1. Pinellas

John Jonchuck, convicted of daughter's murder, asks for new trial

John Jonchuck is led out of the courtroom after he was found guilty of first-degree murder on April 16. [SCOTT KEELER | Times]
Published Apr. 26

John Jonchuck's public defenders on Friday filed a motion asking for a new trial, arguing that several decisions made by the judge during the four-week murder trial that ended with a conviction this month were improper and unfair to Jonchuck.

The motion laid out 11 reasons Jonchuck's lawyers think he deserves a new trial, almost all related to pieces of evidence or testimony the judge either let the jury hear or didn't.

"The strength of the motion is how many issues there are," public defender Jessica Manuele, who drafted the motion, said in a phone interview. "Where one thing may not have warranted a new trial alone, the totality of the errors should."


The motion will be weighed by the same judge who presided over the trial, Pinellas-Pasco Circuit Judge Chris Helinger, who can act upon it or set a hearing. Manuele said her team will likely file additional documents next week.

The motion is significant because it's the first of several post-conviction moves Jonchuck's lawyers are likely to make, and it previews the appeal lawyers likely will later file if this motion fails.

Pinellas-Pasco State Attorney Bernie McCabe said Friday that he hadn't seen the motion and wouldn't comment on the substance. But, he dismissed the tactic as "standard operating procedure."

"Every time we win a case, the defense lawyer will file a motion for new trial," he said.

Jurors on April 16 found Jonchuck guilty of first-degree murder in the Jan. 8, 2015 death of his daughter, 5-year-old Phoebe Jonchuck, siding with prosecutors who argued Jonchuck was driven by vengeance when he dropped her off the Dick Misener Bridge. He was sentenced to life in prison.

PREVIOUS COVERAGE: The Long Fall of Phoebe Jonchuck

They said he was angry at his mother, who abandoned Jonchuck as a little boy but returned to shower affection on Phoebe in a way she never did upon him. And, prosecutors said, Jonchuck feared losing Phoebe in a custody dispute to the girl's mother.

Jonchuck's lawyers argued he was legally insane, meaning he suffered from a mental illness that prevented him from knowing what he was doing when he let Phoebe go, or that it was wrong. They sought a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity. If that had been the verdict, Helinger would have likely sent Jonchuck to a state treatment facility, where he could have remained for life.

RELATED: The trial of John Jonchuck came down to one question: Evil or insane?

Of the 11 points, the most significant, Manuele said, is that Helinger allowed testimony related to Jonchuck's history of misbehavior, including that he polished stairs so his uncles would fall, that he forged checks and that he has shown a pattern of poor emotional control.

"The defendant was prejudiced because he was not on trial for any of these crimes or wrongs," Manuele wrote, adding later in a phone interview that testimony about Jonchuck's past became "a feature of the trial."

Defense attorneys also took issue with the fact that Helinger allowed the prosecution's expert witnesses — psychologist Peter Bursten and psychiatrist Emily Lazarou — to testify about Jonchuck's propensity toward psychopathy. The admissibility of testimony about Jonchuck being a psychopath was hotly debated in hearings before and during the trial with the jury out of the room. While Helinger said she would not allow Bursten or Lazarou to call Jonchuck a psychopath, she did allow them to discuss the psychopathic traits Jonchuck exhibits, like lying, remorselessness and being deceitful.

Lawyers also raised concern that Helinger allowed jurors to banter with witnesses after their testimony, a move legal experts acknowledged was unusual.

Other things the defense lawyers argued were problematic included that the judge allowed jurors to see photos of Phoebe's body collected during the autopsy and that the judge didn't issue proper instructions to the jury.

Contact Josh Solomon at or (813) 909-4613. Follow @ByJoshSolomon.


  1. Check for the latest breaking news and updates. Tampa Bay Times
    He was taken by helicopter to Bayfront Health St. Petersburg as a “trauma alert” with potentially life-threatening injuries
  2. A Spirit Airlines plane before getting ready to push back and depart from one of their four gates at the Tampa International Airport on Tuesday. Spirit, a low-cost, Florida-based airline, has increased the number of cities it serves from Tampa 50 percent in two years. And in a recent 12-month period, Spirit's passengers accounted for 38 percent of the airport's total growth in passengers. Spirit is not only raising its profile in Tampa. It is pursuing rapid growth nationwide, with plans to move its corporate headquarters from Miramar to a new $250 million headquarters building in Dania Beach in Broward County. DIRK SHADD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    In 12 months, the number of passengers at Tampa International Airport has grown by about 1.1 million. Spirit Airlines accounts for 38 percent of those fliers.
  3. Bob Duggan, second from right, receives the 2016 Venky Award from Rod Alferness, dean of the College of Engineering at UC Santa Barbara. Duggan, a longtime Church of Scientology member, says he has given much more to church causes than the previously reported $360 million, and continues to do so. ERIC ISAACS
    Absent from Scientology publications since his 2017 divorce, Bob Duggan had a lot to say. He tells the Times he’s still a dedicated member and donor.
  4. Trish Duggan, second from right, was honored with a "Patron of Legend" award, a donor designation created just for her, at the annual gathering of the International Association of Scientologists last month in England. The event was documented in Scientology's November 2019 edition of its IMPACT magazine. A photo of the spread is seen here. Scientology leader David Miscavige, far right, presents the award to Duggan and members of her family. DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD  |  TImes
    Trish Duggan, who has given hundreds of millions to the church, has talked to the city about turning the prime location into a glass art showcase.
  5. The future site of the $64 million Imagine Clearwater downtown waterfront redevelopment project. On Nov. 21, 2019, the Clearwater City Council voted to authorize up to $30 million in bonds to help pay for the city. [Times]
    The bonds give Clearwater a funding source to help pay for the project, but much remains to be done. The lone no vote came from the only council member up for re-election.
  6. For the latest breaking news, check Tampa Bay Times
    The city said its reclaimed water has failed ‘disinfection criteria.’ It won’t be turned back on until it’s environmentally safe.
  7. The Hofbrauhaus, St. Petersburg, located in the former historic Tramor Cafeteria, is in the center of legal a rent disagreement. [SCOTT KEELER  |  TIMES]
    The beer hall operators’ lawyers argue they weren’t properly notified when legal action began.
  8. Police across the country are increasingly restricting when officers can use their Taser X26 stun guns to shock suspects. The electroshock weapons have been linked to fatalities. Baudilio Morales Velásquez, 31 (inset) was repeatedly shocked by a Taser fired by a Pinellas sheriff's deputy on Aug. 18. He fell and hit his head, and later died of his injuries. Times
    Amid a nationwide movement to rein in when police can use Tasers, Pinellas Sheriff Bob Gualtieri gives his deputies wide latitude to shock suspects.
  9. All northbound lanes on Interstate 275 just south of 54th Ave. S in St. Petersburg were shut down Thursday as troopers investigated a three-vehicle crash that left a motorcyclist critically injured. Florida Highway Patrol
    A driver in the center lane failed to slow as traffic in front of her did, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.
  10. The Aldi store located on 1551 34th St N. in St. Petersburg features the store look being deployed across the country. JONES, OCTAVIO   |  Tampa Bay Times
    The store had been closed for about two months during its makeover.