Over the span of 72 hours, Florida’s inmate death toll related to COVID-19 in prisons increased by nearly 28 percent, raising the total number of inmate deaths from 36 to 46 over the weekend.
As the case count and deaths accelerate, inmates’ families and advocates wonder if the Florida Department of Corrections has an alternate plan to prevent and treat COVID-19. They say whatever the prison system is doing doesn’t seem to be working.
“If no one takes notice, they are going to kill our loved ones,” said Cynthia Cooper, whose husband is incarcerated at Columbia Correctional Institution in Lake City, where at least three men have died. “I never thought I’d see the day when I was afraid of something more than him just being in prison. But it’s come to that.”
At 22 deaths, July has been the deadliest month for inmates when it comes to COVID-19. The second-deadliest month was June, during which nine inmates died. At first, inmate deaths weren’t even acknowledged by the Florida Department of Corrections until the News Service of Florida revealed them after obtaining data from a local medical examiner.
Department of Corrections spokesman Rob Klepper said in a statement that the department is “closely aligned” with Centers for Disease Control and Prevention guidelines for prisons, and that the department’s managed-care contractor, Centurion, has brought in additional staff to hard-hit prisons to provide additional testing and resources.
“The level of care and attention they have provided to the inmate population has been outstanding,” Klepper wrote, despite years of complaints about the quality of prison healthcare.
He said that at the prisons, doctors assess the inmates’ needs, and recommend outside medical care if needed.
When it comes to deaths, the state Department of Health updates a weekly data set with a total number of inmate and staff deaths sorted by facility. The data, which was not up to date as of Monday afternoon, does not identify the deaths by individual inmate. But data logged by the state’s medical examiners and obtained from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement by the Miami Herald show a fuller picture of the inmates who have died of COVID-19, beyond the facility at which they were incarcerated.
On July 25, for example, medical examiner data shows that an otherwise healthy 32-year-old woman incarcerated at Lowell Correctional Institution in Ocala was admitted to a local hospital with shortness of breath. She was diagnosed with pneumonia and COVID-19 and died 10 days later. She is the youngest inmate to die of the disease thus far. The 32-year-old’s death was one of three recorded at Lowell, a prison where testing only recently began to ramp up.
One of the other deaths was 75-year-old Martha Beatty, who died July 24, according to inmate advocate Debra Bennett, who served at Lowell with Beatty for five years and knew her well.
Bennett, who now runs a nonprofit that coordinates donations to women’s prisons, said she fears things will only get worse if the state doesn’t change course.
“With every new death, it’s apparent that they’re failing,” Bennett said. “They are just issuing death sentences …[Beatty] was a lovable old woman and she’s dead because of COVID.”
The state, which oversees more than 24,000 full-time staff and approximately 96,000 inmates, has administered 43,272 COVID-19 tests, according to numbers posted on the department’s website. Of those, 6,217 came up positive, 32,381 negative, and 4,674 are awaiting results. The numbers reflect the number of tests given, not the number of inmates who have received tests.
What can be done
Experts say the most efficient way to curb COVID-19 infections and deaths is to reduce the prison population so that social distancing can be better enforced. In Florida, groups like Families Against Mandatory Minimums and lawmakers such as St. Petersburg Republican Sen. Jeff Brandes have been advocating for policy around releasing ill and elderly inmates or even furloughing them until COVID-19 conditions change in the facilities.
In states like Louisiana, Oklahoma, Kentucky and Ohio, releases have been part of the COVID-19 strategy, Denise Rock of Florida Cares noted in an impassioned letter to Gov. Ron DeSantis, who is the only official who holds the power to make such a decision.
“For no discernible reason, Florida has not joined them,” she wrote. “Untold numbers will die unless you intervene … I am begging for your help.”
DeSantis did not respond.
When asked at an April 2 news conference about the idea, DeSantis said releasing felons wouldn’t “make things any better.”
“Some of these other states have really been releasing a lot of people. Some of these people are dangerous,” he said. “I don’t see how in a time of pandemic, where people are on edge already, [that] releasing felons in society would make a whole lot of sense.”
Correctional officers are scared too
Just like in long-term care facilities, prison staffers also can catch and transmit the disease to others. The difference is prison staff aren’t mandated to be tested every two weeks as nursing home and assisted living facility staff are. They also say they are not getting enough protective equipment, though the department disputes that point.
The number of corrections workers who have tested positive for the virus also went up from 1,318 on Friday to 1,417 Monday. While no officers are reported to have died of the disease yet, medical examiner data show one death of a man who was living with his son, a corrections officer. Both the son and his wife tested positive and were hospitalized for COVID-19 on June 19. On June 20, the 82-year-old father of the officer was found dead. The medical examiner reports he had COVID-19.
“Officers are throwing up in the corner, still being told they are OK to work,” Florida Police Benevolent Association’s James Baiardi, who represents corrections officers, told the Times/Herald last week. “They have no feeling of protection. ... They feel like nobody cares about them.”
• • •
Tampa Bay Times coronavirus coverage
HOW CORONAVIRUS IS SPREADING IN FLORIDA: Find the latest numbers for your county, city or zip code.
LATEST ON CORONAVIRUS: Six things we’ve learned about the coronavirus since March.
MASK UPDATE: Find out where you have to wear a mask in Tampa Bay
GET THE DAYSTARTER MORNING UPDATE: Sign up to receive the most up-to-date information.
HAVE A TIP?: Send us confidential news tips
We’re working hard to bring you the latest news on the coronavirus in Florida. This effort takes a lot of resources to gather and update. If you haven’t already subscribed, please consider buying a print or digital subscription.