common but simplistic rank-based measures of income or wealth would suggest."

The study, conducted by William R. Emmons and Bryan J. Noeth, found that one reason many Americans viewed themselves as struggling was that their real incomes had not advanced significantly beyond their parents' — even when they reached higher educational levels. And those who matched their parents' achievements were actually worse off.

Young adults have been especially hard hit. A recent report from the Young Invincibles research group found that, since 2009, the share of impoverished young people has been higher than at any other point in the past 25 years. Since 2009, 16 percent of young people without children were in poverty, up 5 percentage points from the late 1990s. And as many as 23 percent of young parents were in poverty, an 8 percentage point increase. Larger debts driven by rapidly rising education costs have compounded their burden.

Maybe that's why so many politicians running for president in the 2016 election are avoiding the phrase "middle class" in their remarks. Instead, the New York Times reported this past week, we hear alternative phrases like "working class" or "hardworking taxpayers" or "ordinary Americans."

The phrase "middle class" — long synonymous with the American Dream — suggests the Times, "now evokes anxiety, an uncertain future and a lifestyle that is increasingly out of reach."

"I'm worried we're about to see the first generation to have a lower standard of living than their parents," Mike Poller of South Florida's Poller & Jordan Advertising firm told me. "Those who achieve what you and I as old white guys consider 'middle class' will be lucky. The definition of middle class is changing."

Or perhaps "middle class" has just outlived its purpose.

Contact Robert Trigaux at rtrigaux@tampabay.com. Follow @venturetampabay.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. Port Tampa Bay president and CEO Paul Anderson. [OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times (2017)]
    Port commissioners approved the raise after a year with milestone achievements on several fronts.
  2. A rendering of the proposed Edge Collective in St. Petersburg's Edge District. Storyn Studio for Architecture
    The "Hall on Central'' will be managed by Tampa’s Hall on Franklin team.
  3. Mango Plaza in Seffner has sold for $12.49 million. The plaza is anchored by a Publix and Walmart, making it attractive to a Baltimore investment firm. (Continental Realty Corporation)
    Mango Plaza’s new owners are based out of Baltimore.
  4. The Southernmost Point marker in Key West. CAROL TEDESCO  |  AP
    The travel website put the Florida Keys on its list of places not to visit.
  5. Philanthropist David Straz Jr. and his wife Catherine celebrate in March after he advanced into the Tampa mayoral run-off election. Mr. Straz has died at the age of 77. TAILYR IRVINE  |  Times
    The former mayoral candidate who lost to Tampa Mayor Jane Castor earlier this year, died Monday while on a fishing trip in Homosassa. His name, and legacy, are integral to Tampa.
  6. The Chick-fil-A on Dale Mabry in South Tampa. The company announced Monday it will no longer donate to The Salvation Army and the Fellowship of Christian Athletes.
    The groups have faced criticism for their opposition to same-sex marriage.
  7. Candice Anderson, left, and Alsace Walentine, co-owners of Tombolo Books, rearrange books as attendees of the Times Festival of Reading leave the University Student Center behind them. [Jack Evans | Times]
    The shop plans to open next to Black Crow on First Ave. S before the new year.
  8. An opened capsule containing Kratom. The Clearwater City Council was confronted by dozens of concerned citizens at a recent meeting who urged them not to ban the herbal supplement. Times
    “Our recommendation right now is, we don’t think there’s a need to regulate it.”
  9. BayCare Health Systems now plans to build a $200 million, 60-bed hospital along Bruce B. Downs Boulevard. The company previously planned to build on 111 acres further north adjacent to Interstate 75 and an interchange to built at Overpass Road. Shown his the main entrance to BayCare's St. Joseph's Hospital North on Van Dyke Road in Lutz. Times
    BayCare plans a $200 million, 60-bed hospital on land it owns along Bruce B. Downs Boulevard
  10. Damian J. Fernandez, center, is introduced Monday as the new president of Eckerd College. He will succeed longtime president Donald R. Eastman III on July 1. SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Damian Fernandez, 62, will succeed president Donald R. Eastman III, who steps down June 30 after leading the school for 19 years.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement