Monday, November 12, 2018
Public safety

Why video makes this Florida stand your ground debate different

Near a corner of the Circle A Food Store, to the left of the door, a small surveillance camera hangs off the low brick building, pointed down from a spot just below the roof. Slightly askew, it records people and cars coming and going, a slow routine in grainy gray monochrome.

Except for July 19, during 20 charged seconds that broke the monotony and cast the convenience store into a roiling national debate. About 3 p.m., 28-year-old Markeis McGlockton walked outside and found another man, 48-year-old Michael Drejka, arguing with his girlfriend.

McGlockton pushed Drejka to the ground. Drejka shot him. McGlockton died.

The tiny camera hovered above the moment, capturing the frames that would carry the incident to televisions, phones and computer screens across the country.

DEBATE: Think you know stand your ground? The recent Clearwater case tells us you’re probably wrong.

The shooting has started yet another political battle over Florida’s stand your ground law, but this time, experts say, it’s different. Like the videos of police-involved shootings that swept across America in recent years — boosting the Black Lives Matter movement and spreading outcry over racial injustice — the footage has made an abstract legal issue hypervisible.

"People can talk about stand your ground, they can come up with examples, they can say, ‘Well I heard about this one, I read about this one in the news,’ " said University of South Carolina law professor Seth Stoughton. "It’s different when you can see it on video."

PREVIOUS COVERAGE: Shooter charged with manslaughter in Clearwater stand your ground case

READ MORE: How prosecutors decided to charge Michael Drejka, shooter in controversial stand your ground case

• ••

The weeks after McGlockton died were hectic. Marches, news conferences, a visit to a Clearwater church from the Rev. Al Sharpton, but no arrest. The reason, Pinellas Sheriff Bob Gualtieri said, was stand your ground.

The controversial self-defense law, which affords the chance for immunity from prosecution to people who assert they used force while in fear for their life or serious injury, made it so deputies could not arrest Drejka, the sheriff said. Instead, he handed the case to prosecutors, who later charged Drejka with manslaughter.

But the incident took on a new dimension as soon as Gualtieri invoked stand your ground.

The law had touched off political and legal conflagrations before — whether it was invoked during trials or not. First there was the deadly shooting of Trayvon Martin by a neighborhood watch volunteer, George Zimmerman, in Sanford. There was the case of Curtis Reeves, a retired police officer who shot and killed another man during an argument in a Pasco County movie theater. There was Michael Dunn, who shot and killed Jordan Davis at a Jacksonville gas station after confronting the teen and his friends about loud music.

None of those cases, however, involved clear public video like the one that shows Drejka shoot McGlockton.

"In the Trayvon Martin case, Zimmerman is the only one who gets to say how that went down," said University of Miami law professor Mary Anne Franks. "There’s so many competing stories, especially when someone dies."

In the latest shooting, she said, people are left with more than just conflicting witness testimony to decipher. "That’s one of the reasons why this is going to be different," Franks said.

Caroline Light, a Harvard professor who wrote a book about self-defense, said video changes the discussion.

"Typically you have the word of the survivor when there are two involved, and there are no witnesses," she said. "There wouldn’t be the same visual dramatization that helps us put things into perspective."

Stoughton, the South Carolina law professor who is also a frequent commentator on police shooting videos, said the McGlockton case has some parallels to the recordings of officer-involved violence.

"When you have a lethal shooting you have he-said and he’s-dead, so you only get one story. When you only have one story, it’s fairly easy to come to one conclusion," said Stoughton, a former Tallahassee police officer. "Video injects a whole new interpretation .... that tells a totally different story, or the same story from a different perspective."

• • •

The surveillance footage of Drejka shooting McGlockton is already a key part of the legal case against him. A detective wrote that investigators have analyzed the footage repeatedly, measuring the distance and movements between the men in the moments before the shooting.

Pinellas-Pasco State Attorney Bernie McCabe has signaled that the video is critical for prosecutors.

But experts cautioned against viewing the recording as a definitive account of the incident, something the sheriff has acknowledged repeatedly since announcing he would not initially arrest Drejka.

"The perception is that watching a video makes you an eyewitness to that event. It has a visceral impact on how you perceive that incident," Stoughton said. "It’s also wrong. You are not in fact an eyewitness to an event just because you watched a video."

Many surveillance recordings, for instance, do not have sound — including the footage in the McGlockton case. Cameras are also typically anchored to a fixed point.

"Video shows us a two-dimensional representation of a three-dimensional action from one and only one perspective," said David Klinger, a criminology professor at the University of Missouri-St. Louis and former police officer. "We can get sucked into this one piece of evidence because we are visual creatures, humans. ... We always have to be careful not to believe that we have everything that we need to know just by seeing a particular surveillance video."

TAMPA BAY TIMES COVERAGE: STAND YOUR GROUND CASE

Records show road rage, gun threats in stand your ground shooter’s past

Family to Pinellas prosecutor: File charges in death of Markeis McGlockton

Attorney calls Markeis McGlockton’s death ‘cold-blooded murder’ by ‘wannabe cop’

Nelson, Crist call for Department of Justice investigation into death of Markeis McGlockton

In latest ‘stand your ground’ case, a question: Who started it?

Contact Zachary T. Sampson at [email protected] or (727) 893-8804. Follow @ZackSampson. Contact Kathryn Varn at (727) 893-8913 or [email protected] Follow @kathrynvarn.

Comments
Hillsborough Sheriff's deputies investigating woman's death in Lake Egypt Estates

Hillsborough Sheriff's deputies investigating woman's death in Lake Egypt Estates

Hillsborough County Sheriff's deputies responded to the scene of a suspicious death at about 8p.m. Monday in the Lake Egypt Estates neighborhood near Tampa's Lowry Park Zoo.
Updated: 2 hours ago
Pedestrian killed in crash with wrong-way driver while loading bicycle onto PSTA bus

Pedestrian killed in crash with wrong-way driver while loading bicycle onto PSTA bus

Pinellas County Sheriff's deputies are investigating the death of a pedestrian who was killed by an out-of-control vehicle while hitching a bicycle to the front of a county bus.
Updated: 4 hours ago
Woman killed by stray bullet in St. Pete shooting was a nursing assistant, mother of 5

Woman killed by stray bullet in St. Pete shooting was a nursing assistant, mother of 5

Aesha Kendrick, 38, fell victim to a shooter who was firing at another target, St. Petersburg police said. Her death left family members reeling Monday and her five children, ages 1 to 17, without a m
Updated: 6 hours ago
First Baptist College Hill’s intruder-training seems like a must for today’s churches

First Baptist College Hill’s intruder-training seems like a must for today’s churches

America’s spate of mass shootings have awaken houses of worship to a new and sad reality.
Updated: 6 hours ago
Naked Florida man revealed on video sneaking into restaurant and munching on ramen

Naked Florida man revealed on video sneaking into restaurant and munching on ramen

ST. PETERSBURG — It started with chicken wings, a beer and a burglar.It went downhill from there.A St. Petersburg police officer was investigating a Nov. 6 break-in at The Chattaway restaurant, reviewing surveillance video that shows the burgl...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Tarpon Springs motorcycle driver killed by car that ran red light, police say

Tarpon Springs motorcycle driver killed by car that ran red light, police say

Sam Bellotte of Tarpon Springs died while he was being transported to Bayonet Point Medical Center, police said.
Updated: 9 hours ago
Boy, 14 months old, drowns in pool at home in Brandon

Boy, 14 months old, drowns in pool at home in Brandon

Emergency personnel transported the boy to Brandon Regional Hospital, deputies say, where he was pronounced dead around 5:30 p.m.
Updated: 10 hours ago
Naples man dies after RV blows tire, crashes on I-4 in Polk County

Naples man dies after RV blows tire, crashes on I-4 in Polk County

A Naples man died after he lost control of his RV and hit a light pole.
Updated: 10 hours ago
Wrong-way DUI crash on Suncoast Boulevard seriously injures Citrus County man

Wrong-way DUI crash on Suncoast Boulevard seriously injures Citrus County man

A Levy County man faces a charge of DUI after he drove his RV the wrong way on the Suncoast Parkway in Citrus County and crashed head-on into a pickup truck early Sunday morning.
Published: 11/12/18
Motorcyclist suffers life-threatening injuries in St. Petersburg crash

Motorcyclist suffers life-threatening injuries in St. Petersburg crash

A 38-year-old man suffered life-threatening injuries after he ran a red light and crashed his 1998 Honda motorcycle into another vehicle early Monday morning.
Published: 11/12/18