On June 8, a condo overlooking the Gulf of Mexico in North Redington Beach sold at a Pinellas County foreclosure auction for $458,100.
The winning bidders, an Orlando couple, thought they had gotten a good deal on the 1,500-square unit in the Ram-Sea Condominiums with heated pool and Jacuzzi. Owners can use their condos as permanent homes or lucrative vacation rentals.
But the Orlando couple won't do either. After the electronic auction was over and the money paid, they made an alarming discovery: A bank has a superior first mortgage on the condo and could soon foreclose.
That would leave them with no condo and out almost half a million dollars.
Foreclosure auctions can be risky, and this couple aren't the first to learn that the hard way. But the amount of money involved and the circumstances around the sale make it stand out among the hundreds of foreclosure auctions held each year in the Tampa Bay area.
"It definitely doesn't smell right, to say the least," said attorney Jon McGraw, who represents the couple, John and Christine Houde.
Among the unusual aspects of the sale:
• The condo's previous owner is a company, Outbidya, Inc., started by Clearwater lawyer and real estate investor Roy C. Skelton. Although Outbidya lost the condo in the auction, another of Skelton's companies, Deutsche Residential Mortgage, collected $380,000 from the sale — $222,000 more than Obidya had paid for the condo.
• Deutsche Residential obtained a final judgement of foreclosure based not just on the amount owed on the condo, but also on promissory notes for other properties owned by Skelton's Outbidya.
• The attorney representing Deutsche Residential in the condo foreclosure, Bruce Harlan, once was suspended from practicing law because of misconduct in a different mortgage foreclosure case.
McGraw said he plans to file an emergency motion to try to vacate the sale and get his clients' money back.
"We're just trying to digest this whole thing," Houde said of the transaction that left him and his wife reeling.
Skelton did not respond to a call or email, and Harlan did not respond to a call.
An Ohio man bought the beachfront condo in 1997. Two years ago, after he failed to pay nearly $11,000 in condo fees, the Ram-Sea II Condominium Association obtained a judgment against him and a foreclosure auction was set. Outbidya won with a bid of $157,800, and deeded half of its interest in the condo to a partner, Parkes Investments, LLC.
Homeowner association auctions have been popular with investors because they often can take title to a property for much less than market value although the home could still face foreclosure on a bank's first mortgage. At the time Outbidya obtained title, there was no active bank foreclosure and the condo could have been available for rent or personal use for a considerable length of time before the lender took it back.
Follow trends affecting the local economy
Subscribe to our free Business by the Bay newsletter
You’re all signed up!
Want more of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get started.Explore all your options
On March 13, 2016, though, Wells Fargo began foreclosing against both the original owner and Outbidya.
Less than a month later, Skelton incorporated Deutsche Residential Mortgage. (It has same name but no connection to the huge German bank.) It then issued a $160,000 mortgage to Outbidya and Parkes Investments.
In effect, one of Skelton's companies — Outbidya — was borrowing from another of Skelton's companies — Deutsche Residential.
The foreclosure case on the bank's first mortgage proceeded slowly. This year, though, the pace accelerated toward foreclosure on the second mortgage held by Deutsche Residential.
In February, Deutsche sued Outbidya and Parkes Investments and demanded payment on loans for properties in Largo and Tarpon Springs as well as for the North Redington Beach condo.
In April, Deutsche obtained a final judgement of foreclosure for $377,036. Circuit Judge Jack St. Arnold set the foreclosure sale for June 8.
Even though the judgment was for considerably less, bidding on the condo hit $458,100 because of its gulf-front location and because some bidders — like the Houdes — probably assumed the foreclosure was on the bank's mortgage. Had that been the case, the winning bidder would have owned the condo free and clear and Skelton's Deutsche Residential, holder of the second mortgage, would have gotten nothing
But by beating the bank to foreclosure, Deutsche Residential already has received $378,000 from the proceeds of the auction, If no one else files a claim or the sale isn't vacated, the company could also get the $78,000 "surplus'' — the difference between the judgment amount and the sale price.
McGraw, the couple's attorney, says Skelton's companies "hijacked" Wells Fargo's case in order to foreclose ahead of the bank.
Lawyer Matt Weidner, who has been involved in many Tampa Bay foreclosures, called the condo case "unprecedented." While Skelton's company might originally have overpaid for the condo, Weidner said, he was able to come out far ahead in the end.
"No way would he imagine such a windfall," Weidner said "but the level of machinations to execute this plan is breathtaking."
Weidner said a $150 title search would have revealed the pending bank foreclosure and presumably kept the Houdes from bidding $458,000.
"Auctions are not for amateurs," he said. "I get a phone call once a week from somebody who went to a seminar, or saw a buddy do it and the stories are pretty sad. I've had people take their retirement income and throw it at one of the auctions. But the psychology of these investors is that this is a county auction and surely it must be legitimate and simple and so I'll bid."
Harlan, Deutsche's Residential's attorney, got in trouble in 2011 over his role in another condo foreclosure case. The Florida Supreme Court suspended him from practicing law for three months for trying to block foreclosure of a Tampa man's condo without the man's knowledge. Harlan had been hired by a real estate agent who wanted to buy the condo in a short sale.
Contact Susan Taylor Martin at email@example.com or (727) 893-8642. Follow @susanskate