1. News

Pinellas sheriff, feds announce changes to controversial immigrant detention policy

Pinellas Sheriff Bob Gualtieri, as a representative of the National Sheriffs' Association and Major County Sheriffs of America, helped develop the new protocol during yearlong talks with ICE officials. [Photo from video]
Published Jan. 17, 2018

LARGO — For years, county sheriffs in the United States have faced a quandary when asked by federal officials to hold undocumented immigrants in their local jails.

They could continue to hold them for up to two days past the time they were legally free to leave, giving U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcements officers time to pick them up. But that would open the sheriffs to civil rights lawsuits.

They could release the detainee before ICE arrived. But that risked putting someone in the country illegally back on the streets.

On Wednesday, a top federal immigration official stood alongside Tampa Bay area sheriffs to announce what he said is a workaround for sheriffs who want to cooperate with ICE.

The new protocol calls for ICE to send a booking form that transfers custody of the detainees from the local jail to federal immigration authorities, said ICE Deputy Director Thomas Homan.

At that point, the jail's only role is housing the detainee, said Pinellas Sheriff Bob Gualtieri.

Sheriffs will be paid up to $50 to hold the inmate for up to 48 hours. Called a "basic ordering agreement," the scheme is similar to the inter-governmental agreements that jail operators strike with federal agencies like the Federal Bureau of Investigation, Gualtieri said.

"These agreements will make communities here in the Sunshine State safer and more secure from criminal activity perpetrated by individuals with no legal standing to be in this country in the first place," Homan said at a news conference held at the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office.

But immigrant and civil rights advocates say the new agreement is likely not a legal cure-all. Local sheriffs, they said, will continue to face the threat of lawsuits.

"I think they can anticipate more litigation on this subject," said Alyson Sincavage, a legislative associate for the American Immigration Lawyers Association,

The new protocol will be rolled out immediately in 17 Florida counties including Hillsborough, Pinellas, Pasco and Hernando. Gualtieri helped develop it as a representative of the National Sheriffs' Association and Major County Sheriffs of America.

PREVIOUS COVERAGE: Sheriff Gualtieri taking lead in talks with ICE over immigrant detainees.

Though ICE detainer requests date back to the late 1980s, Wednesday's announcement is the latest development in a debate that has heated up in the last few years.

In 2014, the first federal court rulings found that ICE detainer requests did not give jail operators legal authority to hold inmates after their local charges were resolved. Doing so, the courts found, violated the detainee's Fourth Amendment protection against illegal search and seizures.

The vast majority of the nation's 3,100 local jails — most of which are run by local sheriffs — honored the detainer requests. But more than a dozen court rulings across the country have dissuaded even red-state sheriffs who want to cooperate with ICE from honoring requests because they worry doing so makes them vulnerable to civil rights lawsuits. Some suits have resulted in six-figure settlements.

"Sheriffs were between a rock and a hard place," said Gualtieri, who is also an attorney. "We had to choose between releasing criminals from our jails to commit more crimes and victimize our communities or hold these illegal aliens and risk being sued."

In addition to the four Tampa Bay area counties, the protocol also is in effect in Polk, Manatee, Sarasota, Bay, Brevard, Collier, Charlotte, Indian River, Lee, Monroe, Santa Rosa, Suwanee and Walton counties. It will expand to the rest of Florida and after that, to the rest of the U.S. A timetable for the expansion has not been set but officials said they want to act as quickly as possible.

When it comes to who would be vulnerable under the new policy, some sheriffs came ready with stories of undocumented immigrants with criminal and deportation histories as examples. Matthew Albence, ICE's executive associate director of enforcement and removal operations, cast an even wider net.

"If you come to our attention through the criminal justice system," he said, "we are going to take an enforcement action against you."

Immigration advocates say the scheme still doesn't resolve a legal flaw: Under the current law, the arrest warrants that allow ICE to take over custody do not have to be reviewed by a judge.

"The basic operation of the scheme is exactly the same," said Spencer Amdur, a staff attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union's Immigrants' Rights Project. "ICE decides they want to arrest somebody, they send a form to the local jail, but the fact remains that it's the local jail who's carrying out that arrest. They're the ones depriving the person of their liberty."

Gualtieri has said those advocates should take up that complaint with Congress because there is currently no legal framework for judicial review.

Sincavage, the AILA attorney, doesn't disagree, "but that doesn't mean sheriffs should be entering agreements with ICE to hold people beyond their release dates and continue to violate their Fourth Amendment rights."

Contact Tony Marrero at or (813) 226-3374. Follow @tmarrerotimes. Contact Kathryn Varn at (727) 893-8913 or Follow @kathrynvarn.


  1. Atlantic tropical cyclones and disturbances, as of 11 a.m. Thursday. National Hurricane Center
    It is projected to pass north of Puerto Rico on Saturday and east of the southeastern Bahamas on Sunday.
  2. Police investigators say they believe the man has a history of mental of illness. Photo from video/10News WTSP
    Firefighters initially tried to climb after him, but the man just climbed higher.
  3. The Tampa City Council was told Thursday that it had little power to prevent a medical marijuana cultivation,  processing and dispensary approved for East Tampa. ANDREW SELSKY  |  AP
    Trulieve plans to open a facility near a recovery center. State preemption prevents the city from taking action.
  4. Statements made online that threaten physical harm, whether seriously intended or not, can have devastating consequences. The “It’s No Joke” awareness campaign seeks to educate youth and parents that even threats made online. Florida Department of Juvenile Justice/Facebook
    The arrests came after other students told deputies they’d been told they were on a “safe” list.
  5. In this Wednesday morning Sept. 18, 2019 photo, Detention Cpl. Shaguanta Scott, left and Detention Deputy Darryl Keaton, right, escort Michael W. Jones Jr. back to the Marion County Sheriff's Office in Ocala, Fla. Jones, suspected of killing his wife and four children and driving their bodies into Georgia, was returned to Florida to face murder charges. (Doug Engle/Star-Banner via AP)
    Investigators found the decomposed bodies of the children in woods nearby.
  6. A team of a dozen victims' rights attorneys on Wednesday filed the third lawsuit in three months against the Church of Scientology and its leader David Miscavige. The complaint states a woman was repeatedly sexually abused as a child in Scientology's care and that church policy enabled the abuse. PIERRE-PHILIPPE MARCOU  |  AFP/Getty Images
    The third lawsuit filed against Scientology and leader David Miscavige in three months accuses the church of sexual battery, racketeering and conspiracy
  7. President Donald Trump boards Air Force One at Marine Corps Air Station Miramar, Wednesday, Sept. 18, 2019, in San Diego, Calif. EVAN VUCCI  |  AP
    The lawsuit opens a new legal front in Trump’s long-running fight to prevent his tax returns from becoming public.
  8. Surveillance video shows suspects in an attempted robbery-turned murder at a Bradenton smoke shop. Manatee County Sheriff's Office
    One suspect is in custody and two others are wanted in connection with the Wednesday armed robbery turned murder.
  9. Jessica LaBouve, a penetration tester for cybersecurity company A-LIGN, poses for a portrait in the A-LIGN office on Thursday, Sept. 12, 2019 in Tampa. Companies hire A-LIGN to figure out where their digital security weak spots are, and LaBouve is one of the "benevolent hackers" that finds them. ALLIE GOULDING  |  Times
    Jessica LaBouve of A-LIGN works with companies to make their applications and platforms more secure.
  10. Stephen A. Schwarzman, CEO of the Blackstone Group, speaks at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, earlier this year. MARKUS SCHREIBER  |  AP
    The billionaire also talks trade with China in an interview with the Tampa Bay Times.