1. News
  2. /
  3. Hernando

Ethics concerns over two Brooksville officials were unfounded

Earlier this month, the Florida Commission on Ethics ruled that no laws were broken in the cases of two former Brooksville mayors.
Brooksville City Hall
Brooksville City Hall
Published Dec. 23, 2019

BROOKSVILLE — Only rarely are local officials scrutinized by the state ethics board, but earlier this month, the board reviewed the actions of two former Brooksville mayors and determined that concerns about law violations were unfounded.

The Florida Commission on Ethics looked into a complaint that Natalie Kahler, former Brooksville city council member and mayor, broke a law that prohibits public officials from lobbying their former agencies for money for two years. In June, Kahler was named executive director of the Brooksville Main Street Program, which is partially funded by the city.

In an unrelated case, the board ruled on whether former mayor and current council member Robert Battista broke state nepotism rules when the City Council discussed giving the city clerk a $10,000 raise. Jennifer Battista, his wife, is the city clerk.

In Kahler’s case, local businesswoman Lori Sowers raised the ethics question. Kahler resigned from the council in 2018 to run for the Hernando County Commission, but she was unsuccessful. She planned to run again in 2020, but dropped that plan when the Brooksville Main Street job came open.

Sowers, a local accountant, has been among those questioning the finances of the Main Street program and its parent the Brooksville Vision Foundation. In her complaint, Sowers said Kahler actively sought funding for the Main Street program from the city and county tourism offices.

The ethics commission advocate recommended no finding of cause. She cited a previous decision involving a person who served an agency and a new employer that had a common mission.

"The two entities -- the City Council and the Foundation operating as Main Street -- have a shared, unified interest in benefiting the city of Brooksville, '' wrote advocate Elizabeth Miller, in recommending that Kahler be cleared on the complaint. The commission agreed.

“I’m glad to have it over with," Kahler said. "Not that it was stressful, but it took a lot of time for the attorney.''

After the complaint was filed, Kahler stepped away from directly addressing the council on various issues. That created more challenges with communication between the city and Main Street, Kahler said.

"They’ve been complaining about communicating, and I couldn’t communicate with them,'' she said.

In the Battista case, Jennifer Battista had been a city employee on and off for 20 years when the city manager named her city clerk last year. Robert Battista said at the time he wanted to make sure he was not violating any rules. The council plays no role in selecting a city clerk, the ethics commission said, and cleared him of any concerns.

This year, during budget discussions, other council members suggested a $10,000 increase in Jennifer Battista’s salary. Robert Battista again raised a concern that, even if he recused himself from voting on her raise, he might have to leave the council.

The city attorney asked for a ruling, which was acted on by the ethics commission on December 6.

The City Council’s decision to increase the clerk’s salary would not create a nepotism problem for Robert Battista as long as the increase was within the bounds of the existing job description, the commission ruled.

Battista, who has served as both a city and a county attorney monitoring ethics issues for elected officials, said he was glad to have a formal ruling.


  1. Ryan Lotito Sr., left, of Spring Hill pitches to his son Ryan Lotito Jr. to work on his swing techniques at the Anderson Snow Sports Complex in Spring Hill.
  2. Hudson High student Kaitlyn Helzer introduces herself to a curious corn snake during the Nature Coast Envirothon, held Feb. 19 at Dade Battlefield Historic State Park in Sumter County. Students from Pasco, Hernando, Sumter and Citrus counties tested their knowledge on aquatics, forestry, soils and wildlife while vying for a spot at state competition. [MICHELE MILLER  |  Times]
  3. The Southwest Florida Water Management District has declared 1,044 acres of its Annutteliga Hammock property in northwest Hernando County surplus. Most of those parcels are in the  area of Royal Highlands. The district has been seeking buyers for the individual parcels. [Tampa Bay Times]
  4. Associate professor of biology Caitlin Gille leads the Pasco-Hernando State College faculty union, which challenged the school's public comment rules.  (Photo Courtesy of Caitlin Gille)
  5. Anthony Jackson, 24, of Spring Hill, faces burglary and grand theft auto charges. Tyreece Germe, 23, whom deputies identified as one of Jackson’s accomplices in some tow truck misadventure, also faces a grand theft auto charge. [Hernando County Sheriff's Office]
  6. Hernando County community news [Tara McCarty]
  7. Tampa Bay Lightning owner Jeff Vinik  [Times staff]
  8. The annual Paulie Palooza festival in downtown Zephyrhills draws a big crowd to a day filled with eight bands performing on the Main Street Stage, food trucks along Fifth Avenue and a variety of vendors. This year's event will be from noon to 9 p.m. Feb. 29, and is a benefit for Gulfside Hospice. [Kirsty Churchill/Gulfside Hospice]
  9. Hernando County community news [Tara McCarty]
  10. A "for sale" sign beckons Friday along Sixth Avenue N in the Kenwood area of St. Petersburg. [CHRIS URSO  |  Times]
  11. Check for the latest breaking news and updates. [Tampa Bay Times]