Advertisement
  1. News

One man's battle over beach access brings a ruling that could affect other Florida towns

This beach access just south of the Don Cesar Hotel in St. Pete Beach is at the center of a recent court ruling that could have repercussions for coastal cities and beachfront property owners. [DIRK SHADD   |   Times]
This beach access just south of the Don Cesar Hotel in St. Pete Beach is at the center of a recent court ruling that could have repercussions for coastal cities and beachfront property owners. [DIRK SHADD | Times]
Published May 31, 2018

ST. PETE BEACH — The city will have to pay a property owner's estate nearly $1.5 million, a federal appeals court has ruled in a case that could have huge repercussions for coastal cities and beachfront property owners.

"We are very disappointed and are still evaluating what the city can or cannot do about this decision," City Attorney Andrew Dickman said in an interview, adding: "This opinion has a broad reach, affecting a lot of coastal communities."

At its most basic, the case sharply penalizes the city for encouraging the public to trespass on privately owned beach property and sets a precedent for similar cases involving disputes between beachfront property owners and their local governments.

The decision comes just as a new state law will go into effect July 1 that makes it easier for property owners to bar the public from their private beaches, estimated to include about 60 percent of the state's beaches.

The law restricts local governments from establishing public access to privately owned beaches, defined as the dry sand area upland of the mean high water line.

"Lots of people don't understand that the beach can be owned privately. Visitors here assume all the beach is public," Dickman said.

As interactions between governments and private beach owners increase, he said, there could be similar high-damage awards against coastal cities.

The May 16 ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit upheld an earlier federal District Court jury verdict that found St. Pete Beach "encouraged and invited" the public to use a private beach, "causing the seizure" of residential property.

Under the ruling, the city will pay damages but also receive a "permanent easement" across the private property "for the benefit of the public."

Just how that easement will be defined was referred back to the U.S. District Court for final resolution.

Dickman said the city has "several options" it can choose as a result of the ruling, including appealing to the U.S. Supreme Court.

That option may be unlikely, however, since the appeals court decision referenced a previous Supreme Court decision that said a government could not take an easement to cross a privately owned beach without paying for it.

Dickman indicated he will ask the City Commission to hold a closed session to discuss how it will respond to the court ruling.

The case began in 2009 when Chet Chmielewski, now deceased, filed a lawsuit against the city, claiming it had illegally taken his beachfront property by encouraging the public to walk by the side of his home to reach a privately owned beach.

Chmielewski purchased his home, located just south of the Don CeSar Hotel, in 1972, including acquiring fee simple title to a 50-foot wide and 300-foot deep portion of the beach.

Chmielewski had been a frequent critic of the city for years, particularly after it refused his request to develop beachfront townhomes on his property in 2005.

In another lawsuit in 2008, he sued, forcing the city to agree the public had no right to access the private beach area.

After the Don Vista Community Center — located just to the north of the Chmielewski property — was renovated, he complained repeatedly that the city encouraged people using the center to access the beach.

The city had cleared a direct public access path from a mini-park to the beach and installed "Beach Access" signs.

Several times Chmielewski blocked a private beachfront sidewalk only to have the city confiscate his lawn chair barricade and threaten to arrest him.

He sued the city again, claiming it had violated its 2008 settlement. Both the district and appeals courts agreed.

At trial, witnesses testified that the area around Chmielewski's property was "quiet, serene, pleasant and peaceful" before the Don Vista renovation, and that, afterward, people frequently walked alongside the Chmielewski home to reach the beach.

During the dispute, Chmielewski filed and won another lawsuit against the city, this time involving a Sunshine Law violation. The city had to pay $125,000 in legal fees for that case.

Now, the Chmielewski estate is to be another $1.5 million richer, and the city has a court-approved public easement not only to the beach access path but to the entire Chmielewski beach property.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. Jesse Michael Chester, 40, was arrested on 20 counts of possession of child pornography and two counts of video voyeurism, according to the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office. [Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]
    A child porn investigation led to secretly recorded videos of adults using the bathroom, according to the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office.
  2. Pinellas Sheriff Bob Gualtieri, left, and Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody were appointed to the Presidential Commission on Law Enforcement and the Administration of Justice by Attorney General Bob Barr. [Tampa Bay Times]
    Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody will also join a commission that will “explore modern issues affecting law enforcement," according to the Department of Justice.
  3. Clockwise from left: Cheesy Sriracha Funnel Cake Bites, Piña Colada Candy Apple, Candy Corn and Cheeseburger-On-A-Stick [Courtesy of the Florida State Fair]
    Cheesy Sriracha Funnel Cake Bites, Piña Colada Candy Apples and more are coming to the Florida State Fair.
  4. Hillsborough County Sheriff's deputy Alton Smith helps recover items Wednesday from Lake Twitt in Odessa during a dive team practice. Divers used the drill to search for evidence of a forgotten African American cemetery nearby. [CHRIS URSO   |  Times]
    Keystone Memorial Cemetery was established by a freed slave and disappeared in the 1950s. The dive team chose Lake Twitt to do its monthly practice.
  5. In this Aug. 28, 2013, file photo, Joseph Maldonado answers a question during an interview at the zoo he runs in Wynnewood, Okla. (AP Photo/Sue Ogrocki, File) [SUE OGROCKI  |  AP]
    A federal judge sentenced Joseph Allen Maldonado-Passage to 22 years in prison for trying to arrange the killing of Carole Baskin.
  6. St. Petersburg Police Chief Anthony Holloway, left, and U.S. Attorney Maria Chapa Lopez announce the creation of the regional Tampa Bay Human Trafficking Task Force. [SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times]
    A six-county task force from Hernando to Polk to Sarasota will band together thanks to a $742,000 Justice Department grant.
  7. In this image from video, House impeachment manager Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., speaks during the impeachment trial against President Donald Trump in the Senate at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, Wednesday. (Senate Television via AP) [AP]
    After late-night deliberations over the rules almost ensured no new witnesses will be heard, the trial picked up speed
  8. More than 44 percent of people who searched on ApartmentList.com for the Tampa Bay area from June to December were outside the region, according to a report from Apartment List. Percentages in the “Top Three Sources” box represent the share of searches coming from outside the metro area. (Apartment List map) [Apartment List]
    The region trails only Denver, Baltimore and San Diego for the percentage of people from outside the area searching for apartments on Apartment List.
  9. To accommodate the swelling numbers of aging baby boomers, experts say we will need to make transportation more readily available, build more affordable housing, modify homes and apartments to help seniors age in place, and create programs to bring young and old people together. [Times (2011)]
    “There’s never been a time like this,” one expert says. Solutions include more health aides, taming long-term care costs and just healthier living.
  10. The northbound lanes of I-275 were closed for more than four hours early Tuesday morning as troopers investigated a deadly crash. [Florida Highway Patrol]
    Police pulled over their vehicle for driving the wrong way on Fifth Avenue S, but the driver took off and crashed shortly after.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement