1. News
  2. /
  3. Military

New questions on why we’re in Afghanistan give way to bigger one: What’s next?

The war has been run from CentCom in Tampa, where one former commander saw inconsistent strategy from above.
Marines evacuate an Afghan civilian injured by insurgent gunfire in Helmand Province during fighting in 2011. New questions have arisen over what's next for U.S. involvement in Afghanistan, 18 years after troops first invaded. [KEVIN FRAYER  |  ASSOCIATED PRESS]
Marines evacuate an Afghan civilian injured by insurgent gunfire in Helmand Province during fighting in 2011. New questions have arisen over what's next for U.S. involvement in Afghanistan, 18 years after troops first invaded. [KEVIN FRAYER | ASSOCIATED PRESS]
Published Dec. 13, 2019
Updated Dec. 13, 2019

TAMPA — U.S. Central Command directs military operations in Afghanistan out of MacDill Air Force Base, guiding the troops — including men and women from the Tampa Bay area — who have fought the nation’s longest war.

Now, peace negotiations are resuming with the Taliban militants whom the United States first set out to depose and a new account of insider interviews in the Washington Post drives home the futility of a campaign that seems to have lacked a consistent strategy.

Eighteen years after the invasion of Afghanistan, the same question faces people touched by the war in Tampa and nationwide: What now?

To many, the answer seems no clearer than it has ever been.

“We want to make it simple, but it’s not simple,” said former CentCom commander William Fallon.

To Fallon, the Trump administration’s move to prioritize a peace settlement with the Taliban amounts to the latest example in a long history of bureaucrats chasing the wrong solution to a problem that grows more complicated as it drags on.

RELATED: CentCom’s role has evolved since 9/11

During his yearlong tenure at CentCom, ending in March 2008, the retired Navy admiral said he faced pushback from both the U.S. and Afghan governments over approaches he sought to pursue. Strategies and policies from on high were inconsistent, Fallon told the Tampa Bay Times, and even attention to Afghanistan came and went.

Among those who have been in the trenches of the war, there is conflict over what to do next.

The nonprofit Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America polled its members earlier this year and found that among 1,600 respondents, 57 percent agreed the conflict should end immediately. Yet 51 percent disagreed with the idea that the United States should pursue a peace deal with the Taliban.

For the United States to end its intervention in Afghanistan, consistency is key — now as it has always been, said Laurel Miller, director of the Asia Program at the International Crisis Group headquartered in Belgium.

A peace settlement has come and gone as a goal in U.S. policy for some time, Miller said. What’s new with the approach of the Trump administration is prioritizing a settlement above all other options.

But for such a measure to work, the United States must demonstrate a consistent commitment to negotiations, Miller said. When talks about a partial removal of U.S. troops on the ground were close to fruition earlier this year, President Donald Trump pulled the plug because of a deadly car bombing carried out by the Taliban.

The history of the Afghanistan conflict is full of pivots in strategy — a pattern revealed in new detail by the Post’s publication of hindsight interviews with U.S. diplomats and military leaders conducted by the Office of the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction.

Miller pointed to a pattern of failure to match policy and strategy with realistic analysis and expectations.

One example: Eliminating corruption in Afghanistan emerged as a priority in the U.S. counterinsurgency plan even though such a goal was never realistic, Miller added.

There were small and significant successes along the way, said Lindsay Rodman, executive vice president of Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America who served as a Marine in Afghanistan. Rodman, based in New York, cited the opening of a women’s clinic as an example.

But they never added up to a cohesive strategy, she said: “The mission has been confusing over time."

Today the Department of Defense points to Trump’s South Asia Strategy which includes a political settlement in lieu of a battlefield victory.

“We remain in Afghanistan to protect our national interests and ensure that Afghanistan is never again used as a safe haven for terrorists who threaten the United States,” Lt. Col. Thomas Campbell, a Department of Defense spokesman, said in an email to the Tampa Bay Times.

A peace settlement with the Taliban isn’t the only option but may be the only realistic one, said James Dobbins, a former U.S. diplomat and current senior fellow at the California based RAND Corp. think tank.

Dobbins, quoted in the report by the Post, identified the two alternatives in an interview with the Times: Push for victory in war or withdraw all remaining troops and create a humanitarian crisis in the region.

Former President George W. Bush had no interest in negotiating with the Taliban while his successor President Barack Obama agreed to open talks but only with the involvement of the Afghan government.

Trump has shown a willingness to reach an interim agreement with the Taliban separately, setting the stage for possible integration later between the Taliban and the government, Dobbins said.

But the latest push for a final settlement faces its own risks from new complications.

Afghanistan is still awaiting the results of an election two months ago and the question of whether Trump stays the course with negotiations remains up for debate — especially after a Taliban attack Wednesday on a medical center attached to the largest U.S. military base in Afghanistan.


  1. This undated file photo provided by the FBI shows Mohammed Alshamrani. The United States is preparing to remove more than a dozen Saudi military students from a training program and return them to their home country after an investigation into a deadly shooting by Saudi aviation student Alshamrani at a Florida navy base in December 2019, a U.S. official told The Associated Press. [AP]
    Many of the 21 cadets had contact with child pornography and possessed jihadist or anti-American material, William Barr said.
  2. MacDill Air Force Base now requires all visitors looking to enter the base to show either Department of Defense ID or valid photo ID with a base pass. [Air Force photo] [HANDOUT  |  Air Force]
    U.S. installations have increased security as tensions with Iran run high, and that includes the bases and veterans’ facilities in the Tampa Bay area.
  3. MacDill Air Force Base in Tampa was briefly on lockdown Friday morning after reports of an armed person near the Tanker Way Gage. The lockdown has been lifted and all gates except the Tanker Way Gate have been lifted. [Times (2018)]
    McDill Air Force Base is investigating a report of an armed person, but a lockdown at the base has been lifted
  4. Rescue workers carry the body of a victim of an Ukrainian plane crash among debris of the plane in Shahedshahr, southwest of the capital Tehran, Iran, Wednesday, Jan. 8, 2020. A Ukrainian airplane carrying 176 people crashed on Wednesday shortly after takeoff from Tehran's main airport, killing all onboard. (AP Photo/Ebrahim Noroozi) [EBRAHIM NOROOZI  |  AP]
    The cause of the crash is currently under investigation
  5. Coffins of Gen. Qassem Soleimani and others who were killed in Iraq by a U.S. drone strike, are carried on a truck surrounded by mourners during a funeral procession, in the city of Kerman, Iran, Tuesday, Jan. 7, 2020. A stampede erupted on Tuesday at a funeral procession for a top Iranian general killed in a U.S. airstrike last week, killing 35 people and injuring 48 others, state television reported. (AP Photo) [AP]
    The stampede took place in Kerman, the hometown of Revolutionary Guard Gen. Qassem Soleimani, as the procession got underway.
  6. Traci Lenz said this is what her kitchen vent looked like even after mold remediation at her MacDill Air Force Base home. [Courtesy of Traci Lenz]
    Over the last year, families reported mold and other problems in military housing at MacDill and other bases.
  7. A woman mourns in a demonstration over the U.S. airstrike in Iraq that killed Iranian Revolutionary Guard Gen. Qassem Soleimani in Tehran, Iran, Friday. Iran has vowed "harsh retaliation" for the U.S. airstrike near Baghdad's airport that killed Tehran's top general and the architect of its interventions across the Middle East, as tensions soared in the wake of the targeted killing. (AP Photo/Vahid Salemi) [VAHID SALEMI  |  AP]
    Iran vowed “harsh retaliation” for a U.S. airstrike near Baghdad’s airport that killed a top Iranian general.
  8. Soldiers board a C-17 aircraft Wednesday, Jan. 1, 2020 at Fort Bragg, N.C., to be deployed in Iraq. (Melissa Sue Gerrits/The Fayetteville Observer via AP) [MELISSA SUE GERRITS  |  AP]
    The President ordered about 750 U.S. soldiers deployed to the Middle East as about 3,000 more prepare for possible deployment in the next several days.
  9. U.S. soldiers fire tear gas towards protesters who broke into the U.S. embassy compound, in Baghdad, Iraq, Tuesday, Dec. 31, 2019. Dozens of angry Iraqi Shiite militia supporters broke into the U.S. Embassy compound in Baghdad on Tuesday after smashing a main door and setting fire to a reception area, prompting tear gas and sounds of gunfire. (AP Photo/Khalid Mohammed) [KHALID MOHAMMED  |  AP]
    The embassy attack, one of the worst in recent memory, followed deadly U.S. airstrikes on Sunday that killed 25 fighters of the Iran-backed militia in Iraq, the Kataeb Hezbollah.
  10. Those who play in a foursome with Julius Okrzesik marvel at how straight he drives the ball. The World War II veteran, 99, is also regarded as one of the better putters at the Bardmoor Golf and Tennis Club in Seminole. [MARTHA ASENCIO RHINE  |  Times]
    Julius Okrzesik, who flew 87 missions over Europe, never misses a round of golf with his buddies each Tuesday.