1. News

Judges question constitutionality of state's red-light cameras, toss cases

A red-light traffic camera is visible which is one of two cameras posted on US 41 (Broad Street) near Wiscon Road in the City of Brooksville on Thursday, May 17, 2012.
Published Dec. 27, 2013

In operation for a little more than 18 months, Brooksville's red-light cameras may be earning the city revenue, but they haven't won a lot of fans.

Opponents of the program sound off at nearly every City Council meeting. And this year saw the launch of a citizen-backed campaign that seeks to put the issue of the camera program before city voters in 2014.

But perhaps the most significant blow to the cameras came during the past year when two Hernando County judges threw out some red-light camera cases, saying the state law governing them was constitutionally unclear.

In May, County Judge Donald E. Scaglione issued an order, not based on any specific traffic case, stating why he would begin dismissing right-turn-on-red cases, and calling the portion of the state law dealing with right-on-red violations "vague (and) arbitrary and capricious." The 2010 Mark Wandall Traffic Safety Act governing traffic camera programs, he said, created a defense that says a right turn on red, without the motorist stopping, is permissible if the turn is made "in a careful and prudent manner," but fails to define those terms, leading to arbitrary rulings.

Right-on-red violators who went before County Judge Kurt Hitzemann heard similar comments from the bench. Nearly 400 drivers got their citations tossed out as a result of the dispute.

But things didn't end there. State Attorney General Pam Bondi objected to Scaglione's actions and argued that state law requires that the attorney general be notified and given an opportunity to be heard when a party alleges that a state law is unconstitutional. In a motion, she asked the judge to order defendants to put their constitutional challenges in writing, then set a hearing to consider the challenges.

A September hearing that was attended by Bondi's representative, Robert Dietz, yielded plenty of debate, but no definitive answer as to the law's constitutionality.

One of more than 70 cities and municipalities statewide that currently have the cameras, Brooksville installed its system in May 2012. A majority of City Council members who voted for them said they supported them for public safety reasons.

Logan Neill, Times staff writer


  1. Dr. James Quintessenza, left, will return as the head of the Johns Hopkins All Children's heart surgery program department. UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY HOSPITAL  |  Times
    The heart surgery program’s mortality rate spiked after the surgeon left, a 2018 Times investigation revealed.
  2. Toby Johnson is the new principal of Martinez Middle School. MARLENE SOKOL  |  Times staff
    The School Board also suspended Martinez Middle’s former principal.
  3. Former NFL running back Warrick Dunn spends time with new homeowner LaToya Reedy and her son, AnTrez, at 918 43rd St. S. SCOTT KEELER  |  Times
    The retired Tampa Bay Buccaneer running back partnered with Habitat for Humanity and others to give a hardworking nursing assistant and her son the home of their dreams.
  4. Duke Energy Co. workers are competing in a line worker competition in Kansas this week. | [Courtesy of Duke Energy Florida] Duke Energy Florida
    Four Duke Energy Florida competitors are from Tampa Bay, as well as two coaches.
  5. An 18 month-old girl died after being left in a car Monday. No charges are expected, police say. WFTS  |  Courtesy of
    No charges are expected after 18 month-old girl was left in a Jeep as her father took a truck to work, police say.
  6. University of South Florida forensic anthropologist Erin Kimmerle pieces together a skull that might have been Amelia Earhart's. SANDRA C. ROA  |  University of South Florida
    DNA from a skull found in 1940 could prove whether the famous aviator has been found.
  7. Alexandra Toigo, 32 and Sabrina Pourghassem, 23, pose for a photo at Hofbrauhaus St. Petersburg holding their signature beer mugs during Oktoberfest 2018. "LUIS SANTANA  |  TIMES"  |  Tampa Bay Times
    The beer hall’s property owners filed a lawsuit saying the restaurant missed its rent starting in August.
  8. Port Tampa Bay on Tuesday agreed to sell a half-acre it owns near the Florida Aquarium for $4.7 million to Streams Capital of Tampa, which is looking at building a 33-story condominium and hotel tower. RICHARD DANIELSON | Times
    The buyer, Streams Capital of Tampa, is looking at building a 33-story tower with a hotel, condominiums and retail.
  9. Nearly a year after it was left abandoned and half-sunk off the Tampa side of the Howard Frankland Bridge, a salvage crew finally raised and towed the Moonraker II to the Courtney Campbell boat ramp. It is slated to be crushed. OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    The boat was an eyesore to those who live off Tampa Bay. Then it became a political statement. Now it’s been towed and will soon be crushed.
  10. Republican Sen. Joe Gruters said Florida consumers are required to pay the sales tax, but rarely do so if online sellers don't collect it.
    The Senate Commerce and Tourism Committee unanimously approved the bill Tuesday.