1. News

Mothers of two St. Petersburg girls who drowned in stolen car drop out of lawsuit

Supporters display a sign during a 2017 candlelight vigil at the Campbell Park recreation center. A lawsuit lodged against law enforcement by the mothers of the three teenage girl saw a major shake-up when two of the mothers backed out of the case. ( DIRK SHADD | Times)
Published Nov. 23, 2018

A lawsuit lodged against law enforcement by the mothers of three teenage girls, who drowned after the stolen car they were driving plunged into a cemetery pond, saw a major shake-up when two of the mothers backed out of the case.

Ciara Butler and Natasha Winkler dismissed their claims last month, according to court records. The remaining mother appears to be pressing forward without a lawyer, seeking damages for what the complaint says were discriminatory and negligent actions that led to the deaths of Dominique Battle, 16, and Ashaunti Butler and LaNiya Miller, both 15.

The flurry of court filings show a tense back-and-forth between the plaintiffs, who were represented by Clearwater civil rights attorney Michele Rayner, and Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri. An in-house lawyer representing the sheriff requested sanctions against Rayner and her clients, writing in a motion that the lawsuit was frivolous and flew in the face of legal procedure.

"I've said all along that, No. 1, it's a very unfortunate and tragic situation," the sheriff said this week, "but despite that, we didn't do anything wrong ... and it is now clear and established through their own acknowledgements that they didn't have a basis for their accusations."

Rayner declined to comment, saying it would be "wholly inappropriate" for her to talk to a reporter while the suit is ongoing. Butler and Winkler, the mothers of Ashaunti and LaNiya, could not be reached for comment.

Yashica Clemmons, the mother of Dominique, could not be reached for comment after repeated attempts and a visit to her home, nor could a lawyer who represented her in the aftermath of the March 2016 crash. The lawyer, Aaron O'Neal, worked with Clemmons, who later adopted the name Kunde Mwamvita, through the International People's Democratic Uhuru Movement. The community group rallied around the families after the crash and contend police killed the girls because they were black.

The crash became a contentious flash point in a long line of deadly Pinellas car thefts perpetuated by teenagers. The Tampa Bay Times published a series about the epidemic last year that showed teens steal cars in Pinellas more than anywhere in the state.

Just this week, 18-year-old Damari Milton lost control of a stolen Mazda Miata and hit a tree at 38th Avenue N and 49th Street. The car burst into flames, killing Milton and his 16-year-old passenger, Dequante Lightsey.

The lawsuit, filed in June in federal court, claims that deputies chased the three girls into the cemetery, then didn't try to help them as the stolen Honda Accord disappeared into the muck. It goes on to allege the Sheriff's Office has repeatedly engaged in unconstitutional behavior and discriminatory actions due to a lack of training and discipline.

"The wrongful deaths … were directly and proximately caused by the failures, negligence, and carelessness of" the county and the sheriff, the lawsuit says, "because it produced or contributed to deputies' devaluation of African-American life in Pinellas County."

It calls for a jury trial, monetary damages and a court order prohibiting what it calls the county's "utilization of patrol techniques that demeans, disregards, or underserves its African-American population."

Gualtieri has continually denied any allegations that he or his agency did anything wrong. And in one filing, an attorney representing Gualtieri and a Pinellas sergeant also named as a defendant, took issue with the mechanics of the lawsuit. She wrote the case is a wrongful death suit disguised as a civil rights complaint to get around the expired statute of limitations. Florida has a two-year statute of limitations for wrongful death claims.

"Plaintiffs' counsel's choice, to file a frivolous complaint without basis in law or fact ... should not be tolerated by this Honorable Court," the attorney, Nicole Durkin, wrote in the Oct. 12 filing.

Winkler and Butler dismissed their claims two weeks later.

This case is not the first time Rayner and Gualtier have sparred. Rayner is representing the parents of Markeis McGlockton, a 28-year-old black man who was shot and killed this summer in a convenience store parking lot. Gualtieri didn't arrest the shooter, Michael Drejka, saying his agency was precluded by Florida's stand your ground law.

Rayner criticized the sheriff's decision and pressed for Drejka to be arrested. Prosecutors eventually charged him with manslaughter.

Last year, Rayner released a dashboard camera video appearing to show deputies beating a black man during an arrest. Gualtieri suspended both deputies after an internal investigation.

Also targeted in the lawsuit were St. Petersburg and its police chief, and Pinellas Park and its police department and police chief. A judge gave Clemmons until Nov. 30 to make her next moves. Clemmons said in several filings this month that she was seeking an attorney.

Contact Kathryn Varn at (727) 893-8913 or Follow @kathrynvarn.


  1. Check for the latest breaking news and developments.
    The shooting happened on the 5100 block of Matanzas Avenue, police said.
  2. Check for the latest breaking news and updates.
    Charges in the incident are pending, the Florida Highway Patrol said.
  3. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis talks to reporters in Tampa on Aug. 21. Delays in his filling vacancies on the state's five water management district boards have twice led to those agencies canceling meetings to levy taxes and set budgets, which one expert said was unprecedented. OCTAVIO JONES   |   TIMES  |  Times
    Vacancies lead to canceling two agencies’ budget meetings.
  4. Jessica Stoneking, Seven Springs Elementary School art teacher, and a group of kindergarten children enjoy a colorful floor rug during instruction time.  The rug is one of the many flexible seating options art students have in Stoneking's class. Gail Diederich
  5. President Donald Trump listens to music by military musicians during a State Dinner in the Rose Garden at the White House, Friday, Sept. 20, 2019, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon) AP
    Allies of Joe Biden, the early front-runner in the Democratic presidential primary, seized on the developments to portray him as the candidate Trump least wants to face next fall.
  6. Imam Askia Muhammad Aquil says religious leaders must be empathetic to the needs of families members of those who die by suicide. SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Attitudes have evolved with understanding about mental illness
  7. Rabbi Reb Tuviah (Paul Schreiber) is rarely seen without his guitar. He will sing at the upcoming Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur services at Temple Beth David in Spring Hill. Paul Schreiber
  8. Joshua Michael Nichols, 21, was arrested by Pasco County Sheriff's deputies on Saturday in connection to the early morning shooting death of an unidentified man during an argument outside a Spring Hill home. [Pasco County Sheriff's Office] ANASTASIA DAWSON  |  Pasco County Sheriff's Office
    One person is in custody. The Pasco County Sheriff’s Office is investigating.
  9. Yesterday• Pasco
    Dr. Rao Musunuru, MD, received his third “Paul Harris Award.” the highest recognition from the Rotary Club, on Aug. 15. The pin was presented to Dr. Musunuru, a nationally-recognized cardiologist, by Rotary 6950 District Governor Allen Collins in recognition of his humanitarian and philanthropic services to the people of Pasco County and the State of Florida for nearly 40 years. Pictured: Dr. Rao Musunuru, MD, (left) and Rotary 6950 District Governor Allen Collins. Jemith Rosa/Hudson Rotary Club
    News and notes about your neighbors
  10. A Lancaster County Sheriff's deputy walks around the Old Skool Sports Bar and Grill, the scene of a shooting early in the morning, north of Lancaster, S.C. on Saturday, Sept. 21, 2019.  Lancaster County Sherriff's Office said in a statement that the agency was investigating a fatal shooting that also injured several people.  (Jessica Holdman/The Post And Courier via AP) JESSICA HOLDMAN  |  AP
    Two adult males were shot and killed.