1. News

Federal judge tells Pinellas judge to back off in Scientology lawsuit

Published Sep. 29, 2010

TAMPA — A federal judge has ordered a Pinellas judge and the Church of Scientology to halt their efforts to severely punish Ken Dandar, a Tampa lawyer who is taking the church to court for the second time in his career.

The action Tuesday by U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday involves Pinellas Judge Robert Beach, who has said he intends to impose a $130,000 fine on Dandar and possibly suspend his license to practice law.

The reason: Dandar allegedly reneged on a legal promise never to challenge the church again after he sued Scientology and won a settlement in the 1995 death of Lisa McPherson.

But in a stinging 29-page order, Merryday questioned the "stunning severity" of the fine and said Beach overstepped his authority. He "permanently enjoined" Beach, the church or anyone else from pursuing the matter, saying they couldn't even hold another hearing on it.

The order frees Dandar to continue representing the estate of Kyle T. Brennan in a federal wrongful death lawsuit against the church's Clearwater entity, the Flag Service Organization. The lawsuit contends that Brennan's apparent suicide was the result of improper actions by his Scientologist father and two other church members. It alleges the father, Thomas Brennan, hid his son's antidepression prescription with the help and advice of Denise Gentile, the sister of Scientology's worldwide leader David Miscavige. A trial is scheduled for December.

The unusual situation puts two noted local judges at odds.

Beach could not be reached Tuesday for comment, but has said he believes that only a state appeals court, not a federal judge, can overturn his decisions regarding Dandar. It was unclear whether a Friday scheduled hearing before Beach will take place as planned.

Scientology lawyer F. Wallace Pope entered a courthouse conference room after Tuesday's hearing to discuss the result with church officials and other lawyers. He could not be reached later for comment.

Said Dandar: "I'm just very happy I can now concentrate on getting to trial." He said the prospect of having to pay a large fine and quit practicing law had been "a huge elephant" weighing on him and his family. He told Merryday he would have to file for bankruptcy if Beach's penalties were imposed.

The dispute began when Dandar sued the church in February 2009. Four months later, the church argued that Dandar's representation violated the terms of its 2004 settlement with the family of McPherson, the 36-year-old Scientologist who died after 17 days in the care of Scientology staffers in Clearwater.

The church contends the McPherson settlement barred Dandar from taking part in any future legal action against Scientology. Dandar strongly disagrees.

Beach sided with the church and ordered Dandar to petition Merryday to remove himself from the Brennan case. Dandar did so, but went before Merryday grudgingly, saying he was under duress. He argued that his client had tried to find other lawyers to replace him, but that no one else wanted to take on Scientology, a claim the church disputes.

Merryday declined to release Dandar from the case, which prompted Beach to react with the fine and other potential sanctions earlier this month.

In his order Tuesday, Merryday said Beach forced his hand.

On one hand, he said, there was Dandar facing the "calamitous consequences" imposed by Beach. On the other was Brennan's family, whose chances of continuing their case would suffer if he allowed Dandar to be released.

He said that if Beach's wishes were allowed to stand, the Brennan family would be harmed from a case they had nothing to do with and a settlement agreement they had no part in.

He said his only course was to "act in defense of the (federal) court's jurisdiction" over the cases before it.

Referring to Beach, he wrote: "A judge should not undertake, directly or indirectly, overtly or through a surrogate, to compel an act by another judge, especially in a different jurisdiction."


  1. Authorities found 29-year-old Sharee Bradley stabbed to death on Aug. 5. The chief says she had three children; the 12-year-old and 3-year-old were found safe, but Nevaeh had disappeared. Sumter Police Department/Facebook
    DNA from the remains found Friday has been matched to Nevaeh Adams, Sumter Police Chief Russell Roark told reporters.
  2. Cars back up at a Tampa intersection last October, not long before Hillsborough County voters approved a one-cent sales tax for transportation improvements. This week, local officials detailed how the money would be spent, if the tax survives a legal challenge before the Florida Supreme Court. URSO, CHRIS  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Local governments have plans for $527 million in projects. But the Florida Supreme Court would need to clear the way.
  3. FILE - In this Sunday, April 22, 2018, file photo, a statue of a chained man is on display at the National Memorial for Peace and Justice, a new memorial to honor thousands of people killed in racist lynchings, in Montgomery, Ala. Facing an impeachment inquiry that he and supporters claim is illegal, President Donald Trump tweeted Tuesday, Oct. 22, 2019, that the process is a lynching. Some Republicans agree, but the relatives of actual lynching victims don’t. BRYNN ANDERSON  |  AP
    Made in a tweet that drew backing from some Republican supporters including Sen. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, Trump’s claim was ill-informed at best and racist at worst, they said.
  4. Check for the latest breaking news and updates. Tampa Bay Times
    Damien Wiggins Jr. was found with a gunshot wound in the parking lot of a vacant business on Haines Road.
  5. FILE - In this Aug. 15, 2018 file photo, Florida school shooting suspect Nikolas Cruz listens during a status check on his case at the Broward County Courthouse in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. As his death penalty trial draws closer, a hearing is set for school shooting defendant Cruz in the 2018 massacre that killed 17 people. The hearing Wednesday, Oct. 23, 2019, likely concerns the setting of timelines leading up to the planned January trial of the 21-year-old Cruz. AMY BETH BENNETT  |  AP
    The hearing Wednesday likely concerns the setting of timelines leading up to the planned January trial of the 21-year-old Cruz.
  6. FILE - This undated file photo released by the FBI shows 3-year-old Kamille McKinney, who police say has been missing since she was abducted while attending a birthday party on Saturday, Oct. 12, 2019, in Birmingham, Ala. Investigators searching through garbage found the body of McKinney, who was missing more than a week, and authorities are charging two people with murder, police said Tuesday, Oct. 22. AP
    The child, known as “Cupcake” to relatives, vanished while outside a birthday party on Oct. 12. Investigators know of no link between the suspects and the girl or her family, police say.
  7. An aerial view as police forensic officers attend the scene after a truck was found to contain a large number of dead bodies, in Thurock, South England, early Wednesday Oct. 23, 2019. Police in southeastern England said that 39 people were found dead Wednesday inside a truck container believed to have come from Bulgaria. UK POOL  |  AP
    “We are in the process of identifying the victims, however, I anticipate that this could be a lengthy process," Essex Police Chief Superintendent Andrew Mariner said.
  8. A top U.S. diplomat, William Taylor, departs the Capitol after testifying in the Democrats' impeachment investigation of President Donald Trump, in Washington, Tuesday, Oct. 22, 2019. J. SCOTT APPLEWHITE  |  AP
    Democrats said they were shocked and disturbed by what they heard. A look at the key takeaways from Taylor’s statement, which was obtained by The Associated Press.
  9. A Florida black bear (not this one) was found at a Marion County school and removed. CARLTON WARD JR  |  Carlton Ward Jr
    A roundup of stories from around the state.
  10. Weeki Wachee Springs main entrance VAUGHN HUGHES  |  Tampa Bay Times
    From its iconic mermaids to its signature statue, Weeki Wachee Springs will be considered for historic designation.