1. News

Clearwater man pleads guilty to stabbing ex-girlfriend 32 times, could get life

Robert Lee Burton Jr.’s initial guilty plea offer was rejected.
Robert Lee Burton Jr.’s initial guilty plea offer was rejected.
Published Aug. 15, 2013

LARGO — For stabbing his 20-year-old girlfriend 32 times, Robert Lee Burton Jr. told a judge on Tuesday that he was willing to plead guilty— as long as he didn't have to spend more than 10 years in prison.

Pinellas-Pasco Circuit Judge Keith Meyer rejected that offer, which made it appear Burton's long-awaited trial on an attempted murder charge was about to begin.

But then, after a discussion with his attorney, Burton surprised victim Melissa Dohme and many of her friends and family members in the courtroom by agreeing to plead guilty, period.

He admitted his crime without any deal from prosecutors, meaning he could face up to life in prison.

"I'm shocked that that happened," said Dohme, now 21. She said she was still grasping the fact that she no longer has to work toward his conviction.

"I am here. I am alive. My fight's over, I won. It's the court's fight, not mine anymore."

She does intend to speak at his sentencing hearing, to tell the judge she fears there will be other victims if Burton ever gets out of prison. A hearing date has not been set.

Although Burton, 22, appeared to cry as he pleaded guilty, Dohme's mother Joann said, "I think those tears were for himself."

Assistant State Attorney Scott Vieth said Burton engaged in an escalating pattern of abuse. The couple already had broken up when he texted her in the early morning hours of Jan. 24, 2012, asking to meet. He sounded down and was close to her Clearwater home. He just wanted a hug.

When she met him near Crest Lake Park, they embraced. That's when he began stabbing her with a pocketknife.

Two people heard her screams, but he threatened them, saying he had a gun. They backed off and called 911, but remained within eyesight.

Burton reached into his truck for what the bystanders thought might be the gun, but instead retrieved a bigger knife and stabbed her more.

She was stabbed in her head, neck, and arms. Her skull was cracked, her teeth knocked loose. She lost so much blood that doctors had to give her seven blood transfusions.

Burton's surprising decision on Tuesday afternoon came after a full morning of arguments about whether he was mentally capable of standing trial and understanding the proceedings.

Based on the testimony of three mental health experts, the judge ruled that he was.

After the attack, Dohme spent three weeks at St. Petersburg's Bayfront Medical Center. She flat-lined four times and suffered a stroke that affected her balance. A severed nerve partly paralyzed the left side of her face.

Doctors weren't sure that Dohme would ever speak, smile or walk the same. But she left rehab without a cane and eventually returned to St. Petersburg College-Clearwater with renewed passion to become a nurse.

"I'm just so proud of her," her 24-year-old sister Michelle said Tuesday. "You wouldn't think your younger sister would be your role model."

Dohme has become an advocate who speaks on domestic violence. Outside the courtroom Tuesday, she said she wanted to let other victims know they aren't alone.

"There is a better life after abuse … you deserve to be loved and respected. Never ever ever should a man lay a hand on you," she said.

Dohme later reconnected with a firefighter-paramedic who helped rush her to the hospital that early morning. The two are now dating.


  1. Bradley Hulett played for the Valrico Venom, an Amateur Athletic Union basketball team, and led the team in scoring last fall. Bradley, 15, was fatally shot at a friend's house in Lithia on Dec. 13, 2019. [Courtesy the Hulett family]
  2. One excursion on Magic Kingdom’s Jungle Cruise ended prematurely Thursday when the boat took on water. [Twitter]
  3. Perched above the top floor of Daer nightclub, the 10,000-square-foot space overlooks the lagoon and the Bora Bora cabanas. [Miami Herald]
  4. Erinasha Jania Porshay Jones was booked at the Pinellas County jail Thursday on two charges of vehicular homicide in connection with the deaths of two teen girls in a Feb. 8 crash. [Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]
  5. Gayle Guyardo hugs a coworker just before leaving the News Channel 8 building after her final broadcast Friday in Tampa. [JOHN PENDYGRAFT  |  Times]
  6. Check for the latest breaking news and updates. [Times]
  7. Madeira Beach City Hall. [City of Madeira Beach]
  8. Pinellas deputies say David Keith Teal was driving at more than 120 mph over the Bayside Bridge, then was pulled over and found with drugs. [Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]
  9. Custodian James Berrien, (center) and Hillsborough Schools Superintendent Jeff Eakins are pictured at Cypress Creek Elementary for the opening of a time capsule buried in 1991 when Eakins was a 4th-grade teacher. It was the first year that Berrien, present at the burial of the capsule, worked at the school. Febuary 27. Thursday, Feb. 27, 2020 in Ruskin.  [MARTHA ASENCIO RHINE  |  Times]
  10. Lynn Cristina is a Wesley Chapel momma with two girls and works full time as a marketing manager. [Courtesy of Lynn Cristina]
  11. Dr. Peter Pritchard of Oviedo was the world's leading expert on turtles and tortoises. He displayed the world's largest collection of specimens at his Chelonian Research Institute where he gave tours to anyone for free. He died Tuesday at age 76. [Courtesy of the Chelonian Research Institute] [Chelonian Research Institute, Oviedo]
  12. Burlington Post, an affordable apartment building for 55 and older residents, opened in 2018. St. Petersburg City Council is looking for ways to pay for more affordable housing. The latest proposal: Charge developers impact fees. [SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times]