Saturday, November 17, 2018
Columns

PolitiFact Florida: No, Andrew Gillum does not have a far left socialist platform

In the race for Florida governor, Republican Ron DeSantis is trying to paint Democrat Andrew Gillum as so far out of the mainstream that Gillum "wants to turn Florida into Venezuela," a reference to the failing socialist country.

"The last thing we need to do is to monkey this up by trying to embrace a socialist agenda with huge tax increases and bankrupting the state," DeSantis said on Fox News.

DeSantisí comments were more controversial because of his use of the phrase "monkey this up," even though DeSantis said his comments had nothing to do with race.

"It had to do with his far-left socialist platform," DeSantis said in a subsequent interview on Laura Ingrahamís radio show.

So, is Gillumís platform far-left socialist?

The DeSantis campaign said "Gillumís socialism" includes his support for Medicare for All, which would provide health care to everyone. (A governor canít change federal policy, but Gillum says he will champion it.)

Gillum also proposed increasing the state corporate tax rate from 5.5 percent to 7.75 percent and the minimum wage from $8.25 to $15 an hour.

DeSantis points to Gillumís endorsement by Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, who has called himself a socialist or a democratic socialist.

Gillum was asked during a 2018 primary forum if he is a socialist or a capitalist.

"I am a Democrat and an individual in this state who believes that weíve had a rough ride these last several years," Gillum said. "People are working, many of them harder than ever, and still canít bring down a wage where they can make ends meet."

For Floridians who are struggling, he said, "these labels mean nothing."

After he won the primary, MSNBCís Chuck Todd asked Gillum if he is a socialist. This time, he rejected the label outright.

"No, Iím a Democrat. I ran as a Democrat, I am a Democrat. And, frankly, the values that I hold, I think, are consistent with the values of the Democratic Party. In fact, I think they are the values shared by the majority of Floridians."

The narrowest definition of socialism involves a state owning all businesses, with a ban on private economic activity above some level, said Daniel Shaviro, a tax law professor at New York University law school.

But when Sanders uses the term, he is referring to the generous social insurance programs available not only in the Scandinavian countries but also France and Germany, along with high tax rates if needed.

"But note that U.S. tax rates in the early 1960s exceeded 90 percent," Shaviro said. "Were we a Ďsocialistí country then? At the time, only the John Birch Society ó not even Barry Goldwater ó was saying so."

We sent experts on political philosophy a list of Gillumís policy positions. They generally told us itís misleading to state that Gillum has a "socialist platform" ó he hasnít advocated that government control all forms of enterprise.

If we examine socialism on a continuum, experts said some of Gillumís policies are further from socialism and some are closer.

Peter Dreier, a political science professor at Occidental College, said that for decades Republicans have used the "socialist" label to attack Democrats over policies including the New Deal in the 1930s and the Civil Rights Act in the 1960s.

Many of the ideas that were once considered "socialist" ó such as the minimum wage, womenís right to vote, and Social Security ó are now mainstream.

Back in the 1960s, when President Lyndon Johnson proposed Medicare, some Republican opponents called it "socialist." But now Americans overwhelmingly support Medicare. In Florida, about one in five people are on Medicare, among the highest rates in the country.

Mac Stipanovich, a Florida Republican strategist and critic of President Donald Trump, wrote in an op-ed in the Tampa Bay Times that what Gillum wants is an expansion of Medicare, minimum wage and public education. But the programs are broadly supported.

"If supporting these socialist programs makes one a socialist, then Gillum is indeed a socialist, as is certainly almost every elected official in Florida, Democrats or Republicans," Stipanovich wrote. "A phone booth could not be filled with politicians of any stripe who oppose Medicare, any minimum wage at all, and public schools."

Antony Davies, an economics professor at Duquesne University, said that Medicare fits the common definition of socialism because it is a program by which the government forces one group of people (wage earners) to pay for health insurance, and forces another group (retirees) to consume health insurance.

"Thus, Medicare for All will have the government exerting even more control over people," he said.

Broadly speaking, Gillumís position of expanding health care access is rooted in the mainstream rather than the far left. So where might his positions shift toward something approximating socialism?

Raising the corporate tax rate is closer to socialism, in the sense that you could say a 0 percent rate is the most "capitalistic" and a 100 percent rate the most "socialistic," Shaviro said.

One could make a similar argument about the minimum wage too, but the minimum wage was far higher, relative to inflation, for most of the post-World War II period than it is now. And a majority of Americans support increasing the minimum wage.

"The real point is that almost no one favors an absolutely pure market system with no government taxation or regulation, and no one in U.S. politics supports going 100 percent the other way, so weíre all just debating mixed systems and itís not a matter of Ďsocialistsí vs. Ďpro-capitalists.í?"

Eduardo A. Gamarra, a political science professor at Florida International University, said the comment by DeSantis that Gillum wants to turn Florida into Venezuela is "ludicrous."

Venezuela has devolved because it mismanaged its oil resources. Florida has a more diversified economy that doesnít rely on one product.

We rate this statement False.

Edited for print. Read the full ruling at PolitiFact.com/florida.

Comments
PolitiFact Florida: More felons regained right to vote in Florida than population of many states

PolitiFact Florida: More felons regained right to vote in Florida than population of many states

Florida has had one of the toughest processes in the nation for felons to regain their voting rights, but that changed on election night when voters approved amending the state Constitution to restore the right to vote to many felons.How many?News ar...
Published: 11/12/18
PolitiFact Florida: Fact-checking Gillumís claim about DeSantisí $145,000 travel receipts

PolitiFact Florida: Fact-checking Gillumís claim about DeSantisí $145,000 travel receipts

Democratic Tallahassee Mayor Andrew Gillum and former Republican U.S. Rep. Ron DeSantis asked each other for receipts during a Florida gubernatorial debate: DeSantis asked who paid for Gillumís ticket to a Hamilton show, and Gillum called out DeSanti...
Updated one month ago
PolitiFact Florida: Andrew Gillumís Pants on Fire claim on Floridaís low unemployment rate

PolitiFact Florida: Andrew Gillumís Pants on Fire claim on Floridaís low unemployment rate

Gov. Rick Scott has touted a strong Florida economy built up over his two terms in office. But Andrew Gillum, the Democratic candidate seeking to replace him, says the economy is "propped up" by low wages and people working multiple jobs just to make...
Updated one month ago