1. Florida Politics

PolitiFact Florida: Gov. Rick Scott misses mark on hospital profitability

Published May 8, 2015

Before the Florida Legislature fought to a budget standstill over a hole in health care funding, Gov. Rick Scott said lawmakers should stop worrying about giving state money to profitable hospitals.

His warning came as legislators faced losing the Low Income Pool, or LIP, a joint state-federal program that helps some hospitals and clinics pay for treating uninsured and underinsured patients. Washington last year announced the fund was going to expire in 2015, taking at least $1.3 billion in matching federal funds out of the state budget.

In meetings with senators on April 22, Scott pointed to a list of facilities from the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration. We requested a copy of the list and found it detailed 252 different medical centers, their revenue and their operating margins.

PolitiFact Florida doesn't know specifically what Scott said to senators or which hospitals he singled out as examples of fueling profits with tax money, so we're not going to the Truth-O-Meter for this one.

However, if Scott's implication was that every hospital that gets LIP money turns a big profit, that's not accurate.

Under current rules, both nonprofit and for-profit hospitals qualify for LIP money. The fund is paid in part by state, county and local taxes that are matched by the federal government. The pool then reimburses hospitals, doctors, clinics and other providers for treating patients with little or no insurance coverage.

Preference is given to hospitals that provide significant care to low-income patients and are in counties or districts that pay into the fund, but the money also is shared with institutions that don't pay into the program.

Of 239 hospitals that treat Medicaid patients, 126 of them are anticipated to get a LIP distribution, according to the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration.

We compared the amount of LIP money earmarked for those hospitals to the operating margins on Scott's list. You can look at Scott's list and the House financial report we used online at

Operating margins are a fair indicator of a hospital's financial health, showing how much revenue a facility brings in from patients after subtracting the cost to treat them. Linda Quick, president of the South Florida Hospital and Healthcare Association, said there are some caveats, but those margins can provide a quick overview.

"Different institutions account for their money in different ways, but it's a good way to make an apples-to-apples comparison," she said.

Roughly, we can say about half of the facilities that get LIP money were in the black, according to Scott's list.

For example, Scott's handout said Tampa's nonprofit Moffitt Cancer Center had an $85.7 million operating margin for fiscal year 2013-14. They were projected to get $23.3 million in LIP money this year. Tampa General was earmarked for $62.4 million in LIP funds, with an operating margin of almost $37 million. Halifax Health Medical Center in Volusia County had a $12.2 million operating margin and stood to get $34 million in LIP cash.

Using the list, Orange County's Florida Hospital ran the highest operating margin of more than $252 million. That hospital received $14.9 million in LIP money.

Now keep in mind, even though these hospitals are in the black, they are being paid for providing services to people with little or no health coverage. And some hospitals treat more indigent patients than others.

Other hospitals get a lot of LIP money but have big operating losses. In Miami-Dade County, the taxpayer-owned Jackson Memorial was slated to get $505 million in LIP funds, but operated at a $291 million loss, according to Scott's list. The Broward Health system gets some $137 million in LIP distribution, but also lost tens of millions of dollars.

Quick said operating margins and LIP disbursements change from year to year, so pointing to one year doesn't necessarily offer a complete overview of a hospital's management, services or fiscal health.

Tampa Bay area hospitals we contacted did not directly address Scott's assertions about profits, but said they would like to see the debate over LIP funding resolved.

"We believe funds for the uninsured should follow the patient, and we are optimistic that the Legislature, the governor and CMS can agree on a funding model that does that," said Largo Medical Center spokeswoman Tammy Robiconti. She added that the facility provided $16.7 million in charity and uncompensated care last year, and paid more than $12 million in taxes. Largo Medical Center collected less than $1 million in LIP funds in 2014.

Dr. Jonathan Ellen, president and physician in chief at All Children's Hospital in St. Petersburg, said that 70 percent of hospital patients are covered by Medicaid, which has limits on payments for treatment. The LIP was essential to their operations.

"These (Medicaid) reimbursements often do not cover the cost of care, leaving (the) Low Income Pool to fill that gap," he said in a statement. "Without these funds, All Children's would have to cut back on clinical programs and other critical care services."

Scott knows a little about how hospitals use money from government health care programs. He was CEO of the Columbia/HCA hospital chain about a decade ago, when the company was fined $1.7 billion for Medicare fraud. Scott resigned and was not charged with a crime.

Now that the legislative session is over, Scott has dialed back his heavy-handed posture. On May 5, he issued an executive order creating a Commission on Healthcare and Hospital Funding to study how taxpayer money pays for health care. Its findings are supposed to help inform the Legislature when it reconvenes for budget talks, which must solve the deadlock over expanding Medicaid.

Expansion would alleviate the need for LIP funding, experts said, since it would provide coverage for patients instead of only paying providers for services after the fact.

The House and Senate have agreed to start a special session on June 1.