1. News

Experts doubt that alligators killed boy, 16, found dead last week at Lake Maggiore

Witnesses spotted alligators dragging the body of ‘16-year-old Jarvis Deliford across Lake Maggiore on July 4. A cause of death remains under investigation and a state-contracted alligator trapper continues to monitor the lake. [ANGELIQUE HERRING | Times]
Published Jul. 11

ST. PETERSBURG — Nearly a week after the body of 16-year-old Jarvis Deliford was found surrounded by alligators on Lake Maggiore, police still don't know how he died.

Most wildlife experts interviewed, though, say it's unlikely Deliford was killed in an alligator attack.

"My guess is the boy died of other causes," said Kent Vliet, an alligator biologist at the University of Florida. "These alligators just opportunistically found the body and were feeding on it."

Deliford disappeared June 29, the same day he left a Clearwater juvenile detention center where he was sent for violating probation he had received in an earlier burglary arrest.

READ MORE: Body found near alligators in St. Petersburg lake identified as 16-year-old boy

The teen cut off his ankle monitor that evening in his mother's home on Paris Avenue and ran away, police said.

His body was found about a week later, around 8 a.m. July 4, near a fishing dock along the southeastern bank of Lake Maggiore. About 10 alligators had surrounded it and were dragging the corpse south, witnesses said.

Police initially said they had found "no obvious signs of foul play" or homicidal violence. Detectives are still waiting for an official autopsy report, which could take six to eight weeks or longer.

But based on witness accounts and police statements, most experts interviewed by the Times say the Lake Maggiore alligators probably happened upon Deliford's body while scavenging for food.

Alligators are territorial and hunt alone, said New Port Richey trapper Daniel Altimus. They don't like to share the mosquitofish, raccoons and other creatures that make up their diets.

If that many alligators had surrounded the body, Altimus said, it's likely a sign of scavenging rather than hunting.

Alligators regularly scavenge, said Vliet with UF, and may crawl 100 yards or more out of the water to grab dead animals.

Several alligators were seen dragging Deliford's body across the surface of Lake Maggiore, indicating he was found dead near shore, said Lakeland trapper David Blaesing.

"Anything meat," Blaesing said. "That's all they're ever looking for."

Even in healthy lakes with ample prey, Vliet said, alligators won't hesitate to scavenge for dead animals. Deliford may have been pulled from the land into the water after he died.

"That is entirely possible," said Sandra Bentil, a St. Petersburg police spokeswoman. "That is why we're waiting for a complete report from the medical examiner."

For now, it's "hard to say" what the cause of death was, Bentil said. Perhaps it was a medical emergency, she said.

Deliford's sister, Laporsha Smalls, told the Times on Saturday she thinks someone killed her brother.

"He doesn't go to beaches, he doesn't even play around water," said Smalls, 27. "He doesn't know how to swim."

One expert, though — Frank Mazzotti, a wildlife biology professor at the University of Florida — advised against ruling out an alligator attack.

When alligators kill, they frequently stow their prey underwater and away from flies, vultures or other alligators. They leave meals rotting under rocks, docks or submerged trees.

Alligators sometimes fight over those meals, Mazzotti said, and aggressive alligators try to steal from younger or weaker alligators.

Deliford could have been killed by an alligator, dragged underwater and then found by other alligators, Mazzotti said.

"The way they scavenge could be fighting over it," he said. "It could be either or."

Still, he added, fatal alligator attacks in Florida are rare.

Only a postmortem examination will shed light on the cause of death, Mazzotti said. Investigators might look for blood that accumulated in wounds, he said, which would mean the heart was still pumping as an alligator bit down.

That evidence was likely difficult to collect, though, given the body's decomposition, he said. Police initially said they couldn't determine a race or gender.

The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission trapped and killed a 6-foot alligator and 10-foot alligator at Lake Maggiore last week as they gathered evidence in the case. A necropsy found that the 10-foot alligator had "involvement" with Deliford, the commission said.

An alligator trapper is still monitoring and working the area, Ashley Tyer, a commission spokeswoman, said Tuesday in an email to the Times.

Senior news researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report. Contact Sam Ogozalek at or (813) 226-3430. Follow@SamOgozalek .


  1. A Hernando County Sheriff's deputy talks to students in the cafeteria of Brooksville Elementary School in 2018. Earlier this month, the school district put forward a proposal to move away from a contract with the Sheriff and establish its own police force. On Tuesday, it announced it would drop that idea.
    Hernando County Sheriff Al Nienhuis spoke out this week against the proposal.
  2. [RON BORRESEN  |  Times].
    The deadline is Friday to submit your employer’s name for consideration.
  3. Sigfredo Garcia leans back in his chair and whispers to his former longtime girlfriend Katherine Magbanua on Friday, Oct. 11, 2019, in Tallahassee, Fla., after Leon County jurors announced a guilty verdict against him in the murder trial of Dan Markel. ALICIA DEVINE  |  AP
    The case had riveted Florida’s capital as sordid details began to emerge about a messy divorce, tensions with in-laws and child custody battles that culminated in a murder-for-hire plot.
  4. The developers of The Heights say they have reached an agreement with Marriott International to include a 153-room Marriott Moxy Hotel on the first seven floors of a 25-story apartment tower planned on the block two blocks east of the Armature Works. The Heights District
    Plans call for a 153-room hotel that will occupy the first seven floors within a new, mixed-use, 25-story tower.
  5. FILE - In this image released Friday, Oct. 4, 2019, by NASA, astronauts Christina Koch, right, and, Jessica Meir pose for a photo on the International Space Station. NASA has moved up the first all-female spacewalk to Thursday, Oct. 17, 2019, or Friday because of a power system failure at the International Space Station. AP
    Astronauts Christina Koch (cook) and Jessica Meir (mere) will now venture out Thursday or Friday, instead of next Monday.
  6. Taco Bell Tuesday announced it had recalled 2.3 million pounds of its seasoned beef filling.
    The fast food chain announced Tuesday it voluntarily recalled 2.3 million pounds of beef after customers reported fining metal shavings in their food.
  7. Former White House advisor on Russia, Fiona Hill, leaves Capitol Hill in Washington, Monday, Oct. 14, 2019, after testifying before congressional lawmakers as part of the House impeachment inquiry into President Donald Trump. MANUEL BALCE CENETA  |  AP
    The aide, Fiona Hill, testified for more than 10 hours on Monday as part of the Democrats’ impeachment probe into Trump’s dealings with Ukraine.
  8. In this photo taken from the Turkish side of the border between Turkey and Syria, in Ceylanpinar, Sanliurfa province, southeastern Turkey, smoke and dust billows from targets in Ras al-Ayn, Syria, caused by bombardment by Turkish forces, Tuesday, Oct. 15, 2019. Turkish artillery on Tuesday pounded suspected Syrian Kurdish positions near the town in northeast Syria amid reports that Kurdish fighters had retaken the town as Turkey pressed ahead with a military incursion that has drawn widespread condemnation. CAVIT OZGUL         |  AP
    Russia moved quickly to further entrench its role as a power broker after President Donald Trump ordered the pullout of American forces in northeastern Syria.
  9. Timothy Farmer is accused of intentionally driving his car into a New Port Richey house. Pasco Sheriff's Office
    Deputies said Timothy Farmer backed his Ford Explorer into the home, then resisted arrest.
  10. Judge Caryl E. Delano, chief judge of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the middle district of Florida Caryl E. Delano
    Caryl E. Delano will serve four years as chief judge of one of the nation’s busiest bankruptcy courts.