1. News

St. Pete Beach to sue its former lawyers over fees

Published Sep. 14, 2016

ST. PETE BEACH — After spending about $2 million in legal fees to defend against multiple legal actions challenging its development rules, the city wants a large chunk of its money back and is going to court to get it.

The City Commission voted unanimously Tuesday to file a malpractice lawsuit against its former law firm, Bryant Miller Olive, that will seek restitution of the $625,000 the city spent for opposing attorney fees, as well as an unknown amount of potential damages.

One of those cases originally involved alleged city encroachment and land-taking of beachfront property owned by the late Chet Chmielewski, and the other involved resident James Anderson's challenge to the city's development regulations.

During litigation of those cases, the commission met in closed session with its BMO lawyers to discuss the cases.

When lawyers for Chmielewski and Anderson were denied transcripts of those meetings, they sued, claiming the city had violated the Sunshine Law.

Though the city prevailed in Circuit Court, it lost both cases before the Second District Court of Appeal and was forced to reimburse Chmielewski's and Anderson's legal fees.

The city subsequently fired BMO, hired a new city attorney, Andrew Dickman, commissioned an investigation of BMO's actions, and now has hired a trial attorney, James Rolfes, to pursue the malpractice case against BMO.

Dickman said Tuesday that Rolfes "has concluded the city has a valid case against BMO."

The commission's vote came just weeks before the statute of limitations was slated to run out on the malpractice action. The city will be seeking damages against both BMO and the individual attorneys who represented the city.

Though they were not named, those attorneys include Susan Churuti and Mike Davis.

Ben Hill, an attorney defending BMO, said Wednesday that the law firm did nothing wrong.

"At the time of the meetings, there was no case law. Now we have conflicting judicial decisions," Hill said, stressing that "BMO exercised its best judgment at the time."

Hill also said if BMO wins in the city's malpractice action, the city might be liable for BMO's attorney's fees. If the city wins, it will be responsible only for an estimated $50,000 in court fees. Rolfes has taken the case on contingency, which means his time will be paid out of any final court award or settlement.


  1. Travis Polk, 30, seen here in a public photo on his Facebook page, died on Nov. 16, 2019, six days after he was critically injured in a fight with his half brother Jose Vasquez, Jr. outside of Brandon Crossroads Bowl, authorities say. Vasquez was charged with manslaughter. Facebook
    Travis Polk, 30, died after his head hit the pavement multiple times while fighting with Jose Vasquez, Jr., who is now charged with manslaughter, records show.
  2. The New York Times newspaper on the shelf at the Citrus County Library Lakes Region at 1511 Druid Rd. on Thursday, Nov. 7, 2019 in Inverness. The Citrus County Commison was looking to eliminate the cost of the New York Times digital subscriptions because they say it is "Fake News." A former Mets GM has stepped up and wants to donate money to the Citrus County Libraries to cover the cost of the subscriptions. DIRK SHADD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    After Citrus commissioners voted down the digital subscription, library leaders say they cannot accept thousands of dollars from GoFundMe pages.
  3. In this Nov. 2, 2017, photo, Carter Page, a foreign policy adviser to Donald Trump's 2016 presidential campaign, speaks with reporters following a day of questions from the House Intelligence Committee, on Capitol Hill in Washington. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite) J. SCOTT APPLEWHITE  |  AP
    The finding is part of a Justice Department inspector general investigation into the FBI’s probe of ties between the Trump campaign and Russia during the 2016 election.
  4. President Donald Trump speaks during a cabinet meeting at the White House, Tuesday, in Washington. (AP Photo/ Evan Vucci) EVAN VUCCI  |  AP
    The President called in to “Fox & Friends” to say he was trying to root out corruption in the Eastern European nation when he withheld aid over the summer.
  5. An aerial view of Florida Ave. directly across from E. Kentucky Ave. where Zion Cemetery is once located.  Today, the property is owned by Richard Gonzmart. SANTANA, LUIS  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Richard Gonzmart says he previously misspoke. He expects to know for sure by the end of the year.
  6. Check for the latest breaking news and updates. Tampa Bay Times
    He was taken by helicopter to Bayfront Health St. Petersburg as a “trauma alert” with potentially life-threatening injuries
  7. Pinellas Pasco Circuit Court Judge William H. Burgess III, listens in court Friday during a hearing in the case against James Rybicki, 63. Burgess earlier this month wrote an excoriating order tossing out evidence collected in a search of Rybicki's home, saying prosecutors and detectives lied to obtain the warrant. SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Prosecutors did not drop charges against Rybicki at a Friday hearing, despite a judge’s order in which he excoriated investigators for lying to obtain a search warrant. The judge wrote the cause could...
  8. A Spirit Airlines plane before getting ready to push back and depart from one of their four gates at the Tampa International Airport on Tuesday. Spirit, a low-cost, Florida-based airline, has increased the number of cities it serves from Tampa 50 percent in two years. And in a recent 12-month period, Spirit's passengers accounted for 38 percent of the airport's total growth in passengers. Spirit is not only raising its profile in Tampa. It is pursuing rapid growth nationwide, with plans to move its corporate headquarters from Miramar to a new $250 million headquarters building in Dania Beach in Broward County. DIRK SHADD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    In 12 months, the number of passengers at Tampa International Airport has grown by about 1.1 million. Spirit Airlines accounts for 38 percent of those fliers.
  9. David Paul Wipperman, 61, of Largo, was arrested Thursday on charges of felony battery and burglary of an occupied vehicle. Pinellas County Sheriff's Office
    She rolled down her window to apologize but got a mouthful of food instead.
  10. Bob Duggan, second from right, receives the 2016 Venky Award from Rod Alferness, dean of the College of Engineering at UC Santa Barbara. Duggan, a longtime Church of Scientology member, says he has given much more to church causes than the previously reported $360 million, and continues to do so. ERIC ISAACS
    Absent from Scientology publications since his 2017 divorce, Bob Duggan had a lot to say. He tells the Times he’s still a dedicated member and donor.