1. Health

Florida lawmakers consider tough law to protect assisted living facilities

Published Jan. 20, 2012

After years of stripping away critical protections at assisted living facilities, Florida lawmakers are radically changing course in what could lead to one of the toughest laws in the nation against abusive caretakers.

With rampant abuse across the state, key lawmakers are calling for homes to be shut down when residents die from shoddy care and caretakers banned from the industry, in the biggest changes in state law since the creation of ALFs a generation ago.

Unveiled this week by two Senate committees, the dual bills follow months of reports by the Miami Herald that showed frail elders were living in squalor and dangerous conditions while regulators failed to crack down on the worst abusers.

"(The state) wasn't doing its job," said Sen. Nan Rich, a Weston Democrat and vice chair of the Children, Families and Elder Affairs Committee. "They were not enforcing the regulations and not closing down facilities that didn't correct the violations and abuse."

Not since the creation of ALFs four decades ago in Florida have lawmakers proposed such comprehensive legislation to improve oversight, including mandatory penalties in fatal neglect cases and creation of a public rating system for homes based on their regulatory rap sheets.

The bills also strip away some power from Florida's regulator, the Agency for Health Care Administration, which has drawn fire for failing to shutter troubled homes, even after caretakers were found abusing residents to death.

The bills from Rich's committee and the Senate's Health Regulation Committee — both including strikingly similar reforms — come after eight months of intense pressure on state leaders to radically improve an industry that has surpassed nursing homes as the primary residences for the elderly and mentally ill in Florida.

Among the proposals, the state would:

• Strip the license of any home where a resident dies from abuse or neglect. Under current law, the agency can impose much weaker sanctions — or do nothing at all.

• Slap the maximum fines on homes caught abusing or neglecting residents to death, without resorting to making settlements.

• Dramatically increase the qualifications for ALF administrators, from a high school diploma to a college degree with coursework in health fields or two years of experience caring for residents.

• Impose criminal penalties for caregivers and administrators who falsify medical and other ALF records.

• Allow family members of residents to install so-called "Granny Cams" in rooms to help detect caregiver abuse, as long as relatives sign agreements to respect the privacy of others.

• Allow residents to appeal a home's decision to force them out, giving residents the chance to remain at the home until a hearing is held.

The emergence of the bills comes after revelations that residents were regularly dying of abuse and neglect — nearly one a month since 2002 — while the state was carrying out fewer inspections.

The Herald found that while abuse and neglect cases doubled since 2005, the state dropped crucial inspections by 33 percent.

Under the bills, state agents would be required to increase their trips to homes where they have found a history of violations that threaten the safety of residents.

"It's time to get rid of some of the bad actors," said Sen. Don Gaetz, a Destin Republican and member of the health committee. "This is about protecting vulnerable people."

Both bills strongly support increasing the educational requirements for people to run ALFs: bachelor's or associate degrees with emphasis in health fields or prior experience in resident care. Current managers would be grandfathered in with one exception: no severe violations at their homes in the prior two years.

Larry Polivka, who led a governor's task force examining problems in ALFs, said the bills tackle several issues raised by the panel, including improving care for the mentally ill.

"We were behind the curve on regulatory issues," said Polivka, scholar in residence at the Claude Pepper Center at Florida State University. "We needed to close the gap."

One key proposal: AHCA professionals must visit homes catering to the mentally ill four times a year to ensure residents are properly treated.

While the bills are supported by some of Florida's most powerful senators — including Ronda Storms, a Republican from Valrico who chairs the Children, Families and Elder Affairs Committee — they are expected to draw opposition from industry leaders and some House members.

Just last year, lawmakers pushed 16 pieces of legislation that would have gone in the opposite direction and weakened oversight of ALFs, including stripping away penalties on repeat offenders — but the bills were pulled from consideration in May after the Herald's series.

Rich said she expects a fight in the House, where the last serious effort to reform ALFs was killed in 2008.

"They have not indicated the same commitment to passing significant legislation," she said.


  1. In this Sept. 6, 2019, photo, Donna Cryer holds up family photos that include her father Roland Henry, as she poses for a photo in Washington. When her father died, she tried to donate his organs, yet the local organ collection agency said no, without talking to the family or providing a reason. "It was devastating to be told there was nothing they considered worthy of donation. Nada. Not a kidney, not a liver, not tissue,” recalled Donna Cryer, president of the nonprofit Global Liver Institute and herself a recipient of a liver transplant. SUSAN WALSH  |  AP
    Under U.S. transplant rules, the country is divided into 58 zones, each assigned an “organ procurement organization” in charge of donation at death.
  2. Kreshae Humphrey, 26, bathes her daughter, Nevaeh Soto De Jesus, 3, inside of a baby bath tub in the middle of their living room. The parents bathe all three of their girls with bottled water because they believe the children were sickened by the tap water at the Southern Comfort mobile home park off U.S. 19 in Clearwater. The family is suing the park's owner over the issue, but the owner and the state say there are no problems with the drinking water there. MARTHA ASENCIO-RHINE  |  Times
    The owner of Southern Comfort denies there are problems with the drinking water. But the park is still being shut down. All families must be out by Oct. 31.
  3. An arm of the Department of Health and Human Services is taking steps to establish a National Volunteer Care Corps that would recruit healthy retirees and young adults to help seniors live independently. The ranks of Americans age 85 and up are set to swell to 14.6 million in 2040, up from more than 6 million now. Times (2010)
    A federal agency is exploring a national volunteer program modeled after the Peace Corps to help care for the booming elderly population.
  4. Medicare can be confusing. But there's help from trained counselors for SHINE. Serving Health Insurance Needs of Elders is a free program offered by the Florida Department of Elder Affairs and your local Area Agency on Aging. Michele Miller
    Columnist Michele Miller shares her husband’s journey to get on Medicare and how local volunteers can help seniors navigate the system.
  5. Ana Martinez, a medical assistant at the Sea Mar Community Health Center in Seattle, gives a patient a flu shot. Some signs are already pointing to an active flu season in the Tampa Bay area. [TED S. WARREN   |   Associated Press]
    One area hospital has seen a sharp increase this month in children coming in with flu-like symptoms. Health officials are urging people to get a flu shot.
  6. Vagner Lage, 27, and Ayana Lage, 26, pose with a sonogram of their child. JOHN PENDYGRAFT   |  Times
    Pregnancy loss can be isolating and carry guilt and shame. It’s time to end that.
  7. FILE - This 1975 file microscope image made available by the the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention shows chlamydia trachomatis bacteria magnified 200 times. U.S. infections from three sexually-transmitted diseases have risen for the fifth consecutive year and broken more records. More than 1.7 million cases of chlamydia were reported in 2018. DR. E. ARUM  |  Dr. E. Arum, Dr. N. Jacobs/CDC via AP, File
    The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention released the numbers on Tuesday. The increases coincided with public health funding cuts and clinic closures.
  8. President Donald Trump speaks to his supporters at the Sharon L. Morse Performing Arts Center in The Villages on Oct. 3. OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    While the executive order spells out few details, it calls for the removal of “unnecessary barriers” to private contracting.
  9. Thomas Perlmann, far right, Secretary-General of the Nobel Committee announces the 2019 Nobel laureates in Physiology or Medicine during a news conference in Stockholm, Sweden, Monday Oct. 7, 2019. The prize has been awarded to scientists, from left on the screen, Gregg L. Semenza, Peter J. Ratcliffe and William G. Kaelin Jr. receiving the award jointly for their discoveries of "how cells sense and adapt to oxygen availability". PONTUS LUNDAHL/TT  |  AP
    The scientists identified the biological machinery that regulates how genes respond to varying levels of oxygen.
  10. President Donald Trump signs an executive order on Medicare Advantage while his supporters look on including Florida Governor Ron DeSantis at the Sharon L. Morse Performing Arts Center in The Villages on Thursday. OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    The president took aim at overhaul plans being advocated by his Democratic opponents.