Advertisement
  1. News

Harvard report dubs Hillsborough, Pinellas as 'outliers' on death penalty (w/full report)

Hillsborough and Pinellas counties are "outliers" in their use of the death penalty, a result of overzealous prosecutors, a lack of regard for defendants with mental and intellectual problems, and racial disparities, a Harvard University study says. [Associated Press]
Hillsborough and Pinellas counties are "outliers" in their use of the death penalty, a result of overzealous prosecutors, a lack of regard for defendants with mental and intellectual problems, and racial disparities, a Harvard University study says. [Associated Press]
Published Oct. 12, 2016

Hillsborough and Pinellas counties are "outliers" in their use of the death penalty, a result of overzealous prosecutors, a lack of regard for defendants with mental and intellectual problems, and racial disparities, a Harvard University study says.

A report by the school's Fair Punishment Project places the two counties among 16 in the nation where five or more defendants received death sentences between 2010 and 2015. Two other Florida counties — Duval and Miami-Dade — also made the list.

"This is what capital punishment in America looks like today," the report states. "While the vast majority of counties have abandoned the practice altogether, what remains is the culmination of one systemic deficiency layered atop another."

Representatives for Hillsborough State Attorney Mark Ober and Pinellas-Pasco State Attorney Bernie McCabe declined to comment on the report because they had not yet seen it. Ober is in the middle of a heated re-election bid.

Researchers examining six Hillsborough death cases on appeal found three of the condemned men had intellectual disabilities, severe mental illness or brain damage. In four of those cases, jurors had not been unanimous about a death sentence. And three of the five more recent death sentences (from the 2010-2015 cases) were imposed on black or Hispanic defendants.

In Pinellas, four out of six appellate defendants had intellectual disabilities, severe mental illness or brain damage; three of five new death sentences were for black defendants; and recent death sentences all came from non-unanimous juries, according to the report.

Also common to death cases in both counties was a lack of adequate defense representation, the report says, with presentations of mitigating evidence typically lasting less than one day.

The report accuses Ober of being quick to pursue the death penalty even when there are significant mitigating factors, such as an intellectual disability. It notes a comment published last year by Public Defender Julianne Holt that Hillsborough prosecutors seek the death penalty in one out of every five first-degree murder cases.

Researchers singled out some of Ober's top prosecutors, noting one sought death sentences in a handful of cases in which a judge or a jury disagreed or the sentence was overturned on appeal. Among those cases was that of Humberto Delgado, convicted in the 2009 shooting death of Tampa police Cpl. Mike Roberts. The state Supreme Court threw out Delgado's death sentence because of severe mental illness.

The report also noted three cases, under previous state attorneys, in which men sentenced to death in Hillsborough were later exonerated.

In Pinellas County, the report references the case of Patrick Evans, whose death sentence was overturned by the state Supreme Court because of inappropriate comments made by an assistant state attorney during trial.

Researchers pointed out four Pinellas cases in which defendants had mental health issues or intellectual disabilities. Among them was the case of Genghis Kocaker, who killed a Clearwater cab driver in 2004. An expert at Kocaker's trial testified that he suffered from mental illness and had an IQ of 70 and organic brain damage.

The Fair Punishment Project is part of Harvard Law School's Criminal Justice Institute and the Charles Hamilton Houston Institute for Race & Justice. Its stated purpose is to use legal research and education to promote fairness and accountability in the criminal justice system.

The project purports to take no official stance on the death penalty. However, its director, Robert Smith, has also worked on the Eighth Amendment Project, which has been described as an effort to abolish the death penalty. He has written academic papers in which he expresses the view that the death penalty is unconstitutional.

While Smith acknowledged his personal opposition to the death penalty, he noted that the Fair Punishment Project is a collaboration among dozens of researchers who have diverse views on capital punishment.

"No project that's affiliated with the law school is allowed to have any particular view on the death penalty," Smith said. "If the goal of the Fair Punishment Project was to get rid of the death penalty, I think the report would look a lot different than it does."

Contact Dan Sullivan at dsullivan@tampabay.com or (813) 226-3386. Follow @TimesDan.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. The area will be closed to drivers headed north and south from 6 a.m. to 9 a.m. through Friday.
  2. FILE - In this Dec. 14, 2009 file photo, Frank Knight, 101, of Yarmouth, Maine, stands in front of an elm tree known as "Herbie" in Yarmouth. Knight took care of the tree for about 50 years while working as the Yarmouth tree warden. The tree, estimated to be 217 years old, was cut down Jan. 19, 2010 after suffering numerous bouts of Dutch elm disease. "Herbie" may be gone, but he'll live on in cloned trees that are now being made available to the public. (AP Photo/Steven Senne, File) [STEVEN SENNE  |  AP]
    What was once a 213-year-old tree will now be available for purchase — in the form of thousands of cloned versions of the tree once named ‘Herbie.’
  3. Tampa Premium Outlets, 2300 Grand Cypress Drive. The area’s newest outlet is touting the shop tax free weekend and extra savings on top of already reduced prices.
    Deputies are searching for a suspect. There is no public safety threat.
  4. A SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket lifts off from Cape Canaveral Air Force Station, Monday, Nov. 11, 2019, in Cape Canaveral, Fla. SpaceX launched 60 mini satellites Monday, the second batch of an orbiting network meant to provide global internet coverage. (Craig Bailey/Florida Today via AP) [CRAIG BAILEY/FLORIDA TODAY  |  AP]
    No one was aboard for the wild ride in the skies above Cape Canaveral, just two mannequins.
  5. social card for breaking news in crime, for web only
    The driver lost control and crashed into an overpass wall.
  6. social card for breaking news in crime, for web only
    The woman called a second man for help, who shot the man, according to authorities.
  7. The Stewart Detention Center is seen through the front gate, Friday, Nov. 15, 2019, in Lumpkin, Ga. The rural town is about 140 miles southwest of Atlanta and next to the Georgia-Alabama state line. The town’s 1,172 residents are outnumbered by the roughly 1,650 male detainees that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement said were being held in the detention center in late November. (AP Photo/David Goldman) [DAVID GOLDMAN  |  AP]
    The Associated Press sent journalists throughout the country to immigration court.
  8. Mike Bishop joins Pasco EDC staff. [Pasco EDC]
    News and notes on Pasco businesses
  9. Hernando County community news [Tara McCarty]
    News and notes on Hernando businesses
  10. Ed Turanchik is a lawyer and former Hillsborough County commissioner. [Times (2016)]
    Politico Ed Turanchik is warned for lobbying about the MacDill ferry after his status as a consultant ended.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement