1. News
  2. /
  3. Hillsborough

Jurors in Tampa murder trial confront ultimate question: Could they impose the death penalty?

Jury selection continued in the murder trial of Granville Ritchie, who is accused of strangling 9-year-old Felecia Williams in 2014.
Granville Ritchie is seen in a Tampa courtroom just prior to jury selection Monday. Ritchie is accused in the May 2014 killing of 9-year-old Felecia Williams. [CHRIS URSO | Times]
Published Sep. 10
Updated Sep. 10

TAMPA — Not long after they crammed into six rows of wooden benches this week in Hillsborough County’s largest courtroom, dozens of people were asked a question few ever have to answer: Could they sentence a man to death?

Late Monday and into Tuesday, the 93 prospective jurors who said they knew nothing about the case of Granville Ritchie and could commit to attending a three-week trial learned for the first time the gravity of what was before them.

They were told that Ritchie is accused of strangling a 9-year-old girl named Felecia Williams in 2014. They were told that he is also accused of raping her. And they were told that the state plans to seek capital punishment.

Related story: 'You can’t get over it." Mother works to preserve memory of daughter who was slain at age 9

Brows furrowed when the jurors heard the wording of the indictment. They gazed at Ritchie, who sat at a defense table wearing a crisp black suit jacket with a handkerchief tucked in the front pocket. He looked back at them.

“In criminal law, it doesn’t get any more serious than what we’re dealing with here,” Hillsborough Assistant State Attorney Scott Harmon told the panel.

The prosecutor explained that the trial will have a guilt phase and a penalty phase. The 12 people selected to serve on the jury will first have to decide if Ritchie is guilty. If he is, they will then have to decide if the 40-year-old man’s crimes merit the death sentence.

The state will have to prove the existence of at least one aggravating factor — a circumstance that suggests death may be an appropriate sentence. In Ritchie’s case, the prosecution has claimed two aggravating factors: that the victim was less than 12 years old and that the crime was committed during a sexual battery and an aggravated child abuse.

The jury will also hear about mitigating factors: circumstances his defense might present to argue that his life should be spared.

Felecia Demerson, center, the mother of Felecia Williams, speaks with a victim advocate as Jerome Williams, right, the father of Felecia Williams, looks on just prior to jury selection Monday for Granville Ritchie. Ritchie is accused of killing Williams in May of 2014. [CHRIS URSO | Times]

Related story: Five years later, trial set in slaying of Tampa girl known as Sugar Plum

On Monday, Ritchie’s attorneys filed a notice listing 10 mitigating factors they want to bring up. They include a claim that Ritchie suffered a head injury as a child, that he suffered mental and physical abuse throughout his upbringing, and that he grew up amid poverty and violence in his native Kingston, Jamaica.

The jurors were told they must be unanimous for a death sentence to be imposed. If anyone disagrees, the sentence will be life in prison without parole.

The identities of jurors are shielded by the courts during trials. Several expressed moral objections to capital punishment.

“There have been a lot of things in the news about people who were wrongfully convicted," said one man. “Because of things like that, I would never support the death penalty.”

Another said he works as a registered nurse. His job, he said, is to help people and heal the sick.

“I don’t think I should be able to take a life.” he said.

Some said capital punishment was contrary to their religious values, that they could not live with themselves if they played a part in imposing a death sentence.

“I think it’s barbaric under any circumstance,” said another man. “It doesn’t bring anything back.”

A woman sitting near the rear of the courtroom, her face buried in the crowd, told the court she was against the death penalty, but waffled on the issue. She said if something happened to her or her loved ones she would have to consider the circumstances.

“I’m morally against it,” she said, “but I do have to put myself in the shoes of other people as well."

Harmon, the prosecutor, asked her to imagine what she would do if she was selected for the jury in the Ritchie case. He told her she would be seated steps away from Ritchie, that she would be able to see him writing notes and chatting with his attorneys.

“He’s going to be breathing and he’s going to be blinking and he’s going to be fully alive,” Harmon said. “And at some point, the state of Florida is going to ask you to sentence him to death ... Can you do that?”

“I honestly have to say I don’t know,” the woman said.

Other jurors were less hesitant. Many said they felt death could be an appropriate sentence, depending on the severity of the circumstances.

For much of Tuesday afternoon, defense attorney Bjorn Brunvand asked his own questions. He wanted to know: if a person is found guilty of premeditated murder, did anyone think that death should be the only penalty?

“The most appropriate (penalty),” said one woman, adding that she would lean toward the state’s position in such a case.

Brunvand asked if there were certain factors that would sway her even further toward death.

“When it’s a child,” she said.

By the end of Tuesday, 23 jurors were dismissed. They included those who said they could not sentence someone to death, or that death was the only penalty they’d consider for premeditated murder. Jury selection will continue Wednesday.


  1. Titan Goodson points to visitors in the courtroom during his unsuccessful motion to dismiss the manslaughter charge against him Thursday. SCOTT KEELER  |  Scott Keeler
    Titan Goodson’s lawyer argued there was no proof he supplied the heroin that killed Katie Golden, 17. Trial is set for December.
  2. A 20-year-old Plant City man was seriously injured Thursday night after he lost control of the car he was driving on the Selmon Expressway and hit a guardrail, which Florida Highway Patrol troopers said “impaled” the car. FHP
    The driver was taken to Tampa General Hospital with serious injuries.
  3. Steven Currall prepares to deliver an address during his investiture as the University of South Florida's seventh president Thursday at the Yuengling Center in Tampa. MARTHA ASENCIO-RHINE  |  Times
    Though he started the job in July, Steve Currall is officially installed as president on his 137th day in office.
  4. Apollo Global Management has offered $130 per share for Tech Data's stock in an acquisition worth $5.4 billion. If regulators shareholders approve, the home-grown company will remain based in Pinellas County, where it employs 2,000 of its 14,000 workers. DIRK SHADD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Private equity firms like Apollo create wealth for pension funds, financial institutions and individual investors by buying assets that typically are sold later at a profit.
  5. USF student Gabriela Young is the owner of Earth and Ivory, an online jewelry business with items made out of clay.  [Special to the Times | Sarah Foster] SARAH FOSTER  |  Special to the Times | @sarahtheartiste
    Gabriela Young went from selling bracelets to friends to making clay wares for customers with her business, Earth and Ivory.
  6. Chief Veterinarian Mallory Offner examines a female rescue puppy at the Hillsborough County Pet Resource Center in Tampa. MARTHA ASENCIO-RHINE  |  Times
    With 250 of the pooches ready for adoption, each potential puppy parent has a 1-in-4 shot at getting picked in today’s drawing.
  7. Eight vehicles were involved in a fiery and fatal crash late Wednesday that left two people dead and shut down northbound Interstate 75 bridging Hillsborough and Pasco counties, authorities said. The driver of the white van pictured above, George Pagan of Tampa, said he saw the semi-trailer truck, left, sliding sideways toward him in his rearview mirror before impact. Pasco Fire Rescue
    The chain-reaction crash that closed the northbound lanes near the Pasco-Hillsborough line started when a semi-trailer truck driver didn’t stop for traffic, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.
  8. Hillsborough Community College solicited "non-binding letters of interest or intent” last month from developers interested in purchasing the Dr. Gwendolyn W. Stephenson District Administration Center on Davis Islands. OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    Developers have eyed the 3.7 acre waterfront parcel for years, but recent interest has prompted the college’s trustees to finally start the conversation.
  9. Left: Janis Joplin performs (AP Photo). Right: Joplin's booking photo (Courtesy of Tampa History Center). Tampa Bay Times
    Police let Joplin finish her set at Curtis Hixon Hall before arresting the singer in her dressing room.
  10. Yesterday• Hillsborough
    The Exercise Coach offers personalized strength training workouts for clients of all ages and fitness levels. Courtesy of The Exercise Coach
    Slated to open in late November, The Exercise Coach offers strength training workouts in a setting that differs from traditional gyms.