1. News

Former Pinellas teacher acquitted in ex-husband's slaying faces wrongful death lawsuit

Cara Ryan, a former Clearwater High School teacher, was acquitted of second-degree murder in January in the 2015 shooting death of her ex-husband. Now the daughter of former St. Petersburg police Sgt. John "J.J." Rush is suing her in civil court. [SCOTT KEELER   |   TIMES]
Cara Ryan, a former Clearwater High School teacher, was acquitted of second-degree murder in January in the 2015 shooting death of her ex-husband. Now the daughter of former St. Petersburg police Sgt. John "J.J." Rush is suing her in civil court. [SCOTT KEELER | TIMES]
Published Mar. 24, 2017

Two months ago, a jury acquitted Cara Ryan of murdering her ex-husband, a former St. Petersburg police officer.

But Ryan may go to court again for the 2015 shooting — this time because of wrongful death lawsuit recently filed by the daughter of Sgt. John "J.J." Rush.

Meghan Rush's attorney, Christian Waugh, said it's a chance for the 23-year-old to find closure in the 2015 slaying of her father.

"Our point and our job with this lawsuit is to get what justice we can," Waugh said.

Ryan, 47, did not return calls for comment Thursday. Attorney Roger Futerman, who represented her during the criminal trial, said: "Just because you file a lawsuit, doesn't mean it's going to prevail."

The former Clearwater High School teacher was arrested on a charge of second-degree murder, accused of fatally shooting Rush at her Indian Rocks Beach apartment on March 7, 2015. During her trial, defense attorneys said she shot her husband in self-defense. Prosecutors argued that the shooting was intentional, and that afterward Ryan changed her story about what happened several times.

After two hours of deliberation, a jury sided with Ryan and found her not guilty on Jan. 27.

The wrongful death lawsuit was filed in Pinellas-Pasco Circuit Court on March 6 and seeks to hold Ryan responsible for John Rush's death. It also seeks to bar Ryan from claiming any of her ex-husband's life insurance and other benefits under a Florida law called the "Slayer Statute" that prohibits one from receiving income from the person they killed.

The couple married in 1997 and then divorced in 2006, but continued to date and stayed friends in later years. Josh Rush's daughter, Meghan, is from a previous marriage. He had retired from the police force as a sergeant in the forensic unit and started working as an investigator with the medical examiner.

Ryan, according to the lawsuit, "exerted great control and influence of (John) Rush's actions."

In February 2015, John Rush told Ryan he was breaking up with her and moving out of their home — this time for good. Still, he occasionally checked in on her and made repairs at the apartment.

Prosecutors and the lawsuit chronicle the same time line of the murder:

On March 7, John Rush came over to the apartment at 2601 1st Street after Ryan texted him. While he was there, the lawsuit states, she received a text from another man, so John Rush left. Ryan called him six times, and John Rush returned to her house. Moments later, she shot him in the back.

He stumbled out of the apartment seeking help from a neighbor. In her 911 call to dispatchers, Ryan said he had raped her.

"The one thing that Defendant could not change by story-telling, however, was the death of J.J. Rush," the lawsuit said.

The lawsuit also claimed that Ryan may be receiving Rush's pension, roughly $1,500 a month, as well as life insurance benefits. As her father's heir, the lawsuit said the funds should be distributed to Meghan Rush.

Contact Laura C. Morel at Follow @lauracmorel.


  1. A section of the Robles Park Village public housing complex was built on top the forgotten Zion Cemetery.
  2. Tampa Fire Rescue units arrived at 1011 E 23rd Ave. and put out the fire that consumed this two-story house. The fire was started by a man who trapped himself inside, officials said, and later died of his injuries.
  3. Violinists, Patricia Quintero, RubŽn Rengel, Alex Gonzalez and Emilia Mettenbrink, with the Sphinx Virtuosi orchestra from Detroit, perform at the Carter G. Woodson African-American Museum Thursday/
  4. Tampa City Council chairman Luis Viera said Mayor Jane Castor's decision to add a second ambulance to Station 13 in North Tampa will improve emergency services for his constituents.
  5. A rendering of the new Ulta created by Hennon Group Architects and included in the permits for the building filed with the City of Tampa.
  6. New Orleans-based Dat Dog offers exotic sausages like alligator, duck and crawfish, along with multiple vegan options and more than 30 toppings. The chain is seeking franchisees to bring a location to Tampa Bay.
  7. Debbie and her husband Michael, of Parkersburg, West Virginia, fish from the Dunedin Causeway Thursday. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission extended the period of catch and release for several species of fish along the west coast of Florida.
  8. Shirley Elizabeth Rayner, 52, of Tarpon Springs, is facing a charge of elderly exploitation. Deputies say she forged or altered checks belonging to a 97-year-old woman she was hired to help.
  9. James S. Moody III was appointed in January as a Hillsborough County Judge. He is the son of federal judge James S. Moody Jr. and the brother of Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody. [Photo courtesy of the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit Court]
  10. A rendering of the downtown Sarasota building that holds the office of Retirement Wealth Specialists.
  11. Michael Keetley is brought into the courtroom during his murder trial Thursday, Feb. 20, 2020 in Tampa. Keetley is the former ice cream truck driver who is accused of shooting a group of men in 2010.
  12. The Oaks Estate, a mansion owned by Lazydays RV co-founder Donald Wallace and his wife Erika. The property is a French-Normandy country-style gated manor build on Lake Thonotosassa listed on the market with an asking price of $17.5 million. It includes a main house, 2-story guest house, garage for up to 20 cars, workshop, pool house, gatehouse, horse barn with grazing pasture, indoor and outdoor pools, 2-story boat house, go-cart track, bowling alley and jogging trail pictured on Wednesday, Feb. 19, 2020 in Thonotosassa.