Wednesday, November 14, 2018
Politics

Florida Cabinet supports Rick Scott, approves investment prohibitions on Venezuela

TALLAHASSEE — Rick Scott and the Florida Cabinet unanimously voted Wednesday to continue to refrain from allowing state investment managers to use Florida funds to invest in companies controlled by the Nicolás Maduro regime or companies that violate federal law by doing business in Venezuela.

The state currently has no direct investment with the government of Venezuela and the proposal will continue that, but the resolution falls short of a plan initially pitched by Scott that would have required the state to divest its assets in companies that do business with the Maduro regime, including Goldman Sachs.

Instead, the mostly symbolic measure is designed to send a message to the emerging dictatorship that Florida will not sanction the regime's brutality.

"I stand firmly with the Venezuelan people," Scott said before the vote of the State Board of Administration, which includes the governor, the chief financial officer, and the attorney general, and is charged with oversight of the Florida Retirement System and its $150 billion in assets.

He said he may pursue legislation next session that pressures more companies to stop doing business in Venezuela, but "this was a great start."

Goldman Sachs' investment arm was criticized earlier this year when it purchased $2.8 billion in what were called "hunger bonds" from Maduro's state-owned oil company. The reference to the low-cost bonds was seen by critics as providing the Maduro regime an economic lifeline when the government's policies were causing a shortage of food and leading to malnutrition, unrest and violence.

Goldman responded that it bought the bonds for asset-management clients through a second-party broker, and didn't send the money directly to the government.

The Florida Retirement Fund holds $147 million in Goldman Sachs shares, $171 million in Goldman Sachs bonds and other financial instruments and pays the firm $1.9 million in yearly fees to manage some accounts.

Scott, who is expected to run for U.S. Senate next year, has been courting South Florida voters in the last two months with tough talk on the Maduro government. He backed off his initial comments, made at a series of media events in Miami, after Goldman Sachs sent its head of its Investment Management Division, Tim O'Neill, and the firm's chief of staff, John Rogers, to meet with Scott, the other members of the Cabinet, and SBA Executive Director Ash Williams in mid-July.

They would like to introduce themselves to you, answer your questions, and share the story of the trade and what the firm will do for trades of this magnitude going forward," wrote Lisa Rotenberg, Goldman Sachs' asset managing director, in a July 13 email to Williams.

In July, state Sen. Jose Javier Rodriguez, D-Miami, proposed legislation, SB 70, which would add the Maduro dictatorship to Florida's existing divestment programs — Sudan and Iran — and force the state to sell its Goldman assets.

If the governor follows through and supports a similar proposal, Goldman Sachs and numerous other companies who derive revenue from Venezuela could lose Florida as an investor.

According to Enterprise Florida's annual report, at least three companies that derive revenues from Venezuela — General Electric, United Technologies International and Citibank — have collectively received more than $4.26 million in Florida incentive funds.

The governor did not say whether those companies will be part of his legislation.

"My focus today was on the SBA doing business with the Maduro regime but I'm going to continue to look at ways to make sure we don't support the Maduro regime," he told reporters.

"Companies that do business with the Venezuelan people, that's not our target. Our target is companies that do business with the Venezuelan regime," he said.

According to internal SBA correspondence obtained by the Times/Herald, divesting of all investments from Goldman Sachs and companies that do business in Venezuela could have a broad impact on the retirement fund.

"As you would expect, the list of companies with revenue exposure in Venezuela includes major consumer staple, auto, electronic and airlines companies as well as some oil, infrastructure and financial companies. The list is extensive so any prohibition on holding these companies would have a significant impact on returns," wrote Alison Romano, senior investment officer, in a July 7 email to other investment team members.

She also noted, however, that "many of the companies that had business in Venezuela have either shrunk those businesses or pulled out entirely."

Under the proposal approved Wednesday, the SBA will be prohibited from investing in any securities issued by the Venezuelan government; prohibited from doing business with any financial institution or U.S. company which directly, or through a subsidiary, violates federal law by making a loan, extending credit, or makes purchases with the government of Venezuela, and will be prohibited from taking a shareholder proxy vote that advocates or supports the Maduro regime.

"These guidelines will be in place to keep us in the posture we are in today," Williams told reporters Wednesday. He said they will have "zero" impact on any current investments.

Rodriguez said in a statement that he welcomed the SBA's "initial step" but urged them to "take stronger action in the face of the deepening crisis in Venezuela."

Contact Mary Ellen Klas at [email protected] Follow @MaryEllenKlas

Comments
??Rick Scott appears in D.C. along with new GOP senators, despite the recount

??Rick Scott appears in D.C. along with new GOP senators, despite the recount

Even though his Senate race is in the middle of a recount, the governor was with new senators.
Updated: 4 hours ago
Judge considers Bill Nelson lawsuit to count votes with faulty signatures

Judge considers Bill Nelson lawsuit to count votes with faulty signatures

Florida's system of verifying signatures on mail and provisional ballots is under intense legal scrutiny.
Updated: 5 hours ago
Florida officials flag a possible violation of elections law by state Democrats

Florida officials flag a possible violation of elections law by state Democrats

The forms listed the wrong due date for voters to fix issues with their mail-in ballots.
Updated: 7 hours ago
Rick Scott wins suit against Hillsborough Supervisor of Elections

Rick Scott wins suit against Hillsborough Supervisor of Elections

Election watchers will now be allowed to stand inside the physical area where machine recounts are taking place.
Updated: 8 hours ago
Hillsborough to be a dumping ground for clay from Hardee County phosphate mine

Hillsborough to be a dumping ground for clay from Hardee County phosphate mine

Hillsborough County Commissioners on Wednesday voted 4-2 in favor of a controversial request by Mosaic to dump clay from its Ona Mine into the Four Corners Mine in southeast Hillsborough County.
Updated: 8 hours ago
Palm Beach recount further behind after machine malfunction

Palm Beach recount further behind after machine malfunction

There's uncertainty about meeting the Thursday deadline for a machine recount.
Updated: 9 hours ago
Broward County confident it will make Florida recount deadline

Broward County confident it will make Florida recount deadline

After starting the recount way after other counties, Broward is now optimistic about finishing on time.
Updated: 9 hours ago
Bill Nelson sues for fax, email voting records from Bay County

Bill Nelson sues for fax, email voting records from Bay County

The Bay County Supervisor of Elections has said he accepted some ballots by fax and email.
Updated: 9 hours ago
Judge Mark Walker is at the center of Florida recount legal fight

Judge Mark Walker is at the center of Florida recount legal fight

Several federal lawsuits are assigned to the federal judge.
Published: 11/14/18
Broward County elections supervisor says invalid ballots ‘were never counted’

Broward County elections supervisor says invalid ballots ‘were never counted’

She is trying to tamp down reports that she included invalid ballots in vote totals transmitted to the state over the weekend.
Published: 11/14/18