1. News

Tampa couple sues Davis Islands home owners, neighbors after racially charged home-buying dispute

A couple of Indian descent trying to buy this house in Davis Islands in Tampa say they pulled out of the sale after a hostile encounter.
Published Jan. 14, 2017

TAMPA — Contracts had been signed, money had been paid, and the family was ready to finalize a $658,000 purchase of a home in Tampa's affluent Davis Islands neighborhood.

They arrived the morning of Nov. 3 for a final look at the property at 632 Luzon Ave. The women wore traditional Indian sari garb. The Asgars are of Indian descent.

Two neighbors noticed. And that's when the sale soured.

A lawsuit filed recently in Hillsborough Circuit Court alleges neighbors loudly objected to Kaderbhai and Sehera Ali Asgar buying the home. One man uttered racial slurs, according to a civil complaint. He threatened to break the home's windows and set it ablaze.

Police were called, though no official report was taken. But it was enough for the Asgars, who said their daughter was in tears after the ordeal, to cancel the sale.

Now, they are demanding a return of their deposit of $30,000 from the home's owners, Herb and Jan Donica, plus damages from neighbors Debra Olson and David Howard for "infliction of emotional distress."

During the incident, the real estate agent, Jeanne Wolfe, called 911, the complaint stated.

Tampa police records reflect that officers were sent to the home that day. But a record of the call indicates that the agent could not explain specifically what happened or what was said.

Wolfe alleged a neighbor was shouting racial slurs and suggested a hate crime had been committed, according to police records.

The civil complaint states that Olson, who lives across the street, burst through the home's front door and yelled that the Asgars would be bad for the neighborhood. She then left and went to Howard's home down the street, according to the complaint.

Howard then came to the yard and engaged in a "profanity-laced tirade" against the Asgars, the Donicas, and their real estate agent, the complaint stated. He said that "those people" would not be moving into the home.

"You lied!" he said to Herb Donica, according to the complaint. "I will break all your … windows and I will burn your … house down!"

Officers were again called to the home the next day, where another real estate agent complained that a real estate sign had been knocked over, according to police records. The agent suspected one of the neighbors had toppled it.

Police noted no permanent damage to the sign. No formal police report was written after either incident.

Neither Olson nor Howard responded to repeated requests for comments Wednesday and Thursday.

The lawsuit seeks a return of the money and damages for infliction of emotional distress.

It alleges fraud, claiming the Donicas knew their neighbors would be hostile to the sale but did not disclose that during the buying process. The Donicas' attorney, Richard McIntyre, said that is the only portion of the complaint with which they disagree.

"The Donicas agree with the recitation of the facts that occurred on that day," he said. "There's no exaggeration."

He declined further comment.

The Donicas are both attorneys. Herb Donica is known for chairing the committee that supports Toys for Tots in Hillsborough County.

Court records show the Donicas applied Nov. 4 for an injunction for protection against Howard, citing "repeat violence." A judge declined their request. Property records show they still own the home on Luzon Avenue.

The Asgars could not be reached.

Kaderbhai Ali Asgar and his wife run an engineering firm, A-1 Engineering & Consultants, out of their current home, which is elsewhere on Davis Islands, according to state business records. They also previously managed a chain of stores specializing in healthy frozen desserts.

Contact Dan Sullivan at or (813) 226-3386. Follow @TimesDan.


  1. Lawanda Ravoira, DPA, president & CEO, Delores Barr Weaver Policy Center, said girls are subject to an alarming rate of violence and bullying and are not getting the help they need from counseling and other social services. CHRISTOPHER O'DONNELL  |  Times
    Leader of Delores Barr Weaver Policy Center comes to Tampa to warn of “unchecked crisis” of violence and victimization of middle and high school girls.
  2. This rendering shows Scientology's proposed L. Ron Hubbard Hall, a 3,600-seat auditorium with an all-glass facade at the corner of Garden Avenue and Court Street in downtown Clearwater. [Courtesy City of Clearwater]
    Plans for L. Ron Hubbard Hall go back 26 years. If constructed, it would have more seats than Clearwater’s Ruth Eckerd Hall.
  3. Classic Reflections Carriages is offering carriage rides starting at 6 p.m. Dec. 19-21 throughout downtown Brooksville. Reservations are made in person on each event date, starting at 4 p.m., in front of the historic courthouse. Brooksville Main Street
    Holiday events in Pasco and Hernando counties
  4. A huge number of homes owned by Baby Boomers will sell in the next 20 years. How will the trend affect the Florida housing market? CAMERON GILLIE  |  NAPLES DAILY NEWS
    The enormous generation born between 1946 and 1964 owns about 40 percent of the homes across the country.
  5. A Brinks security guard was shot during a robbery attempt at a GTE Financial credit union in Brandon Friday morning. TONY MARRERO  |  Times
    Deputies thought they had the suspect pinned down at the Bridgeport Apartments, but he fled.
  6. Check for the latest breaking news and updates. Tampa Bay Times
    The motorcycle was headed south on Dale Mabry, while the northbound bus was making a turn.
  7. Police are seen outside a home at 5342 22nd Ave. N Friday in St. Petersburg. Stanley Jones, inset, is accused of stabbing two women at 22nd Avenue North and 53rd Street. One woman died from her injuries and the other was hospitalized. [URSO, CHRIS | Tampa Bay Times] CHRIS URSO | Times; St. Petersburg Police Department
    Police arrested Stanley Jones just after the stabbing Friday on 22nd Avenue N.
  8. President Donald Trump speaks during a small business roundtable in the Roosevelt Room of the White House, Friday, in Washington. (AP Photo/ Evan Vucci) EVAN VUCCI  |  AP
    It’s another sign Donald Trump has accepted that he is likely to be impeached by the House.
  9. In this Dec. 5 photo authorities investigate the scene of a shooting in Miramar, Fla. The FBI says several people, including a UPS driver, were killed after robbers stole the driver’s truck and led police on a chase that ended in gunfire at a busy South Florida intersection during rush hour. (Taimy Alvarez/South Florida Sun-Sentinel via AP) TAIMY ALVAREZ  |  AP
    A lawyer for the union where Rick Cutshaw worked said Cutshaw had just left his office before being killed. “He was going home.”
  10. In this Dec. 4, 2019 file photo, Tesla CEO Elon Musk arrives at U.S. District Court in Los Angeles. Musk did not defame a British cave explorer when he called him “pedo guy” in an angry tweet, a Los Angeles jury found Friday. (AP Photo/Mark J. Terrill, File) MARK J. TERRILL  |  AP
    Vernon Unsworth had angered the Tesla CEO by belittling his effort to help in the rescue of 12 boys and their soccer coach trapped for weeks in a Thailand cave as a “PR stunt.”