Advertisement
  1. News
  2. /
  3. Gradebook

’Parents Bill of Rights’ wins bipartisan backing in first House stop

Parents have been marginalized by bureaucracy, and need to be empowered in law, sponsor Rep. Erin Grall says.
State Rep. Erin Grall, R-Vero Beach, presents legislation to create a new chapter of Florida law dedicated to parents' rights when dealing with government and other agencies, during a committee meeting Jan. 23, 2020. [The Florida Channel]
State Rep. Erin Grall, R-Vero Beach, presents legislation to create a new chapter of Florida law dedicated to parents' rights when dealing with government and other agencies, during a committee meeting Jan. 23, 2020. [The Florida Channel]
Published Jan. 23
Updated Jan. 23

Parents know best.

Government, not so much.

That was the clear message sent by the Florida House Education Committee on Thursday, when a bipartisan majority offered its strong support for legislation deemed the “Parents Bill of Rights” by sponsor Rep. Erin Grall, a Vero Beach Republican who first offered a similar bill a year ago.

With HB 1059, Grall aims to create a new chapter of state law that has a core goal of describing parents’ fundamental rights to control their children’s education, health care and other aspects of upbringing. It stresses that the government may not infringe upon such rights without “demonstrating that such action is reasonable and necessary to achieve a compelling state interest” in a very narrow way.

The bill would require, among other things, school district procedures for parents to opt their children out of lessons and materials they find objectionable. It would mandate schools have set ways for parents to learn about all clubs and activities. It would bar the withholding of information from parents, and set penalties for any government employee who tries to do so.

“This is all about empowering parents,” Grall told the committee. “I have heard from parents that the bureaucracy just wears them down. They don’t know where to go.”

Government systems, established over decades, make it difficult for many to interact and get answers, she said. Parents have been marginalized along the way.

“That means you have to have a shift in the culture,” Grall said, explaining the rationale for her bill.

Representatives from several groups including Planned Parenthood and Human Rights Watch submitted speaker cards, but did not make comments to the panel. Most simply announced their opposition.

That prompted Rep. Byron Donalds, a Naples Republican, to ask for more detailed explanations why they did not like the measure. Only two stepped up to the microphone.

Melina Rayna Barratt of Florida NOW said the measure would empower parents to mistreat LGBTQ children, who are at great risk of self harm.

“You’re saying parents have rights,” Barratt said. “Parents have responsibilities to provide a safe, accepting household for their kids. Please go against this bill.”

Related: Parental ‘bill of rights’ raises concern about Florida LGBTQ minors

A handful of other speakers offered support for the measure.

Bev Kilmer of the conservative Freedom Speaks Coalition said schools have introduced many “inappropriate” programs that parents have found upsetting. Yet when parents seek more details, the districts often are not helpful, she said.

“This bill will solve that issue, or at least take us a long way,” she said.

Her perspective found a welcoming audience within the committee, where only two members opposed the bill. One of them was Rep. Susan Valdes, D-Tampa, who deemed the legislation duplicative and unnecessary.

School systems have rules like the ones suggested, Valdes said. “Parents do have rights already.”

The overwhelming sentiment among the committee, though, was one of disappointment that such a bill is needed, and strong support to get it done.

“Parents bring their children into the world. Parents pay bills. Parents should have rights to raise their children,” said Rep. Kimberly Daniels, D-Jacksonville. “I don’t want the government telling me how to raise my children.”

Rep. Delores Hogan-Johnson, a Fort Pierce Democrat, said the proposal was vague. She noted that many parents rely on schools to educate and discipline their children, and then complain about it.

But perhaps the bill would serve as a wakeup call for parents and agencies alike, Hogan-Johnson said, to do better.

Some parents might never wish to take advantage of their rights, Donalds said. But for those who wish to be involved, and want to maintain control of their children’s growth to adulthood, “this is critical for them.”

The bill next moves to the Health and Human Services committee. An identical version in the Senate is awaiting its first hearing.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

  1. Patrick Suiters, 10, left, and Gabriel Stanford, 9, both fourth-graders at San Jose Elementary School in Dunedin, fill out a survey after tasting falafel tots and nuggets during the 2nd Annual Student Food Connection taste test at Pinellas Technical College. About 120 students tasted and rated 28 new food items that could be added to school breakfast and lunch menus next year.
  2. Pasco School District headquarters in Land O' Lakes
  3. The Pinellas County school system is offering driver education camps to hundreds of students like this one over the summer. The program will be held over two sessions at nine high school campuses across the county.
  4. Incoming Superintendent Addison Davis (center) and School Board Chair Melissa Snively (right) sign Davis' contract with the Hillsborough County School District after it was unanimously approved by the school board on February 18, 2020.
  5. Incoming Hillsborough School Superintendent Addison Davis (center), School Board Chair Melissa Snively (right) and the other board members pose as Davis signs his contract with the district on Tuesday night. The board unanimously approved the contract beforehand.
  6. Jarvis Delon West was arrested on child neglect charges after he didn't report an employee at AMI Kids who slammed a boy to the ground, according to police.
  7. Associate professor of biology Caitlin Gille leads the Pasco-Hernando State College faculty union, which challenged the school's public comment rules.  (Photo Courtesy of Caitlin Gille)
  8. Prekindergarten students at James B. Sanderlin IB World School in St. Petersburg, show the peace sign during an assembly in 2012. New state data show children in prekindergarten are better prepared for kindergarten than those who don't attend.
  9. Leon County fifth-grader Ingrid Hanley asks the Senate Education Committee not to adopt legislation that would get tougher on D-rated schools, during a Feb. 17, 2020, session.
  10. Nadia King, 6, is smiles for a photo. The special-needs student was taken from school Feb. 4 and placed in a mental health facility under Florida's Baker Act, and now her mother and a team of attorneys are asking why.
  11. The Voluntary Prekindergarten room is one feature of the new Bardmoor Branch of the YMCA of Greater St. Petersburg. The location also includes a child-care center and Preschool Academy.
  12. FILE - In this Wednesday, Feb. 14, 2018, file photo, students hold their hands in the air as they are evacuated by police from Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla., after a shooter opened fire on the campus. School districts continue to improve their security plans in the aftermath. (Mike Stocker/South Florida Sun-Sentinel via AP, File)
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement