1. News
  2. /
  3. Crime

Student who aimed to sell stolen gun had it stolen at school, deputies say. Five arrested.

It started with a 15-year-old, his 16-year-old friend, and a meeting in a Hernando High bathroom. Then three 17-year-olds made off with the weapon.
Sheriff Al Nienhuis, left, and school Superintendent John Stratton, second from left, describe the series of events that led to the arrest of five Hernando High students and the confiscation of a handgun. [PAIGE FRY  |  Paige Fry]
Sheriff Al Nienhuis, left, and school Superintendent John Stratton, second from left, describe the series of events that led to the arrest of five Hernando High students and the confiscation of a handgun. [PAIGE FRY | Paige Fry]
Published Sep. 6, 2019
Updated Sep. 6, 2019

BROOKSVILLE — Five Hernando High School students are facing felony charges after one of them brought a stolen gun to sell on campus only to have it stolen from him by other students.

The Thursday morning incident prompted a two-hour lockdown at Hernando High and surrounding schools. At a news conference Friday, the Hernando County sheriff and school superintendent provided details about what happened.

“We never want to face these issues, but when we do, it’s nice to know that we are prepared to react,” Superintendent John Stratton said. “We will seek expulsion for those students.”

The Tampa Bay Times is not identfying the students because of their ages.

It all started when a 15-year-old boy stole a Ruger 9mm handgun from a relative and brought it on a school bus, Sheriff Al Nienhuis said. He told a 16-year-old student that he planned to sell the gun at school and asked him to hold it.

The 16-year-old hid the gun in his backpack and brought it into school, Nienhuis said.

The 15-year-old then called a third student, who is 17, about buying the gun, and they agreed to meet in a school bathroom. Two more students, both 17, came with the other 17-year-old to meet the first two students.

RELATED STORY: Parents worried by allegations someone tried to sell a gun at Hernando High School

Bill Pope, Hernando High’s school resource deputy, received a tip at about 8:45 a.m. from a parent who had heard from a student about a gun on campus. The campus was placed on lockdown.

Before they reached the bathroom, the first 17-year-old told one of the others that he planned to steal the gun, the Sheriff’s Office said.

Inside the bathroom, he asked to see the gun and racked the slide a few times. The three 17-year-olds then ran out, left the building and headed toward the gym, the Sheriff’s Office said. The 15-year-old tried to chase them but lost sight of them.

The teen who had made off with the gun took it to a relative’s house and hid it under a mattress, Nienhuis said.

By 8:50 a.m., at least seven Sheriff’s Office units had arrived on campus, increasing to 22 within the next 20 minutes.

Deputies found the other two 17-year-olds on campus at 8:56 a.m. on campus and took them into custody to question them, the Sheriff’s Office said. Later, the 15-year-old and 16-year-old were taken into custody.

Finally, at 9:36 a.m., deputies found the boy who made off with the gun. He was still at his relative’s house. The gun did not appear to be loaded. Deputies also found two other guns and a BB gun there.

This is the Ruger 9mm handgun that Hernando High School students tried to sell on campus Thursday, deputies say. [Hernando County Sheriff's Office]

“It doesn’t appear in hindsight that they intended on doing anything that particular day, but of course, we have no idea what their intent was in the future,” Nienhuis said.

“It’s frustrating. Kids are going to do things that are not the brightest and this is an example of that.”

The State Attorney’s Office will decide whether the teens are charged as adults, Nienhuis said. If so, they each face up to five years in prison on third-degree felony charges.

The two 17-year-olds accompanying the teen who made off with the gun have had run-ins with the law before. One was arrested on a felony charge of issuing a written threat to kill, and the other had a robbery arrest, a nonviolent arrest and was convicted of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon. The 15-year-old also had two prior non-violent felonies.

The Sheriff’s Office said parents of the students arrested have been cooperating with authorities.

RELATED STORY: Hernando County deputies find no evidence of reported person with gun at Central High School

On Thursday, some parents expressed concerns about safety on campus. Superintendent Stratton said the school district and the Sheriff’s Office are considering steps to ensure campus safety.

These include securing perimeters around campus, bringing in metal detectors and establishing a student safety group. Hernando High already has a care team and staff is monitoring students who may have felt traumatized by the incident, Stratton said.

“If it were not for the parents involved or the students involved, we certainly would not be where we are in the investigation," Nienhuis said, "and we certainly would not be able to prevent something bad in the future happening with those guns.”


  1. Daniel Lee Martin performs during a 1999 benefit concert at Coachman Park in Clearwater. Martin was found dead Friday at his New Port Richey home.
  2. Deputies are looking for a shirtless man who stole a gun from a pickup truck near Plant City on Friday morning and later fired rounds at a convenience store.
  3. David Lee Fogg, Jr., 36, faces charges of first-degree murder and two counts of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon.
  4. Two men used a sledgehammer to punch a hole through the wall of a Metro PCS Store in an attempt to burglarize the business Thursday in Tampa.
  5. Pasco County Sheriff's deputies said dental assistant Edwin Alvis, 37, sexually assaulted an 18-year-old patient who he was preparing for wisdom teeth-removal surgery.
  6. Matthew R. White, who ran a Tampa-based company, M.W. Global Futures, has pleaded guilty in federal court in the state of Washington to one count of wire fraud in connection with soliciting a total of $1.29 million from investors in Florida and Washington and misappropriating the funds from 2011 to 2018. He is scheduled to be sentenced April 10. [Dreamstime | TNS]
  7. Christopher Reddick faces charges of aggravated child abuse with great bodily harm, child neglect with great bodily harm, carrying a concealed firearm and possession of a firearm with a serial number removed.
  8. Michael Benson, 48, of Oldsmar faces a felony charge of video voyeurism, a Class 3 Felony.
  9. Ahmad Weston, left, and Charleston Long are awaiting trial in federal court. They are accused of running a drug ring out of their mother's apartment in a downtown St. Pete senior complex.
  10. DNA evidence linked Alfred Fennie, 58 to the 1991 murder of Jamie Christine Duncan in Tampa. Fennie was already in prison for a murder that occurred in Hernando County the same year. On Tuesday, he pleaded guilty to Duncan's murder and received a 50-year sentence.
  11. Check for the latest breaking news and updates.
  12. Toronto Blue Jays' Reese McGuire, shown in a 2019 game, has been accused by law enforcement of exposure of sexual organs in Pinellas County. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)