Advertisement
  1. News
  2. /
  3. Health

The most comfortable face masks? A Tampa Bay panel tested a variety.

Testers from age 3 to 56 each wore a face mask for at least four hours and gave us feedback on comfort and function.

With school expected to start soon, kids will be required to wear face masks all day. Many of us only wear them for 30-40 minutes at a time in a store, so we might not realize how hard it can be to wear a face covering for hours at a time.

As health care workers and grocery store clerks have already learned, long-term use of masks mean more than just your glasses fogging up. You can get skin irritation and sore ears. It might take a bit of trial and error to find the style that fits right and is the most comfortable.

11 year old Luis Santana IV tested out a variety of face masks in three price ranges, wearing each one for four hours. He liked the cheap disposable one the best. [ LUIS SANTANA | Times ]

Tampa Bay public school districts have announced they will be providing cloth face masks to students and staff, but pediatricians and educators suggest practicing now to get used to wearing them for long periods.

With this in mind, we asked a panel of volunteers from age 3 to 56 to test out three different masks that they each wore for at least four hours — or at least tried to.

Related: Tips and tricks to make mask wearing more comfortable for long-term wear

Some inexpensive masks were surprisingly more comfortable than designer face coverings.

The trade-off for comfort can be that some options are safer than others. Disney World has banned the super comfortable “neck gaiters” as a face covering. The tube-style face scarves, and also home-made triangle-shaped bandanas, are banned because CDC recommendations are for “at least two layers of breathable material” that completely cover the nose and mouth to stop droplets. One study found gaiters to be worse than no mask at all.

Related: Face masks are on everyone's back-to-school list

Tampa Bay public schools have crafted face mask policies or are in the process of doing so. So far, Pasco and Pinellas counties both are considering a fairly broad interpretation of face coverings that includes scarfs, bandannas, fishing buffs and other items that will cover the wearer’s nose and mouth. Both also have crafted policies that ban coverings made of mesh or with holes of any kind.

And administrators said they will be reminding students that the school dress code applies to face masks just like it does for T-shirts, so no profane or offensive images will be allowed.

Related: Experts weigh in on the most effective face masks

Mask guidelines continue to evolve as researchers learn more about the virus. The CDC guidelines on wearing a mask suggest that it cover your nose and mouth and fit snugly to the sides of your face.

Pediatric specialist Dr. Allison Messina, the chief of the division of infectious diseases at Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital in St. Petersburg, said barriers of all kinds have been found to be effective, “especially if everyone is wearing a mask.”

There have been a number of social media posts that claim wearing a mask can be dangerous because they are depleting oxygen levels for the wearer. Those claims have been roundly debunked.

Related: Politifact: There's no evidence wearing standard masks are harmful to health

Messina said it’s more likely claustrophobia at play since a cloth mask will add some resistance to the breathing process, so it may feel like it requires more work to breathe. But it won’t materially change the makeup of air that comes through the mask, she said, or surgeons would be passing out every day.

Safety aside, there’s a new market for fashion face coverings that can cost $30 or more. Disposable brands go for as low as 50 cents each. We gave the panel of testers each a cheap disposable mask, a cloth mask in the $5-$10 range and some of the more fashionable ones made by Tampa Bay area artists.

Here are the results:

Victoria Messina, 3, Clearwater

Victoria has a small face, so finding a mask that fits can be a challenge. “The longest Victoria has been able to wear a mask continuously was for 40 minutes,” her mother, Theresa Messina, said. “Regardless of the mask, she starts fidgeting with it.”

The worst

Dr. Talbot’s printed disposable kid’s face mask, with a three-layered filter, easy bend nose clip and soft ear loops (10 for $10.99 at Winn-Dixie). The fit just wasn’t there. “It was loose even with twisting the ear loops. When she talked it fell below her nose immediately; the sides were not secure to the face.” But for the fashion part of it, she loved the shark pattern and thought it was fun. There were no problems hearing her speak, which has sometimes been an issue with masks, her mother said.

Though she liked the fun shark design, this disposable face mask was way too big for Victoria Messina, 3, who tested out a variety of face masks. [ Theresa Messina ]

The okay

A little better, but inconsistent, was the Jojo Siwa double ply machine washable face mask — a set of three printed with unicorns, rainbows and lots of pink are $10 at Target. Out of the pack of three, only one fit Victoria like the CDC guidelines recommend. The other two were too loose. But she loved the material, which is silky smooth and comes in fun designs. It had a pocket for a filter and is made of very breathable material. “Overall, we would purchase these masks for Victoria even though some of them wouldn’t fit,” Messina said.

The Jojo Siwa double ply machine washable face mask — a set of three printed with unicorns, rainbows and lots of pink are $10 at Target was a mixed mag for Victoria Messina, 3. Out of the pack of three, only one fit but she loved it. [ Theresa Messina ]

The best

The winner was a handmade kid’s mask by Kosharek Art, $12 on Etsy. It is made with vintage fabrics and has a pocket for filters and elastic bands that go around the head. It fit Victoria snug on the face but not uncomfortable. “She seems to prefer that style,” her mother said of the head strap, noting Victoria could easily put this mask on all by herself.

Victoria Messina, 3, of Clearwater liked this face mask from Etsy best in a test of a variety of face masks. The elastic bands that go around the head made it easy for the toddler to put the mask on by herself. [ Theresa Messina ]

Isadora Pendygraft, 8, Gulfport

Isadora has allergies, so some masks can feel a bit stuffy. Breathable material was the most important thing to her.

The worst

Dr. Talbot’s printed disposable kid’s face mask (10 for $10.99 at Winn-Dixie) were a little bit big and she had to tie the elastic ear bands together to make it fit better. But where this one really failed for Isadora was in fashion. “The pattern is completely inappropriate for most girls,” she wrote in her review, clearly not a fan of sharks.

A disposable mask tested by Isadora Pendygraft, 8, who will be going into third grade. [ JOHN PENDYGRAFT | Times ]

The okay

The Cat and Jack washable mask ($4 for a set of two from Target) felt scratchy on her cheeks and slid down her nose if it wasn’t positioned right. “I took it off a few times because it was scratchy and I also took it off to eat. But other than that, it was pretty good.”

A Cat and Jack mask tested by Isadora Pendygraft, 8, who will be going into third grade. [ JOHN PENDYGRAFT | Times ]

The best

The Shore swimwear mask sold at Ashe Couture Boutique in St. Petersburg was her favorite. The double ply, adjustable mask made of swimsuit material is $14 at the Central Avenue clothing store. She loved the adjusters and though it felt a bit stuffy, “that could just be my allergies.” She rated it “one of the best masks I’ve ever tried on. I love the color, although it does slide down my nose.”

Isadora Pendygraft, 8, liked this Shore swimwear mask sold at Ashe Couture Boutique in St. Petersburg. It was the third grader's favorite of the three masks she tested for form, fit and function. She liked its breathable fabric, comfort, adjustable ear straps and the fact that it matched her dress. [ JOHN PENDYGRAFT | Times ]

Madison Wagner, 10, Kenneth City

Madison wears glasses, so her biggest challenge has been finding masks that fit around her lenses correctly.

The worst

The Cat and Jack washable cotton mask (two for $4 at Target) had comfortable straps. “I liked the color and it didn’t fog up my glasses as much as the other ones.” But she found it didn’t form to her nose very well and slipped down. Also, “it was confusing which way it goes on.”

Testing face masks, Madison Wagner found the Cat and Jack washable cotton mask (two for $4 at Target) didn’t form to her nose very well and slipped down. Also, “it was confusing which way it goes on.” Photo courtesy Jessica Wagner [ Jessica Wagner ]

The okay

Dr. Talbot’s printed disposable kid’s face mask (10 for $10.99 at Winn-Dixie) felt too small for her face and for fashion “it looks too boyish with the sharks, and it also looks a little babyish.” But she found it wasn’t as itchy after four hours of wear as other disposable masks can be. On the down side, “The wire inside is not comfortable on my nose, and the elastic seems too stretched out. My glasses still fog up.”

Madison Wagner, 10, found Dr. Talbot’s printed disposable kid’s face mask (10 for $10.99 at Winn-Dixie) felt too small for her face and for fashion “it looks too boyish with the sharks." [ Jessica Wagner ]

The best

The Safe Warrior disposable face mask (20 for $15.99 at Walgreens) was the most comfortable of the three she tested. “I would wear this one the most because I can breathe easier,” she said. It didn’t fog up her glasses, formed to her nose nicely. As for fashion, “It makes me look like a doctor.” She did find, however, that it felt itchy after wearing it for awhile outside in the heat. “It feels wet when you sweat in it.”

Madison Wagner, 10, of Kenneth City found the Safe Warrior disposable face mask was the most comfortable of the three she tested. But it didn’t score many fashion points. “It makes me look like a doctor.” Photo courtesy Jessica Wagner. [ Jessica Wagner ]

Luis Santana IV, 11, Brandon

This sixth grader towers over his father at 6 feet 2 inches tall, so most kids’ masks don’t fit his face very comfortably.

The worst

The 1771 Designs hand washable mask ($12 at 1771designs.com or at Shapiro’s Gallery in downtown St. Petersburg) was his least favorite. The biggest issue was its lack of a nose bridge — it kept exposing his nose. A tag inside scratched his face while he talked and he felt like he had to keep adjusting the mask. Being a Brandon resident, he didn’t understand the green pelican that is a popular image in St. Petersburg.

11 year old Luis Santana IV tested face masks and his biggest issue with this one was its lack of a nose bridges so his nose kept popping out of it. [ LUIS SANTANA | Times ]

The okay

A Cat and Jack black and camouflage cotton mask ($4 for a set of two at Target) was the best looking, he said, but it was too small for his face. Because it was small on him, he couldn’t finish the four-hour test because it irritated the skin behind his ears.

A Cat and Jack black and camouflage cotton mask from Target was the best looking but was too small for Luis Santana IV, who tested a variety of face masks for four hours at a time. [ LUIS SANTANA | Times ]

The best

The Safe Warrior disposable face mask, which has a flexible nose bridge (20 for $15.99 at Walgreens) was his favorite in terms of fit, comfort and perceived protection. The elastic band of the mask was comfortable and thin, which he said did not irritate as much as the others after wearing it awhile. It got the lowest rating in the fashion category, but, “I want to feel protected and don’t care about looks,” he said.

11 year old Luis Santana IV tested out a variety of face masks but this disposable one was his favorite. “I want to feel protected and don’t care about looks,” he said. [ LUIS SANTANA | Times ]

Ashleigh Wagner, 14, Kenneth City

Like her younger sister, the teenager also wears glasses and is looking for masks that don’t fog up her lenses. One trick she has learned is to twist the elastic straps to pull the mask on tighter and that sometimes reduces the fogging.

The worst

The Cat and Jack washable cotton kids’ mask (two for $4 at Target) seemed to fit her face the best but felt tight on her face and ears. It was blue with dinosaurs on it so it was a little boyish, but at least it wasn’t plain. She found it confusing to put on and it irritated her ears after a few hours, “especially if I get sweaty.”

The Cat and Jack washable cotton kids’ mask (two for $4 at Target) felt tight on her face and ears Ashleigh Wagner found it irritated her ears after a few hours in a test of a variety of face masks. [ Jessica Wagner ]

The okay

She found the material in the Safe Warrior disposable face mask (20 for $15.99 at Walgreens) uncomfortable, “but the strings don’t tug and it fit around my ears nicely.” Out of the three she tested, she says she would wear this one the most because it’s lightweight and not tight. But it was a dud for fashion. “It looks like it came from a hospital. It’s not very stylish.”

Out of the three she tested, Ashleigh Wagner found the Safe Warrior disposable face mask (20 for $15.99 at Walgreens) the one she would wear this one the most. But it was a dud for fashion. [ Jessica Wagner ]

The best

The most fashionable mask was a handmade cotton pleated mask ($12 from Florida CraftArt in St. Petersburg.) It felt too big, so she would have gone with a smaller size, but “I like that it’s reversible and that you could have it made with fabrics that I chose.”

Ashleigh Wagner, 14, of Kenneth City tested out wearing a handmade cotton pleated mask ($12 from Florida CraftArt in St. Petersburg) for four hours. “I like that it’s reversible and that you could have it made with fabrics that I chose.” [ Jessica Wagner ]

Boyzell Hosey, 56, St. Petersburg

The Tampa Bay Times deputy editor of photography is often called on to shoot photos in live news scenes and his goal is to blend in, not stand out, while documenting events. He also shoots pictures while walking around in the blazing heat, so breathability is vital for work.

The worst

“I was really excited to try the Dali mask with the notable artwork The Disintegration of the Persistence of Memory,” Hosey said ($7.48 at the Dali Museum store in St. Petersburg) of the print better known to fans as The Melting Clock. “I was impressed by the workmanship description on the label: Cloth masks (92 percent nylon, 8 percent spandex) are treated with biocompatible, hydrophobic splash resistant finish – one size fits most, how could I go wrong? Well to put it bluntly this mask was more suitable for framing than for wearing! It was hard to breathe just sitting at my computer let alone moving around. The craftsmanship and fit left a lot to be desired, I constantly pulled at my mask trying to readjust it. At one point I became very aware of the mask’s presence as it inched up my cheeks to just below my eyes. The fit was not snug, and the ear loops looked like they were cut by a pair of scissors. Honestly, it felt like a worthy craft project from some left-over material. The filter pocket was appreciated, and I did slide a PM 2.5 filter inside, but it didn’t help.”

This mask from the Dali Museum was beautiful but Boyzell Hosey found it the least comfortable the three face masks he tested [ BOYZELL HOSEY | Times ]

The okay

The Safe Warrior disposable face mask (20 for $15.99 at Walgreens) was the most comfortable of the three tested to wear for extended periods of time. “My breathing was easy and not labored as with other masks. The fit was snug and contoured to my face easily. Psychologically, and perhaps practically, I felt a boost of self-confidence with presenting a clean mask when out in public. As a photographer on the go quite a bit I didn’t get easily overwhelmed with heat with the Safe Warrior.”

This inexpensive disposable mask was the most comfortable of the three face masks Boyzell Hosey tested. [ BOYZELL HOSEY | Times ]

The best

The Goodfellow cloth mask ($4 for a set of two size large/XL at Target) wasn’t as comfortable as the Safe Warrior, “but this was certainly my favorite. I love its durability in that it’s washable and the material was lightweight and it was fairly easy to breathe. I even added a PM 2.5 filter in the built-in pocket and that gave me an added measure of safety and confidence. Also, the masks fit well like the disposable surgical type mask, but much more stylish with its minimalist look.”

This Goodfellow cloth mask, available for $4 for a pack of two from Target, was Boyzell Hosey's favorite of the three face masks he tested. It was lightweight and breathable while also being subdued. The Times set up a panel of testers of a variety of ages to wear different [ BOYZELL HOSEY | Times ]

• • •

Tampa Bay Times coronavirus coverage

HOW CORONAVIRUS IS SPREADING IN FLORIDA: Find the latest numbers for your county, city or zip code.

LATEST ON CORONAVIRUS: Six things we’ve learned about the coronavirus since March.

MASK UPDATE: Find out where you have to wear a mask in Tampa Bay

GET THE DAYSTARTER MORNING UPDATE: Sign up to receive the most up-to-date information.

THE CORONAVIRUS SCRAPBOOK: We collected your stories, pictures, songs, recipes, journals and more to show what life has been like during the pandemic.

HAVE A TIP?: Send us confidential news tips

We’re working hard to bring you the latest news on the coronavirus in Florida. This effort takes a lot of resources to gather and update. If you haven’t already subscribed, please consider buying a print or digital subscription.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

Advertisement
Advertisement