1. Health

State draws scrutiny for decision to keep thousands of children out of health program

Pediatric cardiologist Louis St. Petery battles for standards.
Pediatric cardiologist Louis St. Petery battles for standards.
Published Oct. 11, 2015

Florida lawmakers are starting to ask questions about continuing allegations that state officials are dismantling a health program for thousands of sick and disabled children.

At issue: the new tool used to determine eligibility for the Children's Medical Services program, which manages medical care for about 70,000 low-income kids with serious and chronic conditions. Since the screening tool was introduced in May, about 9,000 children have been dropped from the plan, state records show.

The Florida Department of Health's Chief Operating Officer Jennifer Tschetter has said the changes were necessary to "ensure that only children with chronic and serious health conditions were part of the (program)" in light of concerns about its $826 million budget.

But a group of physicians allege the overhaul has hurt some of the state's most vulnerable kids.

"They dumped them on the regular Medicaid Managed Care program, which is ill-equipped to take care of them," said Dr. Louis St. Petery, a pediatric cardiologist who practices in Tallahassee. "That's unfair to the kids and the families."

A health department workshop on the screening tool is scheduled for Friday in Tallahassee.

Lawmakers are already demanding answers. Last week, Tschetter was called to testify before the Senate Health and Human Services Appropriations Subcommittee.

Sen. Chris Smith, D-Fort Lauderdale, said lawmakers were "starting to hear from constituents and others about kids falling through the cracks."

Sen. Aaron Bean, R-Fernandina Beach, said he had sat down with several parents and physicians, "some of whom were in tears over the changes and how they are coming about."

Tschetter said the kids who had been moved into Medicaid plans were receiving comparable care.

Unlike the old screening tool, which relied on input from clinicians, the new tool is a parent survey. The health department says it is based on a "nationally recognized model," and was developed from a work group that included national experts.

The department began using the survey to screen candidates for the program on May 4. The tool was also used to determine if children who were already in the program would remain eligible.

The changes caught the attention of the program's regional medical directors, more than a dozen of whom sent a letter to Deputy Secretary of Health Celeste Philip saying there had been "a significant decrease in access to care for these vulnerable children."

"We are concerned that Florida CMS no longer provides the high quality care it once did," they wrote.

In June, the families of four children who had been dropped from the program filed a legal challenge, saying the new tool had not gone through the state's formal rule-making procedure.

Though the state argued it was exempt from rule-making — and pointed out that previous tools had not gone through the process — Administrative Law Judge Darren Schwartz sided with the families. He ordered the department to stop using the new screening tool in late September.

But now the state says it won't be able to enroll new children in the Children's Medical Services program until it formally adopts a screening tool. The process will begin with Friday's hearing.

Other changes to CMS may also be under way. The state is considering eliminating a separate rule that requires pediatric cardiac facilities to comply with certain standards, and will hold a hearing on the issue Monday .

The state says the rule "extends beyond the (health) department's statutory authority." But St. Petery called it "the gold standard nationwide," and said Florida had become "very famous for having such an outstanding kids cardiac program for poor kids."

State health officials have tried to assuage concerns by creating a Children's Medical Services advisory panel made up of four physicians, a registered nurse, health care executive and parent. The department also recently announced that CMS had earned full national accreditation from the Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Health Care.

In her Senate appearance last week, Tschetter called the approval of a screening tool a "top priority" for the health department. She conceded that some of the feedback from doctors had been less than favorable — but didn't sound ready to reverse course, either.

"I don't know that we will move completely away from a parent-based model," she said. "There is good literature to support that that is the way to determine what 'serious (medical conditions)' might be."

Senate Health Budget Chairman Rene Garcia, R-Hialeah, said lawmakers would be "keeping a close eye" on the process.

"We're trying to make sure all the kids that need to get covered are covered," he said.

Contact Kathleen McGrory at or (727) 893-8330. Follow @kmcgrory.


  1. A new report to the Florida Legislature details the investigation that led to the forced resignations of six Moffitt Cancer Center employees in December, including president and CEO Dr. Alan List. [Moffitt Cancer Center]
    The money came from the “Thousand Talents Program” and went to personal accounts set up in China.
  2. The C.W. Bill Young VA Medical Center at Bay Pines VA Healthcare System. (Times | 2014)
    The chief justice dropped an ‘Okay, Boomer’ reference during oral arguments in the case of a pharmacist who accused the Bay Pines VA Healthcare System of age discrimination.
  3. Six of the 11 Pinellas County Head Start preschool centers found to have mold problems earlier this month are still closed. A few more could reopen next week, but some could be closed longer. [Google Maps]
    Five of the 11 affected locations have reopened, but hundreds of children can’t go back to their preschool yet.
  4. University of South Florida student Daniella Morales, center, gets information from health insurance navigators Lauren Lambert, left, and Dorothea Polk, right, during an event in November at USF in Tampa. [OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times]
    The state’s decision not to expand Medicaid is one reason for the big number. Still, about 2.7 million people are uninsured.
  5. Century Tower rises at the center of the University of Florida campus, where four medical school researchers recently were found to have had foreign interactions that violated university rules. [University of Florida]
    In a scenario similar to last month’s revelations about Moffitt Cancer Center, four UF faculty members were found to have ties with foreign recruitment programs.
  6. Jami Claire, 62, one of two plaintiffs accusing the state of Florida of sex discrimination because state health plans exclude coverage for gender affirming treatment. [Courtesy of Nancy Kinnally]
    Supported by the ACLU of Florida and Southern Legal Counsel, two women are suing the state.
  7. John Nobel, a clinical perfusionist at Tampa General Hospital, winds up a power cord to one of the hospital's new Organ Care System machines. The devices work to keep donated organs functioning for longer periods of time. [Tampa General Hospital]
    The ice-and-cooler method is giving way to a device that pumps blood, oxygen and nutrients into donor organs during transport.
  8. County commissioners agreed Wednesday to pursue a local ordinance establishing a needle exchange program in Hillsborough County. [C.M. GUERRERO  |  Miami Herald]
    If approved, used syringes could be swapped for free, sterile ones
  9. More than 800 people gathered in 2018 in St. Petersburg to remember the thousands in Tampa Bay who have died from opioid abuse. As bad as the numbers are, the problem is being underreported by the federal government, according to a new study from the University of South Florida. [Times (2018)]
    Routine delays in toxicology results are one reason for the lapse.
  10. Florida health officials say there were nearly 3,400 hepatitis A cases in 2019. (Joshua A. Bickel/Columbus Dispatch/TNS)
    As of Saturday, Pasco County had the most cases in the state in 2019, with 414.