1. News

Romano: Dunedin Elementary case shows problem with Florida school grades

Published Jul. 25, 2014

One small problem with school grades:

They're a sham.

All of the money, all of the time, all of the kvetching surrounding Jeb Bush's school grading scheme is utterly worthless because the proper context is rarely considered.

What do I mean by that?

The single most predictive factor in a school's grade is the poverty level of the student body. You tell me how many students are eligible for the free/reduced lunch program, and I can usually tell you a school's grade.

For instance, since 2011 there have been 71 grades handed to Pinellas County schools that had 30 percent or less of the student body in the free lunch program. Those schools have had a combined grade point average of 3.84. Pretty darn good.

On the other hand, there have been 122 grades given to Pinellas schools that had a 70 percent or higher enrollment in the lunch program. The combined grade point average in those circumstances was 1.62. Pretty darn bad.

All of the schools in between? A 2.97 GPA. Pretty average.

I'm no statistician, but I believe that's called a trend.

We can argue the reasons why wealth plays such a large role, but we cannot deny its impact. Any bar graph of school grades would show a perfectly symmetrical line beginning with schools in rich neighborhoods and trending relentlessly lower as you travel down the economic ladder.

And yet the blockheads we send to Tallahassee refuse to acknowledge this.

Instead of working on real solutions for the economic/education gap, legislators have declared war on the principals and teachers unfortunate enough to work at high poverty schools.

If students score low enough on standardized tests, it triggers a mandatory turnaround program that can lead to employee upheaval.

Which brings us to Dunedin Elementary.

This was once a highly regarded school with the test scores to prove it. Back in 2005, Dunedin scored a coveted A in the state grading system. At the time, its free/reduced lunch rate was 53 percent. As that rate increased to 59, 62, 63 and then 67 percent, Dunedin clung to a B grade. By 2010, the rate was up to 78 percent and Dunedin dropped to a C. By 2012, it was 83 and the school was down to a D.

In 2013, the school fell to an F and was destined for turnaround status.

So the principal was demoted and more than a dozen teachers were jettisoned. Pinellas superintendent Mike Grego says the F grade required him to begin a turnaround process, but he said many other factors contributed to the staffing changes.

"It's not all about a single letter grade,'' Grego said. "It's how things are moving forward, and the leadership dynamics. It's my job to look at the best interests of the school, and what can be done to move it back to being an outstanding performer.''

Grego likened it to a struggling baseball team that changes managers simply to provide a new voice.

With that in mind, he made his decision before the 2013-14 school grades were released. It would be disastrous, he said, to wait until summer to make widespread changes.

Editor's note: This column has been edited to remove an incorrect number found in state records. It is estimated that 83 percent of students at Dunedin Elementary in the 2013-14 school year were from low-income families that qualified for free and reduced-price lunches. An incorrect percentage initially was reported.


  1. An American Airlines Boeing 737 Max 8 aircraft approaches Miami International Airport for landing in March. Bloomberg
    The 60-year-old veteran airline employee told investigators he was upset that union contract negotiations had stalled.
  2. Maurice A. Ferré at his Miami home earlier this year. JOSE A. IGLESIAS  |  Miami Herald
    He served as mayor for 12 years and set the stage for Miami to become an international city.
  3. Lilly Beth Rodriguez, left, Laura Robertson and Linda Lamont work on a Habitat for Humanity house in north Pasco. [Times (2013)]
    The increase is expected to happen in the first half of next year. CEO hopes other nonprofits follow suit.
  4. Terry Spencer carries his daughter, Trinity, through high water on 59th Street near Stewart Road in Galveston, Texas, Wednesday, Sept. 18, 2019, as heavy rain from Tropical Depression Imelda caused street flooding on the island. JENNIFER REYNOLDS  |  AP
    Although the amount of predicted rainfall is massive — forecasters say some places could see 40 inches or more this week.
  5. This April 2001 photo, which appeared in a newsletter from the West Point Grey Academy, shows a costumed Justin Trudeau, his face and hands darkened by makeup, attending an "Arabian Nights" gala. The academy is a private school in Vancouver, B.C., where Trudeau worked as a teacher before entering politics. (West Point Grey Academy/The Canadian Press via AP)
    A few Southern politicians responded to similar scandals recently with denials, apologies, and promises. Most of them have managed to stay in office.
  6. The number of single-family homes sold in the Tampa Bay area during August rose 2.8 percent when compared with the same month last year, according to a monthly report from Florida Realtors. (Times file photo)
    The midpoint price in the bay area rose to $250,000, which is still lower than the state and national median prices.
  7. This April 14, 2019 file photo shows a western meadowlark in the Rocky Mountain Arsenal National Wildlife Refuge in Commerce City, Colo. According to a study released on Thursday, Sept. 19, 2019, North America’s skies are lonelier and quieter as nearly 3 billion fewer wild birds soar in the air than in 1970. Some of the most common and recognizable birds are taking the biggest hits, even though they are not near disappearing yet. The population of eastern meadowlarks has shriveled by more than three-quarters with the western meadowlark nearly as hard hit. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski) DAVID ZALUBOWSKI  |  AP
    “People need to pay attention to the birds around them because they are slowly disappearing,” said the study’s lead author.
  8. Michael Robert-Jose Harbaugh has pleaded guilty in the 2017 slaying of Safety Harbor neighbor David Sommer, a former reporter. Harbaugh also pleaded guilty to a charge he tried to have a witness in the case killed. [Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]
    Michael Harbaugh, 42, also pleaded guilty to trying to have a fellow inmate kill a witness in the murder case.
  9. Rep. Susan Valdes, D-Tampa, during a Feb. 7, 2019, meeting of the House PreK-12 Appropriations subcommittee. [The Florida Channel]
    ‘One test should not determine the rest of your life,’ Rep. Susan Valdes says.
  10. The Aldi store located on 1551 34th St N, St. Petersburg, Florida in 2018, features its updated layout. JONES, OCTAVIO   |  Tampa Bay Times
    The store will re-open after renovations on Thursday, Sept. 26