1. Health

Disputed HCA trauma centers would be protected by House plan

The Regional Medical Center Bayonet Point is among three HCA trauma centers being challenged by other trauma centers that contend the state acted improperly in allowing them to open.
Published Mar. 12, 2014

TALLAHASSEE — Three HCA trauma centers that are being challenged in court would be protected under a measure that advanced in the Florida House on Tuesday — even as legislators expressed concern over hospital billing practices revealed in a Tampa Bay Times investigation.

A House committee agreed to sponsor the bill, which would allow Regional Medical Center Bayonet Point in Pasco County, Blake Medical Center in Manatee County and Ocala Regional Medical Center in Marion County to continue operating. All three have been challenged by other trauma centers that contend the state acted improperly in allowing HCA to open them.

A yearlong investigation by the Times found that trauma centers across the state are charging thousands of dollars just to get through the doors, a fee that frequently goes even to patients who are not severely injured.

The average trauma response fee in Florida has risen from $2,555 in 2006 to $10,825 last year, an increase 20 times the rate of inflation.

HCA, whose average $28,000 trauma response fee is by far the highest in the state, has opened six trauma centers in recent years, including the three affected by the new proposal. If it can win state approval, the company has ambitions to open more this year.

The Times found the trauma fee frequently is just the start of the high charges. HCA hospitals, as a group, are charging tens of thousands of dollars more in average total charges than Florida's other trauma centers.

That information wasn't enough to stop the House's Health Innovation Subcommittee from approving the proposal on an 8-4 vote, with members of both parties on each side of the issue.

Committee Chairman Jason Brodeur, R-Sanford, said the bill should end ongoing lawsuits and administrative hearings pushed by hospitals with long-standing trauma centers that accused the state of approving new centers improperly.

The legacy centers argue that too many trauma centers can actually reduce quality of care by spreading specialists and money too thin, and have petitioned to get the newer centers shut down. Brodeur says that shouldn't be allowed to happen.

"Forcing these trauma centers to close and reapply under new rules would have a negative impact on the health and safety of the residents of these regions," Brodeur said.

Rep. Doc Renuart, a Ponte Vedra Beach physician, was the only Republican to vote against the measure, saying the Legislature should not be intervening.

"I don't believe that injecting politics into this is the right answer," Renuart said.

Jeffrey Frehn, an attorney for Tampa General Hospital and Bayfront Health St. Petersburg, said the bill would allow HCA to skirt rules that determine when and where new centers are needed.

"There is no justification for allowing the HCA trauma centers to circumvent the need requirement that every other trauma center is subject to," he said. Bayfront has been particularly hard hit by the opening of Bayonet Point to its north and Blake to its south.

But the HCA centers also had advocates in the room Tuesday.

"At least for Ocala, don't take it away from us because you'll get a whole bunch of crazy women like me coming up here yelling," said Dawn Bowman, whose relative was treated at the HCA trauma center there.

Brodeur introduced the proposal Tuesday by imploring his colleagues not to factor the Times' findings into its deliberations.

"We've heard a lot about charges in these facilities in the last few days, but cost charges and reimbursement in trauma care is a complicated matter not addressed in this bill," Brodeur said.

Hospitals face virtually no government oversight of how they set their charges. Trauma patients have no choice in where they are taken for care, and so are obviously in no condition to comparison shop.

Brodeur said those facts concern him, and he wanted to look more into the Times' report. Tuesday, he said he wasn't prepared to discuss including cost controls in the trauma center bill, but suggested he might consider it later.

"It's a separate issue, but I think it's germane to the bill and would be something we would be interested in looking at, certainly," he said.

The bill would allow any trauma centers that have been in existence for at least 12 months to remain open as long as they submit an application to the American College of Surgeons Committee on Trauma for a site visit by June 31, 2015.

The Senate has a separate proposal that grandfathers in the three existing HCA trauma centers and also sets new standards for approving future centers. Senate Bill 1276 hasn't been heard in committee yet.

Hospitals are an important special interest group, contributing millions of dollars to political parties, committees and campaigns each election cycle.

HCA has contributed $1.3 million this cycle, including donations to nearly every member of the House committee that reviewed the trauma center proposal Tuesday. The Florida Hospital Association has contributed $207,000 so far.

Times/Herald staff writers Letitia Stein and Mary Ellen Klas contributed to this report. Tia Mitchell can be reached at or (850) 224-7263.


  1. Fifty-two percent of Americans support a ban on the sale of electronic cigarettes with fruit and other flavors, according to new Kaiser Family Foundation poll. TONY DEJAK  |  AP
    But a smaller percentage supports banning all forms of the product. Most younger adults oppose both ideas.
  2. FILE - In this Thursday, Dec. 20, 2018 file photo, Juul products are displayed at a smoke shop in New York. On Thursday, Oct. 17, 2019, the company announced it will voluntarily stop selling its fruit and dessert-flavored vaping pods. SETH WENIG  |  AP
    The flavored pods affected by the announcement are mango, crème, fruit, and cucumber.
  3. Travis Malloy who runs an 8-acre farm with his assistant Shelby Alinsky on the east side of Temple Terrace, raises organic beef, pigs, turkeys and chickens. Malloy has also set up a number of...
  4. Dr. James Quintessenza, left, will return as the head of the Johns Hopkins All Children's heart surgery program department. UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY HOSPITAL  |  Times
    The heart surgery program’s mortality rate spiked after the surgeon left, a 2018 Times investigation revealed.
  5. Stephanie Vold, a medical assistant and intake specialist for OnMed, holds the door while Austin White, president and CEO of the company, talks with a nurse practitioner during a demonstration of their new telehealth system at Tampa General Hospital on Tuesday. The hospital is the first to deploy the OnMed station and plans to install them at other locations. OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    The closet-size “office” with a life-size screen is another example of the changing face of medicine.
  6. Marijuana plants grow in a greenhouse environment in this room at the Curaleaf Homestead Cultivation Facility. This environment controls the amount of natural sunlight and artificial light the plants are exposed to, as well as the temperature. EMILY MICHOT  |  Miami Herald
    An Atlanta broker is listing one license for $40 million and the other for $55 million.
  7. A page from the Medicare Handbook focuses on Medicare Advantage plans, which have become increasingly popular in recent years. Medicare's open enrollment period for 2020 begins Oct. 15 and lasts through Dec. 7. PABLO MARTINEZ MONSIVAIS  |  AP
    New benefits are giving an extra boost to Medicare Advantage, the already popular alternative to traditional Medicare.
  8. The Tampa Bay Times' annual Medicare Guide explains how the program is set up, helps you compare options available in the Tampa Bay area, and points the way toward help, including free, one-on-one assistance. This illustration will grace the cover of LifeTimes on Oct. 23, when the guide will be published in print. RON BORRESEN  |  Tampa Bay Times
    As the open enrollment period begins, it’s time to review your coverage.
  9. The Medicare Handbook for 2020 is a good resource to have as the annual open enrollment period gets under way. The government usually mails beneficiaries a copy. Find a PDF version to print at, or call 1-800-633-4227 (1-800-MEDICARE) to order a copy. THOMAS TOBIN  |  Tampa Bay Times
    The open enrollment period, which lasts into December, is a time for millions of beneficiaries to review, and possibly change, their coverage.
  10. Medicare's online Plan Finder has been redesigned and is available at THOMAS TOBIN  |  Tampa Bay Times
    The most-used tool on will look different this year.