Advertisement
  1. News

Supreme Court finally rules on Florida's 30-year water war with Georgia. And it's not over.

Oysterman T.J. Ward shows a freshly shucked oyster from his water lease 609 in Apalachicola, Florida on November 18, 2017. The Florida-Georgia-Alabama water war has been blamed for cutting the flow of water to Apalachicola Bay, ruining the oyster industry. [EVE EDELHEIT | Times]
Published Jun. 28, 2018

The U.S. Supreme Court gave Florida another chance to show that Georgia's upstream water use should be capped to save the Panhandle's oyster industry in a ruling Wednesday that stopped short of resolving a nearly 30-year-old dispute.

In a 5-4 opinion, the justices said Florida should get another shot at showing that limiting Georgia's consumption could do what's needed to restore the fresh water flow into Apalachicola Bay to revive its oysters. The justices said a special master the court appointed to hear the case applied too strict a standard in requiring Florida to prove its case, and ordered him to reconsider.

Florida Gov. Rick Scott sued Georgia in 2013 after record low flows from the Apalachicola River caused the already ailing oyster industry to collapse. Scott's lawsuit accused Georgia of pulling too much water out to supply drinking and irrigation water to homes in growing Atlanta.

Scott hailed the ruling as "a huge win for the entire state of Florida." He did not address how Florida would approach the requirement for further proceedings, nor the already high cost of the case — $57 million in just the past four years.

Franklin County Commission Chairman Joseph "Smokey" Parrish, who represents Apalachicola, was more measured. He said sending the case back to the special master delays the final decision, but added, "but I'd rather them do that than rule against us."

SHELL GAME: The fight to save Florida's oyster industry.

Meanwhile Georgia Gov. Nathan Deal said he's confident his state will ultimately prevail.

"I remain committed to making every effort to defend Georgia's water resources for our current and future citizens," he said in a statement. "We look forward to obtaining a positive ruling on the merits in this case."

Special master Ralph Lancaster Jr. said after the ruling that he could not comment or address questions about when he might schedule additional hearings.

The ruling says Florida will be entitled to a decree in its favor only if it is shown that "the benefits of the (apportioning the water flow) substantially outweigh the harm that might result."

Florida, Georgia and Alabama have been wrangling for 28 years over how much water Atlanta uses, a fight dubbed the Tri-State Water War. It has resulted in repeated court battles, congressional power plays and even a brief bid to move Tennessee's state line to give Georgia more water.

All three states lay claim to the water flowing through the interconnected Apalachicola, Chattahoochee and Flint river basin.

The Chattahoochee flows south from Georgia to join Alabama's Flint River and become the Apalachicola River from the Florida state line to Apalachicola Bay. The bay used to produce 90 percent of all of Florida's oysters, and 10 percent of all the oysters consumed in the U.S.

These days, those numbers have dwindled to almost nothing.

The balance of fresh and salt water in Apalachicola Bay is crucial to the growth and development of the oysters there. But the loss of fresh water flow during a 2013 drought turned the bay salty and so damaged the oyster beds that the area was declared a federal disaster. A seafood industry official estimated that in just that one year about 60 people quit the oyster business and moved away, tearing apart Apalachicola's culture as well as its economy.

To officials in Florida and Alabama, Atlanta is at fault for wasting water and failing to plan for its future. Florida's lawsuit sought to cap Georgia's overall water consumption by metro Atlanta's 5.4 million residents at 1992 levels, when the region's population was 3 million.

Atlanta officials insist they're now doing more water conservation than anywhere else in the nation, and Florida and Alabama's water demands are unreasonable. Georgia's legal argument contended that Florida's oyster industry was hurt more by drought than water use to the north.

OPINION: Read the text of the Supreme Court's ruling.

Atlanta, built as a railroad hub atop a high ridge, is the largest American city without a major body of water nearby. It cannot pump water from underground because it sits above nonporous hard rock. Instead, Atlanta relies on federal reservoirs.

One of them, Lake Sidney Lanier, provides three-fourths of its water. Lake Lanier was created in the 1950s when the Corps of Engineers built a dam on the Chattahoochee River.

Despite repeated negotiations among the states, nobody has come up with a compromise that suits everyone. Meanwhile, Georgia's consumption is expected to nearly double by 2035 to 705 million gallons a day.

The Corps manages the flow in and out of Lake Lanier, which means it controls the Apalachicola, too. Corps officials have said they must operate the reservoir according to the law Congress passed authorizing its construction. That law mentions Atlanta's water supply, but says nothing about helping Florida oysters.

Florida and Alabama have sued the Corps before, winning at the federal court level before seeing an appeals court reverse the decision.

PRIOR COVERAGE: Florida sues Georgia over water use.

So in 2013, after the federal disaster declaration, Gov. Scott announced that Florida would sue Georgia in the U.S. Supreme Court.

The justices appointed a special master to hear the case, and last year he recommended that they side with Georgia. He said Florida had failed to prove a consumption cap was necessary, and suggested that Scott's legal team stumbled by not including the Corps as a party to the case.

PRIOR COVERAGE: Justices seem to favor Florida in water fight with Georgia.

But during oral arguments six months ago, several justices suggested he had been unfair to Florida.

"Can we agree that a cap at the very least would prevent the situation in Florida from getting worse?" Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said then.

The opinion Wednesday was written by Justice Stephen Breyer.

Contact Craig Pittman at craig@tampabay.com. Follow @craigtimes.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. Defendant Reynaldo Figueroa Sanabria leaves the courtroom Wednesday during his murder trial. Sanabria is accused of the stabbing deaths of John Travlos and his girlfriend Germana Morin aboard their houseboat. SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Reynaldo Figueroa-Sanabria faces the death penalty in the slayings of John Travlos and Germana “Geri” Morin.
  2. [SKIP O'ROURKE   | Times]
    It’s unclear if there will be any proposed changes to this method for measuring teachers’ impact on their students’ performance, despite complaints.
  3. Check tampabay.com for the latest breaking news and updates. TMCCARTY  |  times staff
    The teen sent texts naming two classmates and a faculty member as targets, according to the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office. He did not have access to guns, however.
  4. Zephyrhillls police Officer Timothy Alan Murr II, 33, was arrested Monday on a misdemeanor charge of domestic violence. The police department suspended him with pay pending the completion of the criminal investigation. Pasco County Sheriff's Office
    The officer is accused of grabbing a woman’s wrists. The Zephyrhills Police Department suspended him with pay.
  5. This satellite image shows Hurricane Michael on Oct. 9, 2018, as it enters the Gulf of Mexico. It made landfall near Mexico Beach in the Panhandle as a Category 5 storm. Florida State University professor Wenyuan Fan said the storm probably created "stormquakes" offshore in the gulf, too. [Photo courtesy of the National Ocean and Atmospheric Administration]] NOAA
    Analysis of a decade of records shows hurricanes causing seismic activity on continental shelf
  6. Ken Jones, CEO of Third Lake Capital, has sold WingHouse for $18 million to a Jacksonville restaurant company. [Times 2016]
    Tampa’s Third Like Capital now major shareholder in restaurant’s new owners.
  7. Mama is available for adoption. Hernando County Animal Services
    Hernando County shelter pet offerings
  8. The Don CeSar Hotel is caught up in a lawsuit over liquid nitrogen being served and causing injuries at its restaurant. [Times (2011)]
    They say the other side has made inflammatory and misleading statements to the media.
  9. This Mobil Coast gas station at 16055 State Road 52 in Land O Lakes is one of 10 cited in a Florida Department of Environmental Protection lawsuit where inspectors said they found lapses in regularly required tests, maintenance, documentation or other oversight by Brandon-based Automated Petroleum and Energy or its related companies. On Wednesday, the company said the station had already been put back in compliance with state regulations. (Photo via Google street view) Google street view
    The Florida Department of Environmental Protection contends Automated Petroleum and Energy Company failed to do required maintenance or testing at 10 gas stations in the Tampa Bay area and beyond.
  10. FILE - In this Wednesday, July 10, 2019 file photo, 6-year-old elementary school students go through the lunch line in the school's cafeteria in Paducah, Ky. Nearly a million students could lose their automatic eligibility for free school lunches under a Trump administration proposal that's expected to reduce the number of people who get food stamps. In October 2019, the U.S. Department of Agriculture has released an analysis finding as many as 982,000 children could be affected by the change. ELLEN O'NAN  |  AP
    The U.S. Department of Agriculture has released details of an analysis that found that as many as 982,000 children could be affected by the change.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement