Advertisement
  1. News

Families of three St. Petersburg girls who drowned in pond plan to sue Pinellas County Sheriff's Office

Ciara Butler (left), mother of Ashaunti Butler, along with Kunde Mwamvita (center) (formerly know as Yeshica Clemmons), mother of Dominique Battle, and attorney Aaron T. O'Neal (right), before a press conference at the Pinellas County Justice Center in Clearwater on March 31, 2017. "We are going to fight, fight, fight," said Kunde Mwamvita.  "Fight for justice, until justice is served." On the one-year anniversary of when three girls drowned in a pond inside a stolen car, they announce they will  file an intent to sue notice that claims the sheriff's office was negligent in the the drownings.
Ciara Butler (left), mother of Ashaunti Butler, along with Kunde Mwamvita (center) (formerly know as Yeshica Clemmons), mother of Dominique Battle, and attorney Aaron T. O'Neal (right), before a press conference at the Pinellas County Justice Center in Clearwater on March 31, 2017. "We are going to fight, fight, fight," said Kunde Mwamvita. "Fight for justice, until justice is served." On the one-year anniversary of when three girls drowned in a pond inside a stolen car, they announce they will file an intent to sue notice that claims the sheriff's office was negligent in the the drownings.
Published Apr. 1, 2017

LARGO — One year after authorities said three teenage girls drove a stolen car into a cemetery pond and drowned, lawyers for their mothers announced that they still plan to sue the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office.

"We are going to fight, fight, fight," Kunde Mwamvita, the mother of Dominique Battle, said Friday, the one-year anniversary of her daughter's death. "Fight for justice, until justice is served."

The lawyers, Michele Whitfield and Aaron T. O'Neal, said the lawsuit will allege the Sheriff's Office is responsible for the wrongful deaths of the teens.

Dominique, 16, and Ashaunti Butler and Laniya Miller, both 15, died on March 31, 2016 when the gold Honda Accord they were driving plunged into a cemetery pond near Gandy Boulevard. The Sheriff's Office said they were fleeing deputies who had tried to pull them over.

READ: Three teenage girls dead after stolen car plunges into St. Petersburg pond

O'Neal and Whitfield on Friday released a copy of a notice of intent to sue dated that day, March 31. After receiving it, the sheriff will have six months to respond before a lawsuit can be officially filed.

Pinellas Sheriff Bob Gualtieri said there are no grounds for a lawsuit.

"If they had any factual or legal basis for a claim against us," the sheriff said, "they wouldn't have waited a year to bring it."

The lawyers said deputies chased the girls down a narrow road into the cemetery, then watched in the dark as the car sank below the surface of the pond, clotted with weeds.

"They corralled them into a dead zone," said Whitfield, who said she is representing the families of Ashaunti and Laniya.

Deputies, however, said they did not pursue the stolen car after it drove off at high speeds. The Sheriff's Office prohibits deputies from chasing vehicles unless they believe it to be linked to a violent felony.

The girls' deaths drew national scrutiny as people questioned whether deputies could have jumped into the pond to save them. Three of the first responders said they took off their uniforms and tried to wade into the water but turned back when they hit heavy muck.

A Sheriff's Office helicopter overhead that night was not equipped with a video camera. Several cruisers responded, but some were not equipped with dashboard cameras. The recordings that do exist show at least one deputy in wet clothes but not anyone entering or exiting the pond.

Over the past year, the Tampa Bay Times has reviewed all of the camera footage and read hundreds of pages of police reports and could not determine if deputies actually entered the pond or whether the girls could have been saved. None of the dashboard videos showed a high-speed pursuit took place.

O'Neal, who is representing Mwamvita, said deputies "didn't do anything to save the girls."

"If this was three white girls, they would have went into that pond," he said.

The sheriff said deputies should not need video footage to back-up their account of what happened.

"I maintain that nobody within the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office did anything wrong," Gualtieri said.

After the girls' deaths, the International People's Democratic Uhuru Movement rallied around the girls' mothers, particularly Mwamvita, formerly known as Yashica Clemmons. They organized many of her public appearances and were present at the news conference Friday outside the Pinellas County Justice Center.

Gualtieri said the effort is a publicity grab for the Uhurus' revolutionary platform.

"This is nothing but a bunch of self-serving rhetoric with a false narrative," he said. "They are grasping for straws for their own reason. And it's unfortunate that they use the anniversary of these three girls' deaths to promote their own anti-law enforcement interests."

The morning after the crash, the sheriff highlighted the three girls as an example of what he called a juvenile auto theft epidemic in Pinellas County that needed to be stopped. Between them, the girls had racked up seven grand theft auto arrests.

In the year since the girls died, teens continue to steal cars and drive recklessly across the region.

Mwamvita and Ciara Butler, mother of Ashaunti, remembered their daughters on Friday as free-spirited and happy, with full lives ahead of them. They clutched flowers, tears streaking their cheeks, on a narrow sidewalk filled with news cameras.

It has been a difficult year, Mwamvita said, without her daughter Dominique: "You shop for clothes for your other kids, but you can't buy anything for her."

Contact Zachary T. Sampson at zsampson@tampabay.com or (727) 893-8804. Follow @ZackSampson.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. social card for breaking news in crime, for web only
    The woman called a second man for help, who shot the man, according to authorities.
  2. The Stewart Detention Center is seen through the front gate, Friday, Nov. 15, 2019, in Lumpkin, Ga. The rural town is about 140 miles southwest of Atlanta and next to the Georgia-Alabama state line. The town’s 1,172 residents are outnumbered by the roughly 1,650 male detainees that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement said were being held in the detention center in late November. (AP Photo/David Goldman) [DAVID GOLDMAN  |  AP]
    The Associated Press sent journalists throughout the country to immigration court.
  3. Mike Bishop joins Pasco EDC staff. [Pasco EDC]
    News and notes on Pasco businesses
  4. Hernando County community news [Tara McCarty]
    News and notes on Hernando businesses
  5. Ed Turanchik is a lawyer and former Hillsborough County commissioner. [Times (2016)]
    Politico Ed Turanchik is warned for lobbying about the MacDill ferry after his status as a consultant ended.
  6. Jack Pearcy, left, and James Dailey, right, as they appeared when they each entered Florida's prison system in 1987. Both men were convicted of taking part in the murder of 14-year-old Shelly Boggio in Pinellas County. Pearcy got a life sentence. Dailey got the death penalty. Dailey's lawyers have argued that Pearcy is solely responsible for the crime. [Florida Department of Corrections]
    The case of James Dailey, facing a death sentence for the 1985 Pinellas County murder of a 14-year-old girl, is full of contradiction, ambiguity and doubt. Court records tell the terrible story.
  7. A new report to the Florida Legislature details the investigation that led to the forced resignations of six Moffitt Cancer Center employees in December, including president and CEO Dr. Alan List. [Moffitt Cancer Center]
    The money came from the “Thousand Talents Program” and went to personal accounts set up in China.
  8. Sydney Holton, left, and her friend Jordan Lewis yell for beads along the Gasparilla parade route on Saturday. [OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times]
    A week and a half after the boulevard’s latest high-profile traffic death, pedestrians got the whole road to themselves.
  9. The crash happened near St. Pete–Clearwater International Airport around 5:30 a.m. Saturday.
  10. Search is on for suspect, as police continue crash investigation and seek information.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement