Monday, September 24, 2018
News Roundup

Romano: A modern debate in a historic neighborhood

The house is toast. Let’s begin there.

Built in the 1920s, and neglected in recent years, it needs a major overhaul at the very least and is probably better off being torn down to its foundation. Folks are mostly in agreement on this point.

After that, the story gets messy.

Developer Richard McGinniss bought the home in St. Petersburg’s Old Northeast neighborhood three years ago and, if you believe his neighbors, was always intending to replace it with a McMansion.

Meanwhile, the folks on 18th Avenue sought to have their 10-house street designated as a historic district with the sole purpose, if you believe McGinniss’ attorney, of blocking his client’s plans.

And that’s where we’re at today:

With the City Council being asked, essentially, to decide whether to side with a frustrated homeowner or his unhappy neighbors. There’s a lot of other technical stuff, but that’s the gist of it.

So why should you care?

Because this type of dispute is going to become more and more common, especially in St. Pete where historic districts are being approved with increasing regularity.

"We believe if the city allows him to do this, it’s going to negate the protections a lot of these mini historic districts thought they were being given,’’ said Britt Cobb, who has opposed the plans submitted by McGinniss. "We don’t think the house fits the guidelines whatsoever, and it’s only going to lead to more of this speculated development in historic neighborhoods.’’

Neighbors did not fight McGinniss on the proposed demolition of the house, as long as the proposed replacement fit the 1920s style and size of other houses in their recently anointed historic district.

His first proposal was denied by officials, but subsequent revisions were okayed by city staff and eventually the city’s preservation commission. Neighbors contend, however, that the city did not follow its own rules and procedures during the process, and are appealing to the council today.

Attorney Don Mastry, who represents McGinniss, said the blessing of the city’s staff proves this is not about size or style or architecture. McGinniss has previously built larger, modern homes in nearby communities, and Mastry said neighbors in Old Northeast were determined to keep him off their street.

"They don’t like him. This whole historic district was created just to stop him,’’ Mastry said. "This is personal. It has nothing to do with height or square footage.’’

So who’s right?

There’s a lot to be said for preserving the flavor, and yes the history, of our neighborhoods. And if a majority of residents are in agreement, they have every right to establish rules and guidelines to protect the investment they have made in their homes.

But I have a problem with retroactively applying rules. If McGinniss had bought the house after the historic designation had been created, then he should be obligated to follow those standards. But changing the rules on him months after spending close to $400,000 on a house seems unfair.

"Every house in the neighborhood was bought before the vote, so when do you start the clock?’’ asked Emily Elwyn, president of Preserve the ’Burg. "This is a really important decision because it is going to set the tone in terms of whether we build houses that fit the characteristics and flavor of neighborhoods or whether we’re going to allow houses that are not appropriate for a district.’’

I would guess council members will be sympathetic to the arguments of neighbors and preservationists. They will agree with almost every point.

And they still won’t reverse the decision.

If that happens, Cobb said neighbors may pursue litigation against the city for failing to follow its own rules.

Meanwhile, demolition and construction would begin. McGinniss has been living in the house and planned to make it his home after the rebuild, but now may be having second thoughts about his neighbors.

"He bought it with intention of making it his residence,’’ Mastry said. "I don’t think he is really too enthusiastic about that now.’’

Comments
Judge reschedules John Jonchuck trial for spring 2019

Judge reschedules John Jonchuck trial for spring 2019

CLEARWATER — The day the murder trial of John Jonchuck was supposed to begin, attorneys met instead to discuss a new trial date.The trial, which was supposed to begin Monday, was derailed last week after Jonchuck’s defense attorneys raised concerns a...
Updated: 20 minutes ago
Fall may have arrived, but Tampa Bay area will still feel the heat

Fall may have arrived, but Tampa Bay area will still feel the heat

Falling leaves, cool winds and pumpkin spice characterize the autumn season, which began Saturday. But the Tampa Bay area won't be seeing any differences in our recent hot streak until mid-October, and even then it could be short-lived.Temperatures t...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Hillsborough deputy fatally shoots wife, turns gun on himself with children in home

Hillsborough deputy fatally shoots wife, turns gun on himself with children in home

LAND O'LAKES -- A Hillsborough County sheriff's deputy fatally shot his wife early Monday morning before turning the gun on himself in an apparent murder-suicide, according to the Pasco County Sheriff's Office. In an early-morning news conference, P...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Firefighters respond to blaze in Lakewood High School gymnasium

Firefighters respond to blaze in Lakewood High School gymnasium

St. Petersburg firefighters responded to a fire early Monday morning in the gymnasium at Lakewood High School.According to St. Petersburg Fire Rescue, firefighters responded to the school around 5:40 a.m. after a maintenance worker discovered the fir...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Rick Stroud previews Bucs-Steelers

Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Rick Stroud previews Bucs-Steelers

The Bucs host the Steelers tonight as Monday Night Football comes to town. Will the FitzMagic continue and move Tampa Bay to 3-0? Rick Stroud breaks down the game. Also, Tony Dungy will be enshrined in the team's Ring of Honor.Plus, is there any...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Five new details on Clearwater parking space shooting

Five new details on Clearwater parking space shooting

More than two months have passed since Michael Drejka shot Markeis McGlockton in the parking lot of a convenience store.While developments in the headline-grabbing case have slowed to a trickle as it crawls through the court system, the Tampa Bay Tim...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Hooper: Don’t trade progress for pennies. Reject Amendment 1

Hooper: Don’t trade progress for pennies. Reject Amendment 1

A lot of Tampa Bay city and county elected officials should be sounding the alarm about Amendment 1.The amendment, one of 12 voters will find on the November ballot, increases the maximum homestead exemption from $50,000 to $75,000, but the devil is ...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Drive for January: A look at how the top Group of 5 teams fared

Drive for January: A look at how the top Group of 5 teams fared

For the first time this season, we're examining how USF stacks up in comparison to the other serious Group of Five contenders for the New Year's Six bowl berth.The Group of Five conference champion ranked highest by the College Football Playoff commi...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Port Tampa Bay marks 1 million cruise passengers in a year for the first time ever

Port Tampa Bay marks 1 million cruise passengers in a year for the first time ever

TAMPA — Port Tampa Bay last week welcomed its 1-millionth cruise ship passenger for the first time ever in a single year.The port hit the milestone on Sept. 17, when the count hit 1,000,524 for this fiscal year, which ends on Sept. 30. It rose furthe...
Updated: 3 hours ago
The Daystarter: Building a wall against Red Tide; PolitiFact on a proposed $1 billion tax hike; Dungy goes into Ring of Honor

The Daystarter: Building a wall against Red Tide; PolitiFact on a proposed $1 billion tax hike; Dungy goes into Ring of Honor

Catching you up on overnight happenings, and what to know today.• We’ll have scattered afternoon showers and thunderstorms, according to the National Weather Service. Highs today will be in the lower 90s.• As you head out for your morning commute, c...
Updated: 3 hours ago