Advertisement
  1. Florida Politics

PolitiFact Florida: Would House punishment for 'sanctuary' policies be stronger than any U.S. law?

Joan Wynee, center, protests on Jan. 31 following Miami-Dade Mayor Carlos Gim?nez’s order assuring the Trump administration that Miami-Dade isn’t functioning as a sanctuary city.
Joan Wynee, center, protests on Jan. 31 following Miami-Dade Mayor Carlos Gim?nez’s order assuring the Trump administration that Miami-Dade isn’t functioning as a sanctuary city.
Published Apr. 3, 2017

Rep. Carlos Guillermo Smith, D-Orlando, has raised strong objections to a proposal that would require county and local law enforcement agencies with "sanctuary" policies to comply with the enforcement of federal immigration law or face stiff penalties.

HB 697 has passed a couple of committee hearings but needs a full vote in the House and approval in the Senate, where it has not been heard at all, before it can reach Gov. Rick Scott.

Smith's efforts to weaken the measure in a March 21 committee hearing failed. He tried to point out that the bill's penalties are uniquely harsh.

"It will be the only law of its kind in the nation," Smith said.

Smith is basically right about the measure in its current form.

Even though other states have taken up bills on sanctuary cities, no other law or pending bill goes as far as the prohibitions and the penalties imposed in HB 697.

The main way local governments and agencies refuse to comply with immigration authorities is by not honoring written requests to detain people for up to 48 hours longer than they would have been released.

Leaders who support "sanctuary" policies argue that these requests negatively impact police-community relations, are unconstitutional and are not their responsibility to enforce.

Rep. Larry Metz, the Yalaha Republican who sponsored HB 697, followed the lead of President Donald Trump, who promised to cancel funding to places with "sanctuary" policies.

A major component of his bill requires state and local entities, as well as law enforcement agencies, to comply with the enforcement of federal immigration law 90 days after the law goes into effect. If they don't, the penalties include:

• a five-year suspension on receiving nonfederal grant money from state and local entities that don't honor immigration enforcement;

• the threat of automatic suspension and removal from office for elected state officials accused of violation;

• a prohibition of public funds to reimburse or defend a public official accused of violating a sanctuary prohibition policy;

• civil fines if detainers are not honored starting Oct. 1.

Smith found that Alabama, Georgia, Utah and North Carolina have laws that require entities to honor all Immigration and Customs Enforcement detainer and information requests. But they do not go as far as HB 697.

For example, Alabama law restricts funds, grants or appropriations until a violation has ceased, but does not have a provision to have a civil cause of action against an official if a person is injured by an undocumented immigrant.

Georgia law authorizes local officials to cooperate with federal immigration officials, but does not require it. Utah restricts sanctuary policies, but does not prescribe penalties.

And North Carolina prohibits sanctuary cities, but there is no enforcement mechanism.

Also, Indiana has a law that prohibits local governments from refusing to cooperate with federal immigration authorities, but the penalties are lacking.

National immigration experts agreed with Smith's point.

"If passed, that statement is accurate in that no such law is currently on the books, although several state anti-sanctuary bills are pending with some similar provisions," said Avideh Moussavian, a National Immigration Law Center policy attorney.

Ann Morse, director of the Immigrant Policy Project for the National Conference of State Legislatures, said her group is looking into 100 bills in more than 30 states related to local law enforcement and immigration.

Morse said she couldn't find any pending legislation with quite the penalties listed above.

Monica Varsanyi, an associate professor at political science at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice, CUNY, has researched the explosion of state- and local-level immigration policy-making over recent years.

"I can say that I haven't seen anything like this bill," Varsanyi said. "I can't be 100 percent sure that there aren't others out there, however."

The only other state considering a bill anywhere close to Florida's is Texas, which is considering a piece of legislation that would prohibit sanctuary city policies and apply some of the same penalties included in HB 697, including withholding grant money and civil fines.

The penalties in Florida's bill go further by restricting grant funds for up to five years. Texas' bill only withholds funds for the following year.

Metz told PolitiFact Florida he got the idea to withhold grant money from the Texas bill but considered its language too general. Because this is the second year Metz has proposed this type of legislation, he was able to survey bills from 2016 and 2017 before finalizing HB 697.

In some of the bills he surveyed this year, he said, some looked at making a "sanctuary" policy a criminal violation.

"I did not go that route," Metz said. "I felt it should remain in the civil arena, but with significant penalties."

Smith's statement is accurate but needs additional information, so we rate it Mostly True.

Read more rulings at PolitiFact.com/Florida.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. Visitors head to Florida's Old Capitol building on Tuesday, the first day of the annual session. The same day, the advocacy group Equality Florida denounced four bills filed by Republican lawmakers, calling them “the most overtly anti-LGBTQ agenda from the Florida legislature in recent memory.” [SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times]
    Most of the bills try to eliminate local ordinances, and Republicans say they’ve been unfairly labeled.
  2. Attorney Joseph Bondy tweeted this photo of his client, Lev Parnas (right) with former Florida attorney general Pam Bondi on Friday, Jan. 17. Bondi on Friday was named on of President Donald Trump's impeachment lawyers. [Twitter]
    Parnas’ lawyer tweeted out the photo of the former Florida attorney general along with #TheyAllKnew.
  3. In this Feb. 22, 2018 file photo, Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi, speaks to reporters outside the West Wing in Washington. President Donald Trump's legal team will include Pam Bondi, the former Florida attorney general, former Harvard University law professor Alan Dershowitz and Ken Starr, the former independent counsel who led the Whitewater investigation into President Bill Clinton, according to a person familiar with the matter. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite) [J. SCOTT APPLEWHITE  |  AP]
    The former Florida attorney general reportedly will join former Harvard University law professor Alan Dershowitz and Ken Starr, the independent counsel who investigated President Bill Clinton.
  4. Florida Senator Rob Bradley, R- Fleming Island, watches the action on the first day of the session, 1/14/2020.  [SCOTT KEELER  |  TAMPA BAY TIMES]
    A popular bill would allow judges to dole out punishments less than the mandatory minimum sentences spelled out in state law for many drug crimes if the defendant meets certain criteria.
  5. Vice President Mike Pence take selfies with supporters after giving a campaign speech during the "Keep America Great" rally at the Venetian Event Center at St. Mark the Evangelist Catholic Church in Tampa, Florida on Thursday, January 16, 2020.  [OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times]
    ‘Come November the American people are going to have our say,’ Pence said.
  6. Rep. Stan McClain, an Ocala Republican, presents a bill that would allow Florida public colleges and universities to sponsor charter schools, during a January 2020 meeting of the House PreK-12 Innovation subcommittee. [The Florida Channel]
    Alternative authorizers have been found unconstitutional in the past. But that isn’t stopping the effort.
  7. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, members of the Florida Cabinet, left, and the Florida Supreme Court, right, stand at attention as the colors are posted in the Florida Senate during the first day of the Florida legislative session in Tallahassee, Tuesday, January 14, 2020.  [SCOTT KEELER  |  TAMPA BAY TIMES]
    The court ruled that Amendment 4‘s “all terms of sentence” include the payment of all court fees, fines and restitution.
  8. Thousands rallied and marched from the Donald L. Tucker Civic Center to the Florida Historic Capitol to demand more money for public schools Monday, Jan. 13, 2020. Thousands of school workers from around the state thronged Florida's Capitol on Monday to press Gov. Ron DeSantis and the Legislature to more than double the nearly $1 billion the governor is proposing for teacher raises and bonuses.  (Tori Lynn Schneider/Tallahassee Democrat via AP) [TORI LYNN SCHNEIDER  |  AP]
    The PreK-12 Appropriations subcommittee cutting exercise would come in nearly 25 percent below Gov. Ron DeSantis’ proposal.
  9. Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt.,, center, speaks as fellow candidates businessman Tom Steyer, from left, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., former Vice President Joe Biden, former South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg and Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn. listen, Tuesday during a Democratic presidential primary debate hosted by CNN and the Des Moines Register in Des Moines, Iowa. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky) [PATRICK SEMANSKY  |  AP]
    The candidates’ proposals reveal differences in how they plan to approach the issue.
  10. Vice President Mike Pence points to supporters before speaking during a campaign rally at the Huntington Center, Thursday, Jan. 9, 2020, in Toledo, Ohio. (AP Photo/Tony Dejak) [TONY DEJAK  |  AP]
    Vice President Mike Pence will take the stage in New Tampa, at the Venetian Event Center at St. Mark the Evangelist Catholic Church, at 1:30 p.m. It wasn’t planned that way.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement